>Finished gluing up the MDF prototype of the cradle I'm making. I'm pretty happy with the proportions, height, and it holds the cradle matress snug to the sides. Any comments or suggestions before I start cutting the QSWO? Just picked up the wood today! It passes all safety codes that I could find for USA and Canada, and more importantly Hunter approves of it. He's the clever looking fellow in the picture inspecting the prototype. Modifications to the final version will include the corners joined with a lock miter bit, all other joinery M&T, and cocobolo inlays on the front center panels.
It looks like it might lack racking strength - ie if you push on an end, will it be strong enough to keep the legs from folding sideways?
I'd consider moving the stretchers up to the mid-height-point of the legs, and doubling the height of the stretcher boards.
It should look great in QSWO.
My only other comment is that the new owners will love that cradle for the first six months but, if I were the recipient, I would curse it for the next 18 years until my children were old enough to have their own kids. The problem is that bassinets only get used for six months, then need to be stored somewhere for 18 years.
>Thought of that, didn't like the look. That was one of the reasons of building the prototype though. You have to rock the cradle so far over to tip the center of balance past the tip of the rocker, that the baby would be in trouble whether the cradle tipped or not. Several of the antiques I looked at did not include this design, and there was nothing in the safety codes that I found.
Thanks for the suggestion though. Hunter went through a bit of a rollercoaster ride with all the test-rocking I put the cradle through. Even with some really heavy pushes, he stayed safe, and the cradle remained standing.
>Firstly, the new owners will be my wife and I. #1 is coming along early November. As far as the cradle needing to be stored for 18 years... well, I would like to have at least 5 more after this one, wife willing, so it shouldn't need to be stored too long before being needed again.
Both the racking issue, and the ability to knock down the cradle were related though. If I figured in the hardware and design to be able to break it down, it ended up looking too bulky to me. I like the look of the leg supports now, but I still have worries. I tried increasing the the width of the stretchers, but again, didn't like the look. I can't really move the stretchers up without putting the through mortises through the weakest part of the legs. As it is right now, MDF butt jointed with brads and glue, I can push very hard on the sides with very little movement. In the final version the legs will have 1 1/4" tenons top and bottom, but the legs will only be 1/2" thick. I feel like I'm dancing on the line of "dainty" look and solid enough construction. Perhaps another set of stretchers just below the bed rails... or maybe with as strong as oak is, it will be sound enough... hmmmmm... maybe if I make the current stretchers attach point wider, and then put a curve on the bottom to keep the look of them light... that will be consistent with the rest of the design. I guess I'll have to sleep on it... no, not the cradle.
Couple more thoughts on engineering and aesthetics
Ellis Walentine
>...the ability to knock down the cradle... If I figured in the hardware and design to be able to break it down, it ended up looking too bulky to me.
Design is all about compromise. If you really want a knockdown cradle, it's up to you to figure out how to do it without the bulk that offends you visually. Personally, I can see how you might make the base separate from the cradle itself, utilizing a couple top rails that would connect the opposite legs and support the underside of the bed rails. That, to me would be an improvement over having the legs just mortised into the bottom of the lower end rails of the cradle.
...I tried increasing the the width of the stretchers, but again, didn't like the look. I can't really move the stretchers up without putting the through mortises through the weakest part of the legs. As it is right now, MDF butt jointed with brads and glue, I can push very hard on the sides with very little movement. In the final version the legs will have 1 1/4" tenons top and bottom, but the legs will only be 1/2" thick. I feel like I'm dancing on the line of "dainty" look and solid enough construction. Perhaps another set of stretchers just below the bed rails... or maybe with as strong as oak is, it will be sound enough... hmmmmm... maybe if I make the current stretchers attach point wider, and then put a curve on the bottom to keep the look of them light... that will be consistent with the rest of the design. I guess I'll have to sleep on it... no, not the cradle.
I think you have the germ of a real improvement here. As I mentioned in another design-related post recently, the height of the shoulder is what lends rack resistance to the assembly. The only requirement for the section modulus (W x H) of the rail itself is that it be stiff enough not to deflect. Since they are not carrying any load, they can be fairly light, although I would resist making any structural components of this cradle thinner than, say, 5/8". You could improve on the rigidity of the lower assembly by putting a couple cross stretchers between the two long ones at some pleasing location in the middle of the long stretchers. If you use tusk tenons or some other knockdown device where the long stretchers go through the legs, you could make the whole lower assembly demountable.
A few aesthetic points: Yes, a bottom curve on the lower stretchers would look good. Also, I would resist having the outer faces of the legs in the same plane with the ends of the cradle. I'd set them in at least a little bit, to create a shadow line where the cradle spans the leg assemblies. And, I'd consider making the legs thicker than 1/2" as suggested above, and increasing the height of the lower stretchers as well as curving their lower (or upper) edges. They seem a bit dwarfed by the thickness of the cradle rails above. Finally, if you slope the sides and ends of the cradle in a bit more, I think it would add some visual excitement to the design.
All this is easy for me to say. If any of it resonates, use it. You deserve a lot of credit for making a mockup. This is exactly what these are good for, but to make them really work, you need to know how to react to what you've mocked up. These are only my reactions. You're entitled to the last word on everything.
Best,
Ellis Walentine, Host
PS Congrats on #1 of 6. My #1 was 35 years ago and I'd do it over again in a heartbeat.
>As Ellis has addressed the leg aesthetics and his take on leg thickness, I won't even go there :).
A thought or two - have you considered beefing up the top end rails? In case you want to attach mobiles or something? If the end rails were thicker, you could more easily drill holes.
>This is very nice. Listen to Ellis' suggestions, and the others.
I would suggest that you test it with a better prototype than Hunter. (He's a fine fellow and will welcome his new sibling, but he's a light weight.) Use something that more nearly matches the weight of a baby. Say a ten pound bag of sugar. Or a five pound bag and some canned goods. Do a worst case scenario. Snuggle them up to one side and give it a good shove. Just to check it out. Be safe.
Might lower the whole thing a bit. Consider how tall your wife is and whether she will be able to put the baby in without lifting too high. Just a thought.
I too am skeptical of the racking resistance. I would consider some sort of angle brackets under the bottom. I also like the idea of angling the sides and recessing the base at the ends. The knock down idea was a good one.
Wood Craft had a kit that included some turned spindles if you are interested.
I made a doll's cradle recently. Will post a picture and you can use any ideas it might add to your own.
>These are an attractive project but they seem to me to be impractical. I don't see much that one can do with a cradle after the short time a baby uses it. Then one is left burdened with a piece of single-tasker furniture too valuable to pitch, yet of not much further use. Indeed, a piece of furniture that is not used in a small house becomes a burden.
Seems to me it would be better to build a kid a desk or single bed, or even a dresser with secret compartments, or a toy chest that could evolve into a trunk. Such an heirloom would be more useful, and long term, appreciated.
>Ken, I too agree with Ellis and the others in designing your cradle.
Years ago I made four cradles from a design I got from www.furnituredesigns.com and still have one here for my granddaughter to use for her first child. I made them out of walnut and they are much like the picture that Barry posted.
Re: Couple more thoughts on engineering and aesthe
Kenneth E. Bellock
>Thanks for all the comments Ellis, I really like several of them, and am now revisiting the idea of moving the legs in, and making it able to be broken down. I want to make sure I put enough time into design, but I also have to be careful not to tweak, and tweak, and tweak, and then be done by the time she's two...
I have talked to my parents too about this, some of the ideas I incorporated into my design came from an antique they store in their attic. It breaks down into two sections, top and bottom, but my parents say storage wise that doesn't really help. It just made it easier for them to move it around. If the legs and stretchers could break down and store in the top part of the cradle it would be more helpful I think.
One of my own personal influences on my designs reflects my appreciation for solid pieces of furniture. Meaning, the less hardware/screws/metal in a design, the more I generally like it. That is why the first draft of my design as shown here ended up the way it is. I'm glad I made the prototype and took the time to mull over it though. I think I will spend a few more days trying to work up a design where I can break everything down and place it in the top part of the cradle, and still be happy with the aesthetics.
Thanks again for all your comments, I'll keep posting as it comes along,
>I bought plans for and built a crib that converts to a child's bed and then to a single bed. It should be usable until she is at least 12 years old. You will need to go to July 2006 in the archives, then scroll down to July 6, 2006.
>You must be from a small family. In my family - I had 3 sisters and 1 brother that raised families. I raised 6 children (his hers & ours). Their is certainly no lack of need for a cradle. I didn't build it as I was working 3 jobs at the time it was needed, but I purchased a good quality baby bed for our youngest. It wasn't in storage as it went to good use for at least 5 babies - ours and nieces and nephews before it was destroyed by one niece that didn't fasten it to a trailer properly when moving. Sadly it was needed by some of our older children after that.
>My granddaughter and here husband are planning on having their first child next year. I told here today I would make their crib. I had already made four swinging cribs years ago when my kids were young for their children to have for their kids.
My plans come from www.woodonline.com....the 3 in 1 bed. It is first a baby crib, then converts to a childs bed, and finally converts to a full size adult bed.
>The thought of drilling holes into this when it's done makes me cringe... My wife's parents will be supplying us with a crib, I think we'll mount any hanging dodads from that.
>I gave it a good round with weights ranging from 5-15lbs. The rocking action is good, and even with the heaviest weight to one side, you have to give it a pretty violent throw to get it to go over. The height is perfect, it must appear larger in the picture than it actually is. It stands 32" high, and it is a very comfortable hight for my wife to stand next to and rock it.
It has been tormenting me all weekend though... I would really like to be able to break it down... Designing is as much fun to me as building it, but I recognize that I have a lot to learn. Very glad I made the prototype!
>If I get my way, we'll be using it for many years. As far as useless/impractical furniture goes, I already have that all over the house. Bowls filled with sea shells and marbles... towels you aren't supposed to use... Once I decided to live with a woman I had to just give up on any practical use of available space. When I asked my wife what she would like for our first baby, she said a cradle. I pushed the 3in1 crib for a while because I thought it made the most sense, but this is what she really wanted. Now I just want to make sure it is something that she will love and something that will last for many generations.