Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

Shop humidity ?

Posts

Shop humidity ?

#1

Shop humidity ?

Chuck in ND

>I'm asking this because a guy that makes guitars bought a used dehumidifier from me and brought it back because it ices up, well it worked fine when I had it. He claims he likes the humidity in his shop to be around 40%, but doesn't keep the temperature in the shop constant, he lets it swing from 55 to 70, so he says. I think it's going lower. I find it rather odd that someone worried about wood movement worries about humidity but doesn't care about temperature other that working conditions. On the back of the humidifier it says, if the coils are showing frost or are iceing up, the temperature and or humidity is too low and to shut it off until conditions are corrected.

Re: Shop humidity ?

#2

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Actually, either......

Jesper, Denmark

>The shop temperature is too low or the fan is not moving enough air across the coil.

The second is most likely.

Re: Shop humidity ?

#3

Lee Grindinger

In real terms..., *LINK*

Lee Grindinger

>In real terms the difference between 70 degree air with 40% RH and 55 degree air with 40% is one tenth of one percent EMC (Equilibrium Moisture Content)

It's not much.

However, for the dehumidifier to work the coils need to be warmer.

Back when I was building reproductions of Walter forte piano cases I kept a small wood storage area well controlled into which all the materials would go at night. Piecing together a solid spruce cabinet to exact size was impossible without this control. Your friend is correct to assume control over his humidity thus EMC.

Lee


EMC Chart

Re: Shop humidity ?

#4

Lee Grindinger

In real terms..., again

Lee Grindinger

>To add to my potentially confusing and irrelevant first post in terms of absolute humidity, temperature and relative humidity...,

70 Degree air at 40% relative humidity lowered to 55 degrees would only raise the relative humidity a single percent or slightly less.

Your friend could run the dehumidifier only when the shop temperature is around 70.

Re: Shop humidity ?

#5

Jesper, Denmark

Re:Lee, check your psychrometric chart.....

Jesper, Denmark

>70 degrees at 40% RH, lowered to 55 degrees gives you close to 70% RH.

Re: Shop humidity ?

#6

Lee Grindinger

Yup, you're right,

Lee Grindinger

>Thanks for setting the record straight,

Re: Shop humidity ?

#7

The Bottom Line

Tom MacGregor

>He's asking the dehumidifier to do something that it can't do. There is probably nothing "wrong" with it at all. My workplace runs a half dozen $1400.00 commercial dehumidifiers, and although they don't ice up often, they can if conditions are just right. They have built in defrost thermostats that shut off the compressor but keep the fan running if they freeze up. I've never seen a small residential unit that can run non-stop without icing.

Re: Shop humidity ?

#8

Re: The Bottom Line

Tony - Memphis

>I have a small one in my shop that has never iced before. Now, I only run it in the summer and I keep the shop temp around 76� when I'm not in there. Maybe that's why! Mine has developed a stubborness though....it sometimes will turn on and just run until its full. If you slap the top of the unit, it will shut off. May be time for some new parts or a new unit. Parts are expensive though and the unit is almost ten years old. I'd rather fix it than toss it on the curb. My problem is that my ac unit is too big. I use it as my heat source too (resistance, not a heat pump) and they don't offer small ones with heat. So, the thing runs very infrequently and it gets way too humid in the shop. I forget how big the new unit is, but unit the builder installed was a ton I think and my shop is only 16x20. We have the same problem with the house - 2300 sq ft on paper and a 5 ton unit.

Tis the season again...we are within a degree or two of hi temp records here. Brutal out there. Not too humid yet though, so I merely passed out while cutting the grass as opposed to actually dying!

Tony - 87�/60% in my neighborhood at the moment

Re: Shop humidity ?

#9

Not quite ...

Larry Marker

>Whirlpool makes a line of residential class dehumidifiers marketed to be suitable for low temperature basement use.

I had a "regular" Whirlpool unit in my basement and had loads of icing problems. I bought a low temperature basement model from Lowes several years ago and it works just fine. It's rated to 55 degress, but my basement never goes below 60, so I don't know if it will handle 55 or not. It has never iced up at 60.

They now have one they advertise as being good down to 35 deg. I can't vouch for whether it can do that or not.

Larry