>We're remodeling the church kitchen, and we need a table or actually an island that looks like a table and to serve as a prep table. The cabinet tops are going to be granite or silestone. Neither one of those surfaces are friendly to knives. We figure that just like many women do at home, the cutting will take place on the table top not on a cutting board. So....
What kind of table top would you recommend...laminated maple, oak or some other?
Also especially what type of finish would you recommend?
>Danny, I'm sure you'll get any number of responses to this question that may help with your decision. Unless you made a top that was totally laminated end grain wood (surface is end grain), your top would likely be made from face grain wood. The only problem I have is that cut marks and scratches would show over time and I don't think most people would find that desirable or attractive.
If it were mine to do, I think I would use either hard maple or beech for the top because of their close grain structure. To provide a surface for cutting, while also maintaining a fresh appearance when not in use, I would make a "cutout" or insert. Make the insert while making the top so the wood laminations match and it will look better. The insert can rest on strips applied across the bottom of each corner and can be pushed up from below to flip for use. One side gets cut, and hopefully the other doesn't. Either way, when time comes, it would be easier to resurface a removable surface than the whole thing.
As for finish, I think you'll want the protection polyurethane affords for this top. I wouldn't apply as much to the cutting surface whether you use the entire top to cut on or use the idea for a type of insert. The best way I've found is to use a couple thinned coats on the work surface, allow time for penetration, wipe away any excess each time, and allow adequate drying time between coats. You don't want to build a film on the surface in this case. All you want is enough of the finish in the wood to seal the pores and keep moisture and bacteria from getting in.
>Think carefully about using a wooden top for a table of that type. Wood will be very easily damaged by the slightest use of knives or chopping implements. In addition, you may have problems with your health department if you are subject to health inspections. Wood is just not a good idea.
As for a finish treatment, you don't want to use any type of film finish. Knives will cut right through it and allow water and food juice to get below the finish. Once that happens, the finish will quickly fail. While it won't hurt folks, flaked off varnish or other finish is certainly not "good eats" as Alton would say.
In the shop I was involved with, when we couldn't talk a client out of wood countertops we would use a wax/mineral oil treatment consisting of a mixture of mineral oil and either paraffin or beeswax. This is what is used on many commercial wood surfaces. It will last longer and be more protective than just mineral oil. Mineral oil can be found in most supermarkets in the pharmacy section or in a true pharmacy. Paraffin is found in the canning section of the store or in a hardware store.
Heat the oil in a double boiler and shave in some wax. The exact proportions are not critical--a 5-6 parts of oil to one part of wax will work fine. Stir the mixture until all the wax is liquefied. Apply the mixture heavily and let it set 10-12 hours or overnight. Next day do it again and continue until the wood will no long absorb the finish. Let it set for 10-12 hours and then lightly scrape off any excess. Then buff it with a rag.
Reapply whenever the wood begins to look dry.
Finally, let me again ask that you carefully consider what you want to do.
Hard Maple tops made by John Boos and company in Effingham , Illinois
are a good answer to your project.
Their tops are treated with a penetrating proprietary finish that is approved for commercial food preperation use by the State of California and is the only wood countertop manufacturer to my knowledge that has that distinction.
I used their product many dozens of times in CA while I was in business out there and I installed one here in Kansas on our own kitchen remodel recently.
Since my wife is nit picky, she had me make a couple of small cutting boards with handles out of the same top material that I planed down to 7/8ths inch in thickness,laid out the cutting board shape on a bias and wound up makeing about a dozen of them for her friends and daughters.
If a snapshot of this would be helpful, let me know and I will send you one of the countertop and cutting board.
Another note about Maple countertops was the result of a study on bacteria growth on different counter surface materials and it was found that Hard Maple actually retarded the growth of bacteria commonly found in and around food preperation areas.
Fred, I have read the results of the bacteria study on different cutting board materials. The Boos butcher block top looks like a winner. Thanks for your expertise. A couple photos would be nice and very much appreciated.