Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

Router Templet Disaster

Posts

Router Templet Disaster

#1

Router Templet Disaster

JohnM in Mid Mich

>I can't seem to get my templet guides to stay put on my router. Just now the templet unscrewed in use, destroying itself and the bit (see the pic). What is the trick here? With a knurled ring, and no way to strongly grip the other piece, it seems to be designed for finger tightening. But clearly finger tight, even to the max I'm capable of, doesn't work - it just vibrates itself off. Porter-Cable 690 with PC brand templets.


img

Re: Router Templet Disaster

#2

Re: Router Templet Disaster

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>I use the Freud brass template bushings and have not noticed that problem with mine. It sounds like the threads may be too loose so that the vibration allows them to loosen. Try applying some finger nail polish to the threads of the knurled ring. Try a couple of dabs in the threads to increase the friction. This will make them not "spin on", but then they won't vibrate off either.

Lee

Re: Router Templet Disaster

#3

Dale Lenz

Re: Also...

Dale Lenz

>try a different router bit. Could be your bit is out of balance(?. Let us know what you tried/found out.

Re: Router Templet Disaster

#4

Same router, same template, same disaster

Neal in San Jose

>I had that same thing happen to me. I now use a skinny pair of slip-jaw pliars to tighten the knurled ring, and the problem hasn't happened again.

Re: Router Templet Disaster

#5

Brass is the answer.

Rod Peterson -- Ormond Beach

>I learned that from Bob Rosendahl in an early episode of The Router Workshop. It's been discussed here before (by me). Bob said that finger tight with brass works fine and it won't vibrate loose. I remember the thread because my good friend, Dave Arbuckle, had an insight into brass' characteristics which explained it, but sadly, I can't remember what it was. I just know it works.

Rod

Re: Router Templet Disaster

#6

Re: Router Templet Disaster

Mike in Savannah

>Another fix would be to put an O ring between the nut and the plate.

Re: Router Templet Disaster

#7

Re: Brass

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Brass is a softer allow and steel and as such, a brass-on-brass joint has a higher value of mechanical friction. You can hand-tighten a brass joint that will later take a wrench to get apart.

Re: Router Templet Disaster

#8

Re: Brass is the answer. Vote #3

Rob Stokes in North Vancouver

>I had a set of the "steel" templates and they consistently came loose. In fact, they're a safety hazard and should be banished.

I too purchased a brass set and have not had a problem since.

Rob

Re: Router Templet Disaster

#9

Re: Brass is the answer. Vote #3

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Afternoon Rod,

Lots of people I knew in the military had trouble with brass.

George

Re: Router Templet Disaster

#10

Thanks, and thoughts...

JohnM in Mid Mich

>OK. So I'll have to get a new bit and some brass templets. But here is the thing. These aren't some knockoffs, they are the Porter Cable branded templet guides! I'm not used to concluding that this otherwise reputable manufacturer would sell an accessory that is not only non functional, but dangerous and destructive! I guess I should call their customer service and register my complaint.

John

Re: Router Templet Disaster

#11

Re: Trouble

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Mostly when walking.

Re: Router Templet Disaster

#12

Usually only some

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>It was only ever the top brass that people had trouble with. Good thing my strips were gold and my eagles silver!

Lee

Re: Router Templet Disaster

#13

Re: Long As You're Registering,

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Sign up for the free Lamborghini to be given to the customer with the best complaint. Time to get creative!!!

[psssst ... not]

Re: Router Templet Disaster

#14

Re: Long As You're Registering,

Nelson

>Simple way to correct problem with brass or steel ones, use a pair of channel locks and lock it down good and no more problems.

Re: Router Templet Disaster

#15

Lee Gordon

Re: Router Templet Disaster

Lee Gordon

>What about using a few drops of Loctite 222 on the threads?

Re: Router Templet Disaster

#16

Re: Thanks, and thoughts...

Dick Coers

>Porter-Cable has probably been selling them in steel for 50+ years.

Re: Router Templet Disaster

#17

Re: 50 yrs

John in Mid Mich

>Yeah, that is why I'm so surprised to find them defective. Is it possible that I (and a few others, apparently) got a batch that is somehow out of tolerance?

Re: Router Templet Disaster

#18

Threads

GolfSteve in Calgary

>I had one brass template guide fall off, wrecking the guide, the router bit, and a pair of underwear.

I noticed that the replacement guide I bought had different threads than the old guide (one was bought at Home Depot, the others were bought at Lee Valley). Both were brass.

One had coarse threads and the other had fine threads. I forget now which one failed, but the replacements have never fallen off.

Perhaps it has something to do with the choice of fine or coarse threads by the manufacturer?

Re: Router Templet Disaster

#19

Lee Gordon

Re: Threads

Lee Gordon

>"I forget now which one failed, but the replacements have never fallen off."

It must have been the Home Depot one. If that one failed you would have brought it back to the store, explain to the guy in the orange apron what it was and why you needed a new one.

If it had been the one from Lee Valley, they would have apologized profusely, sent you a new one (their expense for the shipping), and offered to pay the laundry expense for your underwear. You would have remembered.

Re: Router Templet Disaster

#20

Re: Threads

GolfSteve in Calgary

>Unfortunately I have an in-bred aversion to taking things back to stores unless the situation is very clear-cut. I hate dealing with people in situations of potential conflict. One of my shortcomings. It's also one reason why I love dealing with Lee Valley, because I almost certainly will get good service.

I put the incident down to either a) not tightening the nut enough (ie. perhaps my fault), or b) the design was faulty and the alternate design is better (I have no way to know).

Therefore, since this incident was possibly my fault I never took the failed bushing back to the store. In any case, the failure occured well after any warranty period.

Cheers,

Pushover Steve