Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

Cucumber tree

Posts

Cucumber tree

#1

Cucumber tree

Randy Johnson

>I am reading a book, Strangers in High Places, about the history of the Great Smokey Mountains.

In the chapter about the logging that was being done prior to the establishment of the Park, the cucumber tree is mentioned as one of the highly valued hardwoods. I have heard of the cucumber tree because there used to be one in a rural cemetery here in Fayette County. Nonetheless, I was surprised to read that it had major commercial value. It�s a member of the magnolia family and I would have thought the wood would be similar to tulip poplar/yellow poplar/tulip tree.

Has anyone here ever used the wood from a cucumber tree or seen something made from it? I�m really curious, because the book ranks it with walnut and cherry as a desirable hardwood.

By the way, if you are a person who goes to the Smokies as opposed to going to Gatlinburg or Pigeon Forge I can�t recommend this book enough. It�s a very good read.

Re: Cucumber tree

#2

Dale Lenz

Re: Cucumber tree

Dale Lenz

>Have only seen a few in AR during the early part of my forestry career, they were growing in the shade, IMMSMC. I have a fireplace mantel out of holly. A friend wanted one, could not find any holly at that time, nor can I now, unless I buy commercial, which I very rarely do if any. My research said to use cucumber or magnolia lumber in place of holly, those two tree are not native around here so that was out of the question, also. I have always assumed cucumber wood is white in color, similar to holly, at least the sapwood.

Re: Cucumber tree

#3

baloney

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>When I read something like that in a book it calls into question the rest of the information.

Once sawed it is mixed in with poplar ( or at least used to be when I had more direct mill experience), so it is as valuable as poplar, at least in the commercial market. What little I have seen tends to be more dense than poplar. The logs are typically smaller than poplar. I have never seen a large tree, but I suppose it can get to be fair size under good conditions. While not rare it is one of the less common trees one encounters. If I haven't seen one in a while I am usually puzzled for a bit when I encounter one as it has an unusual bark. It does have a nice bloom and an unmistakable leaf. .

Re: Cucumber tree

#4

Re: baloney

Fred Davis

>Google the cucumber Tree, a lot of interesting information, like it's flowers ae pollinated by beetles.

FredD

Re: Cucumber tree

#5

Re: Cucumber tree

Ron in Drums PA

>There is a pretty big cucumber tree not to far from me.

I can't wrap my arms around it and touch my fingers.

The bright red seed pods where what first caught my attention.

Re: Cucumber tree

#6

Re: baloney

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>No offense Bill, but I think you are unfairly criticizing the author of the book, Michael Frome. It's been some years since I've read it, but as I recall it was obvious that he'd done his research on the history of these mountains.

I just looked up the reference that was posted and the author is discussing the lumber markets of the 1880's and 1890's. I'm willing to accept the idea that the wood from mature cucumber trees was valued as a fine cabinet wood in that era. Younger, immature trees today? Probably not fine cabinet wood.

Gary

Re: Cucumber tree

#7

Re: Cucumber tree

Mike Hamilton

>No clue about cabinet work, but my dad always swore it was the best wood for the portion of an ox yoke that sits on the neck and shoulders. Said it was very strong and at the same time light. He always kept the bent hickory portions of a yoke he used growing up in WVa but never found cucumber wood to make a new one - we all have projects we'll never get to, I guess.

Regards,

Mike

Re: Cucumber tree

#8

where is it now?

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>If the wood was as valuable as walnut and cherry then valuable things would have been made from it. Seen any high end antiques made from it? Lots of things made from walnut and cherry available from that era.

Re: Cucumber tree

#9

Re: where is it now?

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>Bill - some interesting facts from a government site. Somewhat agrees with what you said. But it does say that furniture was made from it in the early 1900's. Per the info on this site, it is now sold as yellow poplar and has not been sold as Cucumbertree lumber since 1928. Link -

http://www.na.fs.fed.us/spfo/pubs/silvics_manual/volume_2/magnolia/accuminata.htm

Re: Cucumber tree

#10

Re: where is it now?

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>It's entirely possible that you are correct, Bill. I have no way to argue your point since I have no background in the history of either the lumber or the furniture industries at the turn of the century.

It just seemed to me to be a little unfair to dismiss the value of a 340 page history of the Smokies because you didn't agree with the one statement that was mentioned. By the way, the book does have a 22 page bibliography so I have to believe the author did a little research before he wrote it.

I guess it's only fair to admit that I have always thought highly of this particular book, though it's been the better part of 30 years since the last time I read it.

I'll go back to my room now. 8^]

Gary

Re: Cucumber tree

#11

We used to have a big one!

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>On my grandmother's farm, there was a huge cucumber tree we used to climb. We called it a pickle tree because the cucumbers when we saw them in the summer were the size of the sweet gerkin type pickles. They were great for throwing at your little brother & sister who hadn't mastered tree climbing....or so I've been told.....

Lee

Re: Cucumber tree

#12

Re: where is it now?

John K Jordan

>>...things would have been made from it

I don't remember reading that it was as valuable as walnut and cherry for furniture, but you answered yourself when you mentioned it was mixed with y.poplar. One of my references indicates that since the wood is "marketed along with that of yellow-poplar, it is difficult to be certain which is which unless you harvest it yourself." While less common than y.poplar, it was still widely used in framing for upholstered and veneered furniture (under walnut and cherry no doubt) so it may well be inside many antiques.

Also used for plywood core, toys, woodenware, baskets, wall paneling, trim, woodturnings (reported to be better than y.poplar), carvings, boxes and crates.

JKJ

Re: Cucumber tree

#13

are we talking about Cucumber Magnolia?

Tom Sontag - St. Louis

>Is this the Magnolia acuminata we are talking about? I know the tree can get large, but we sure don't see many around here.

Re: Cucumber tree

#14

Re: are we talking about Cucumber Magnolia?

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>That's the one, I think, Tom. According to the Forest Products Lab, it is commonly known as Cucumber Tree and is one of three commercial species of Magnolia.

Gary