Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

OT Hydrogen

Posts

OT Hydrogen

#1

OT Hydrogen

Sawman

>Yesterday I was talking to an excavator who was fussing with a fuel cell this weekend. Apparently he has looked into this idea of making hdrogen and then connecting it to a vaccum line on his vehicle.

So is there anything to this? Is it for real? Have any of you guys played with this?

Thanks

Re: OT Hydrogen

#2

JL

Re: OT Hydrogen *LINK*

JL

>Fuel cell technology works quite well. But most automobiles aren't quite set-up for it.

Storing liquid hydrogen is difficult at best. You need a nice insulated tank and you have all the problems with boil-off. Storing high pressure hydrogen is somewhat easier, but you still need a storage device or tank.

You then have to convert your engine to run on hydrogen - which is NOT the same as gasoline, propane or natural gas. Can it be done? Sure. My old company paid to have a propane powered forklift converted to run off of a hydrogen fuel cell. It worked quite nicely - just the thing to run inside a warehouse. Which is why it was done.

I think you may find that the expense of the conversion (and the expense of buying the pressurized hydrogen) to be cost prohibitive - even if it is somewhat environmentally correct.


DOE Fuel cell site

Re: OT Hydrogen

#3

Ill-advised alternative . . .

steve mackay

>A long ago (read : pre-lawsuits and political correctness) Boy Scout project involved water, lye and tin foil mixed in a pop bottle. Wonder if this could be applied to a auto and mixed in the tank. No, no, just kidding ! Fuel cell tech is crazy cool but, as stated above, not really ready for the street OR Joe Six-pack.

Re: OT Hydrogen

#4

Re: OT Hydrogen

John McGaw

>Your excavator is either wildly misinformed or is pulling your leg. What you describe is in no way a "fuel cell". What it is is electrolysis of water which produces hydrogen and oxygen. That is all well and good -- the hydrogen will indeed burn as rocket folks have known for decades. But if the tinkerer is throwing away the oxygen he is missing a great opportunity since hydrogen and oxygen burn even better than hydrogen and air.

But the point is, a fuel cell makes electricity and is very difficult to do correctly (otherwise you'd see them everywhere and used for everything). Burning is not fuel cell technology. As for efficiency, unless some absolutely free source of electricity for this electrolysis is available more energy will go into the process than can ever come out. If he does his electrolysis using a vehicle electrical system then he is just burning fuel in the engine to make electricity to make fuel and unless the laws of thermodynamics have been revoked he is digging himself deeper and deeper into a hole.

Re: OT Hydrogen

#5

Re: OT Hydrogen

Tony - Memphis

>There has been a lot of interest in Brown's Gas or Hydroxy stirred up recently with the skyrocketing fuel costs. supposedly, some folks have figured out how to build an HHO generator that operates off of your 12v vehicle source. I read oon one site that they draw 20amps. I've been wondering what the net was. People are claiming anywhere from 20%-60% fuel savings. I'm not 100% convinced, but its interesting to read. These folks produce the gas and plumb the generator into the air intake line (most late model cars have plastic air boxes that contain the filter).

Tony

Re: OT Hydrogen

#6

Re: OT Hydrogen

Bob Persing

>Please recall that hydrogen is extremely flammable (think about the Hindenburg) and with the correct mixture of air, is explosive. Generating and piping hydrogen around the inside of a motor vehicle sounds like a death wish to me. If someone were a careful, knowledgeable researcher, it does sound like a fun project to try and squeeze out a few more MPG from existing technology.

Play it safe.

BobP

Re: OT Hydrogen

#7

Cars that run on Hydrogen

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>There is an entire highway system being developed for Norway to develop a hydrogen corridor between Stavanger and Oslo. Mazda even has a hydrogen powered car for the system. The roadway is supposed to be operational by 2009! Even so it is a professionally designed car, not a backyard modification.

Lee

Re: OT Hydrogen

#8

Re: OT Hydrogen

Jerry Nicholson

>They tried that one on Mythbusters. They built the widget according to the plans but couldn't generate enough hydrogen to do anything. Then they tried aiming a hose from bottled hydrogen at the carb. They didn't quite blow themselves up that way but they got a couple of great flashbacks. There are a lot of people trying to sell magic on the internet but this is nothing new - I read that Henry Ford paid a guy $10,000 for the rights to a pill that converted water to gasoline. Like old PT said, "a sucker born every minute, an another to take him".

Jerry

Re: OT Hydrogen

#9

Re: OT Hydrogen

Hank Knight

>IMHO, hydrogen is the answer to the world's insatiable energy appetite and carbon-related pollution forever. Hydrogen is the most abundant substance (element) in the universe and it is found everywhere. Translating it into energy is a clean process - heat and water are the by products. There are tough engineering probelms associated with making it commercially available on a large scale. Bob pinpointed two of the most troublesome: it's difficult to "pipe in" and it's explosive (which is, of course, why it's a great fuel). The plumbing problem is a real bugaboo. The hydrogen atom is the smallest atom. It can sneak through the smallest opening and many materials are too porous to contain it - think of a child's helium balloon on day 2: the helium has escaped through the tiny pours in the rubber balloon and the balloon is barely floating, if at all. The helium atom is roughly twice as big as the hydrogen atom so the problem with containing hydrogen is greater and the consequences of failing to contain it range from loss of fuel to explosions. All of these problems have already been solved in small scale applications, but we are years behind in getting the solutions translated into our infrastucture. When we do, though, we can kiss oil and carbon pollution goodbye forever and enjoy boundless, clean energy. Won't that be nice?

Re: OT Hydrogen

#10

Re: OT Hydrogen

Jerry Nicholson

>How do you propose to efficiently generate the hydrogen?

Jerry

Re: OT Hydrogen

#11

Re: OT Hydrogen

Paul Leuba

>Hydrogen is best viewed not as an energy source, or fuel, but as a medium in which energy is stored. The reason for this is that hydrogen does not exist in naturally in its pure form for very long. It is too reactive, and joins with other elements to form compounds, such as, water, acids and bases. Pure hydrogen must be generated in some way by inputing energy, electric current for example, and a compound containing hydrogen, such as, water, natural gas, etc., into a process that strips the hydrogen atoms from the compound and stores them for later use.

The later use can be in a fuel cell or as fuel in a combustion engine with air, where the hydrogen reacts with other elements to form water in the case of a fuel cell, or combustion byproducts in the case of a combustion engine.

There are multiple large problems with transitioning to a hydrogen fuel for our transportation system. The first of which is the rather poor energy efficiency of generating hydrogen. It is generally more efficient to just use the original fuel in the transportation vehicle than generate hydrogen for use in the vehicle. In addition to a poor efficiency curve, there are substantial problems involved with the distribution and storage of large quantities of hydrogen, or the generation and storage of hydrogen on site at filling stations.

It just makes much more sense to base our future transportation needs on plug in electric vehicles with small backup fossile fuel engines for longer distances. Electricity is much easier to generate, move and store than hydrogen. The real work needs to be done on developing batteries appropriate for this purpose, and it is beginning. GM is far along with the Volt vehicle that adopts this model. It is scheduled for first sales in the 2010 model year.

Paul in Hunt Valley, MD

Re: OT Hydrogen

#12

Re: OT Hydrogen

Chuck in ND

>Well thats great if you can afford a estimated $47,000 electric vehicle built by GM. And like batteries in a rechargeable drill, how long will they last ? and what would it cost to replace them ? $40,000 ? I can see alot of junked cars in the future.

Re: OT Hydrogen

#13

Commercially Available Hydrogen Car *LINK*

Jim Dillon

>Sawman,

Not an answer to your question, but saw this in the news this morning.

Jim


Honda Hydrogen Car

Re: OT Hydrogen

#14

Sorry, I responded to...

Jim Dillon

>... the post below regarding hydrogen and ended up with a separate posting - or so it appears. My apologies to all and please put an OT in front of the post. Computers ggrrrr....

Jim

Re: OT Hydrogen

#15

Re: Sorry, I responded to...

larry in kansas

>I remember about two months ago some guy in Toledo, Ohio, about 70 miles North of me, made an addition to his motor, a contraption that some of you were talking about. He had it all under his hood, and had it hooked to his intake and his electrical system. It "apparently" made hydrygon and feed it to his intake. A local TV station did a story on it. They clamed it worked and gave him something like 35 MPG. He said it would cost anyone around $800 to convert any car, and he gauranteed it or your money back. I wonder if he`s still doing it. I wish it really did work if it didn`t. I believe it`s going to be someone like him, a back yard tinkerer that`s going to invent a new fuel. Larry in Ohio, temporary in Florida