Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

Belt Sander ? Which one?

Posts

Belt Sander ? Which one?

#1

Belt Sander ? Which one?

ken raddon

>Hello everyone, I really enjoy this site but mostly just lurk. I am a hobbiest and not a very good one at that.

I just have a need for a belt sander and don't want to buy the wrong one because as much as I use it I will have it for life. They range all the way from $69 and up, way up. Any help deciding which one would be appreciated.

Like is 4 inches too big for most/some small jobs? Is smaller better if I don't do anything bigger than a doll house?

Ken Raddon.

Re: Belt Sander ? Which one?

#2

Re: Belt Sander ? Which one?

Kneale Brownson Dreaming of the Snow in N. MI

>I had a couple of three-inch belt sanders and was always leery of using them because they wanted to tip and cut grooves with the edge of the belt unless I was extremely careful, which is hard for a clumsy old fart to be.

My solution was the four-incher I got maybe 20 years ago. I've worn out a switch, a couple sets of brushes and one platen on my PC four-inch, and probably only made three or four gouges in all those years.

Re: Belt Sander ? Which one?

#3

Re: Belt Sander

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Can highly rec the Ryobi 3x21vs inline which is patterned on the Bosch. Benefit is that Ryobi makes a sanding frame for their 321 that makes the machine both stable and precise when doing larger areas; no digs and easy to control, even on the edges.

mm

Re: Belt Sander ? Which one?

#4

Re: Belt Sander ? Which one?

del schisler

>I have the Porter Cable 362 4"x24" Belt Sander with Dust Pickup This is wisper quite Not to loud Works very well It is heavy tho It will take off some wood And also have the Porter-Cable 352VS 8 Amp 3-Inch by 21-Inch Variable Speed Belt Sander This is noisey I use ear potection on this one It works very well The belt I don't have any problum's with mine Just have to adjust with a new belt Than it should track fine And keep it flat Just watch sales At the box stores I bought the Porter Cable 362 4"x24" Belt Sander new in the box for $80.00 They were closing it out couldn't belive the price They only had 1 left I grab it right a way The Porter-Cable 352VS 8 Amp 3-Inch by 21-Inch Variable Speed Belt Sander I got it at a good price also Don't remember Look around I don't use the 4" much but the price i couldn't leve it thanks for reading del

Re: Belt Sander ? Which one?

#5

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Belt Sander ? Which one?

Jesper, Denmark

>Smaller is better. 4" are heavy monsters.

Re: Belt Sander ? Which one?

#6

Re: Belt Sander ? Which one?

Ralph Turney

>I also have the Porter Cable 362 4"x24" Belt Sander with Dust Pickup and used it all the time for the first few years, but I really don't look forward to taking that beast out anymore. I'm finding other ways to remove lots of stock, like using planes...about the same amount of sweat equity, but you can use planes and not get get covered in sweaty dust, and you also have to put up with all that noise. If I had to do it again, I would pick up a small one.

Re: Belt Sander ? Which one?

#7

Re: Belt Sander ? Which one?

ken raddon

>Good advice. I will go with the 3 inch.

Thanks for the thoughts/input.

Ken Raddon.

Re: Belt Sander ? Which one?

#8

Re: Belt Sander ? Which one?

Barry Irby

>I also have the 4x24 Porter Cable. I use it most of the time turned upside down in a rack I made for it. The belt is horizontal. Considering fixing the rack so I can tip it up and use it vertically and adding a fence or table.

I have never had a smaller one. The weight of the larger ones can be an advantage. It's about the right amount of weight for the surface area. Tech sander does the work.

I do not use it nearly as much as I once did. My Random Orbital Sander (A five inch PC 333) is so effective, it does most of what the belt sander used to do and much more. If you don't have a ROS you might want to buy one first. It's one of my favorite "new" tools.