Wide-belt Sander
Jim Tusant
>I am considering a Steel City 15"/30" wide-belt sander. Does anyone have first-hand knowledge of this sander or do you have any first- hand preferences of another wide-belt sander?
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Wide-belt Sander
Jim Tusant
>I am considering a Steel City 15"/30" wide-belt sander. Does anyone have first-hand knowledge of this sander or do you have any first- hand preferences of another wide-belt sander?
Re: Wide-belt Sander
Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn
>I'm considering one of the Jet 22-44 models. A friend has one and uses it a lot. His experience has been all positive, so I'll probably opt fot the high end "Pro" model. Something I like about it is the single pass capacity that will handle the common 19" wide dresser/bureau top and sides.
Clint
Re: Wide-belt Sander
Jim Tusant
>Clint, is the Jet a drum sander or a wide-belt. I am not familar with that particular model?
Apples and Oranges
Neal in San Jose
>The Steel City machine is a wide belt not a drum sander. 3 hp and weighs almost 400 pounds. Not comparable to the drum sanders.
Re: Wide-belt Sander
Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn
>It's a drum. I read your post too quickly. Though I haven't evaluated belt sanders, any advantage they have over a drum isn't obvious to me.
Clint
Re: What.!!!!! No platen!!!!
Rick L
>I wouldn't get a widebelt without a platen. Otherwise you have a glorified drum snader not a true widebelt. The platen allows you to send the piece right to finishing or you must random orbit sand to remove drum marks if you don't have the platen.
Any reason you couldn't use a stroke sander. Having spent many years in the Industry, the stroke sander is a superior tool for general sanding applications in a small shop, professional or amateur. Takes a bit more space but you can go right to finishing off the machine. Much more versatile than a widebelt sander.
Couple of advantages
Neal in San Jose
>First, POWER! The two units we are talking about are 3 HP for the Belt and something like 1/2 HP for the Drum. I have the Delta Drum, and it isn't hard to stall it. As long as I remember that I can't hog material off, it works fine. I'm guessing the Steel City unit would remove stock several times as fast.
Second, oscillation. The belt is powered back and forth as the stock moves thru so that glue lines, etc, don't clog a narrow part of the belt and cause a burn line. I get around this on my drum by feeding at an angle, but there are obvious limits to this work-around.
Third, length. The sanding belt is much longer than a drum, so any pitch pockets, glue lines, etc that you might encounter should be sanded away before the same part of the sandpaper comes back around again. You should be able to get better sandpaper life this way.
Forth, change-over. I haven't used the Steel City unit, but I have helped change belts on a 54 inch TimeSaver, and it took less than 30 seconds to pull out a belt and slide on a new one. I'm pretty fast on my Delta, but it still takes 90 seconds to 2 minutes for me to change the sandpaper strip on the drum.
Neal (lusting after the drum sander, in case you hadn't figured that out by now)
Re: Wide-belt Sander
Paul Woolson
>I've looked into these machines VERY carefully. Right now I've got a General dual drum. It works fine on most domestic woods but I use almost exclusively exotic woods with a lot of resins (all varieties of Rosewoods, Zircote, Cocobolo, etc) and they clog a drums very quickly.
Grizzly makes one that I had my eye on but it takes a ton of air to oscillate the belt. Steel city's takes no air. I'm pretty sure I'll get one soon.
Re: What.!!!!! No platen!!!!
Paul Waddle
>I agree,the stroke sander is a wonderful machine,probably not as easy to use as a wide belt sander,but is so versitile-from picture frames to table tops. I think you also need a wide belt sander ifn you can afford it-5k and up AND a dust remove system is a must... JMHO,pw
Re: Couple of advantages
Jim Tusant
>Neal, you are right on target. I havaen't used the Steel City either. I was looking for someone who may have used it. It is 3 HP too and has excellent features assuming they all work as advertised. Thanks for your response.