Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

Which biscuit joiner

Posts

Which biscuit joiner

#1

Which biscuit joiner

Dan Mitchell

>I'm in the market for a biscuit/plate joiner. Does anyone have a particular model to suggest?

Thanks

Dan

Re: Which biscuit joiner

#2

JL

Re: Which biscuit joiner *LINK*

JL

>I like my Makita 3901 except that it doesn't do 00 biscuits. Here is a link to Fine Homebuilding's tool guide.


FHB Biscuit joiners

Re: Which biscuit joiner

#3

Re: Which biscuit joiner

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>Are you sure you need one? I have one and I haven't used it in years. But then again I haven't made face frames in years.

Tom

Re: Which biscuit joiner

#4

Re: Which biscuit joiner

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Afternoon Dan,

I used my DeWalt this afternoon for the first time in several months. It is a good machine. I bought my #3 son a Porter+Cable which arguably has greater capabilities. The vast majority of my biscuit joints do not require a fancy fence, so had I to buy another, I would avoid the more expensive models with all the bells and whistles. They are over-hyped, nice to have, but not essential to my eternal salvation.

George

Re: Which biscuit joiner

#5

Louie Lovas

Re: Which biscuit joiner

Louie Lovas

>I've own the Porter Cable Biscuit Joiner for about 8 years, a great machine. I've a big fan of biscuit joinery, I use it for all sort of joints - alignment of edge joints, re-enforcing miters, etc. As for whether the PC is better than any of the other brands, I don't have a strong opinion, but I have no regrets on my decision to buy a PC.

Re: Which biscuit joiner

#6

Re: Which biscuit joiner

David Hay @ Denver

>I happen to have a DeWalt biscuit joiner that I got several years ago. I would probably say that, unless you intend to use it day in and day out, there's no reason to spend big bucks on a biscuit joiner. It's a pretty simple machine and just about any of the major brands are likely to be good. If it comes with a fancy fence, great. However, I find I usually reference off the bottom of the machine and don't use the fence all that much. But then, I don't often use it with anything other than 3/4" stock.

I'm glad I have one. However, it's one of those tools that I use infrequently enough that I wouldn't buy the "best" (read, most expensive ;)

Hope that helps!

David

Re: Which biscuit joiner

#7

Re: Which biscuit joiner

Ken Bellock (Houston, TX)

>I also have the dewalt, and have had it a few years now. Like many of the others that have posted so far, I agree that it's a tool that mostly just collects dust on the shelf now. When I have used it, I have not found it lacking in features or performance over the more expensive varieties. I picked it up new for $100 with a rebate, but even at that price, I don't think I would buy it again if mine were to go out. Now, if I could only find another use for the 1000 biscuts I've got sitting on the shelf next to it in zip lock bags...

Re: Which biscuit joiner

#8

Now that I've got most of the "cutting" machines..

Dan Mitchell

>I keep going back & forth on which "joining" tools to get. Plate joiner? Mortising machine?? Pocket screw jig??? The last one's fairly cheap (~$40 for the 2 hole Kreg) the other 2, about $200 or slightly more, and in both cases, lots of people say they only use theirs rarely!

But Norm uses both of his all the time!!! ;-)

I'm new at this, and am only just now starting to make things. In fact, I'm on my 1st "real project", a small, basic end table. I need to join the skirt sections to the legs. Making the tenons on the table saw is no problem, the mortises are another matter. So I thought pocket screws, no tenons. But it seems pocket screws work best on joints where both bits are the same thickness (like a frame, unlike a leg + skirt section) & can be clamped together firmly to drive the screw. So I thought biscuits might work there, plus be useful for table tops (I glued up the small top, aligning one this size was pretty easy, but on a larger one it seems getting all the boards even could be a real task). On this table, I'll probably just make a basic router mortising jig, like in Bill Hylton's "Power tool joinery" book.

But I still keep wondering if one or more of these other tools would be a worthwhile addition...

Thanks again everyone for the insights.

Dan

Re: Which biscuit joiner

#9

Ken...

Dan Mitchell

>Might you be interested in selling your DeWalt & biscuits?

Dan

Re: Which biscuit joiner

#10

Re: Which biscuit joiner

Will Abbott

>I have a PC and I am very happy with it

Re: Which biscuit joiner

#11

Re: Now that I've got most of the "cutting" machin

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Evening Dan,

It all depends on the situation which will dictate the primary tool I use. After years of woodworking, I now have a biscuit joiner, Kreg jig for pocket hole joinery, a nice doweling jig, and a Shop Fox morticing machine+tenoning jig for the table saw. Remember, you can always drill a series of holes and clean them up with a chisel to make mortices. And, you can make a tenoning jig from scrap. The tenon cheeks cover any raggety mortice edges. They may not be perfect, but they will be strong enough to last years and years. You can always take out another mortgage and get a Festool domino. Keep it simple and inexpensive to start, and see where it leads you. Rome wasn't built in a day.

George

Re: Which biscuit joiner

#12

JL

Re: Now that I've got most of the "cutting" machin

JL

>I use my biscuit joiner for joining face frames to cabinet bases. I don't have a pocket hole jig :). I also use my biscuit joiner for aligning long pieces of wood for glue ups (more than 24") and when I am gluing up multiple pieces at one time.

I do find it useful.

Re: Which biscuit joiner

#13

Re: Now that I've got most of the "cutting" machin

Kneale Brownson Dreaming of the Snow in N. MI

>Add to the Col's list of hole makers a plunge router. Probably a much more useful tool than the biscuit hole cutter. Easy to make the proper tennon joints you should use to attach the skirts of a table to the legs.

I have a stationary plate jointer and a hand-held. Used to use both quite regularly. Now I mostly use the hand-held to make slots for the Z-clips I use to fasten tabletops to table skirts.

Re: Which biscuit joiner

#14

Re: Which biscuit joiner

James Clair

>I use a DeWalt jointer and really like the way it is built. I have found that it is very easy to use and stores very well. I do have one question. What biscuit size would be the "M" setting?

Re: Which biscuit joiner

#15

Re: Which biscuit joiner

Jim Dillon

>Dan,

Another vote for the Dewalt. I've had mine for maybe 6 years and have used it quite a bit. Never had a problem. For mortises, I built Bill Hylton's mortise jig and have used that a LOT in combination with a plunge router. I have a Delta mortising machine that I am embarrassed to say I have never used, but I couldn't resist a great sale 8-). And I DID just mortgage my house and got a Domino that I plan to use on a small table I'm building. Life is short and one can't have too many tools, right?

Jim

Re: Which biscuit joiner

#16

Re: Ken...

Ken Bellock (Houston, TX)

>Thanks for the offer, but I think I'll hold on to her. Like everything else I get rid of, it seems, I'll never need it till it's not sitting on the shelf anymore.

Re: Which biscuit joiner

#17

Re: Which biscuit joiner

Phil Thien

>Another vote for the Makita. It is the poor man's Lamello (maybe with an even better fence than the Lamello).

I use mine quite a bit.

The PC is the only unit that will do FF biscuits (for frace frames). I bought a router bit from Whiteside that does biscuit slots and cut my face frame slots on the router table. Works great and fast, too. I can do eight slots (two in each corner) for a face frame in about two minutes at my router table. I do it all with the fence in a single position.

Re: Which biscuit joiner

#18

Ellis Walentine

A bit of perspective *LINK*

Ellis Walentine

>Hi Dan,

I think that one of the first things you should get a handle on is the engineering that goes into joinery. In the case of an end table, biscuits and pocket screws are inappropriate methods of joining the rails to the legs. You have to design for the worst case scenario, e.g., someone knocks over the table or it falls off your truck, or Uncle Festus stumbles into it. Screws and biscuits won't have the rigidity or holding power to resist these forces of leverage, and the leg/rail joint(s) are likely to fail.

Mortise and tenon joinery is the way to go. Ideally, you want to engineer the tenon to be as large as possible (while still having shoulders all around) and to penetrate the leg as far as possible. This adds incredible strength to the joint. The function of the glue in this type of joint is merely to keep the tenon from pulling out, which keeps the all-important shoulders in contact with the leg, which multiplies the joint's resistance to leverage forces. The taller the rail, the longer the side shoulders of the tenon will be and the more resistance it will provide to racking. This is why the long rails of a workbench are made very tall, because it is critical that the bench not be able to rack in the lengthwise direction (or crosswise, for that matter).

Hope this helps.

Ellis Walentine, Host

PS I don't recommend using biscuits to align panel glue-ups. It's more work and expense than necessary, and if the biscuits are too close to the show surface, their swelling can distort the wood above them. If you sand it down flush, subsequent shrinking will contract the wood, leaving a depression there, which will be visible when the finished panel is viewed in oblique light.

Biscuits are great for some alignment chores, such as building box posts from four 1x6s. A glue-up like that is a nightmare without some way of keeping things aligned.

As far as biscuit joiners are concerned, the Lamello is the gold standard. The DeWalt is pretty rough, but it has a dandy rack-and-pinion fence-raising mechanism and is a good performer. I like my Porter-Cable, too, as it has a much more versatile fence and an auxiliary blade for the small FF-size biscuits, which are great for narrow face frames and picture frames. The Porter-Cable's fence lets you biscuit joint mitered plywood panels, one of the biscuit joiner's excellent abilities.

If you would like to read an article about biscuit joiners that I wrote several years ago, click the link below. They've shortened the article quite a bit and aren't showing the pictures or charts, but there should be a lot of relevant information for you.

Ellis


img

Biscuit Joiner Review

Re: Which biscuit joiner

#19

Climbing on a soapbox for a minute.

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>Dan,

This is not directed at you, or anyone else in the thread. I have a biscuit joiner. I haven't used it in probably 4-5 years and in that time I have built a vast amount of work of all sorts. Would I sell my joiner? Like others, no. Sure as shootin' if I sold it I'd suddenly have a need for it.

So I think biscuit joiners, Domino etc. have some uses, especially in production work. So call me "Old School" but I think that for many circumstances biscuit joiners are either unecessary or a poor shortcut for traditional methods of joinery.

In the past, Norm taught building panels with biscuits. But really, biscuits are not needed. And IMHO they can actually just make the panel process more difficult. Good square butt joints with proper glue works very well.

And while biscuits can work in lieu of mortise and tenons I feel that in most cases it is a lesser substitute. Not only is traditional joinery usually better, structurally, but I feel it gives the work you are doing more integrity. In addition, going the extra mile to do the traditional joinery methods, for me, adds greater satisfaction.

This is not a condemnation of biscuit joinery. It's just a different point of view.

Off the soapbox now. :-)

Tom

Re: Which biscuit joiner

#20

I agree with Tom Skaggs.

Garrett in Victoria

>Mine's been gathering dust for a very long time. When I make face frames, I use pocket screws that are faster and stronger, and when I need to make butt joints where both sides are visible, I use a dowelling jig.

Cheers, Garrett

Re: Which biscuit joiner

#21

Re: Climbing on a soapbox for a minute.

Jay St. Peter - Southern, MD

>I used to use mine way more when I first started than I do now. However, it still has it's place. When I want to bang together a shop cabinet or some other form of utility storage in the garage/shed/basement, it's the quickest way I know of putting together some plywood into a cabinet carcase. It may not be the best/strongest, but far stronger than pieces of melamine screwed together (which happens to work in a lot of cases).

OTOH, for real furniture projects, I rarely use it anymore ... but I did.

The thought of using mortise and tennon joinery is daunting when you first start. And, it is time consuming for a while. But, with practice it becomes something you don't give a second though to doing.

Before climbing on a soapbox about things like biscuits and pocket holes (good inexpensive clamps), I think back to how I started. I think I spent about 1.5 years making stuff before I even bought chisels, much less a hand saw, plane, or even a rasp. Now, I assume I'll use my shoulder plane to trim my tennons to fit before I even start making them.

I think there are lots of basic things to learn early on. Until you learn to ensure the wood is flat and cut square and not to measure each part, it sort of doesn't matter what joinery you use. The biscuit short cut isn't so bad, and he'll get over it ;). It's definitely not on my "tools I wish I had never bought" list.

BTW, I have a DW. It's OK. I'd consider it the minimum acceptable, but it is acceptable.

Jay

Re: Which biscuit joiner

#22

Re: There's different types of work, Tommy

Glenn Madsen, SF Bay Area

>And for fine furniture, I agree with you completely. Mortise and tenon makes a lot of sense. And the work feels authentic, like the grandkids will respect it in 50 years.

But when I'm building a kitchen for the house their parents are renting, out of prefinished plywood and soft maple, I want these things to go together, quickly, sturdily and square. I really would rather get some gardening, or golf, or work on the master bath, than fuss with mortise and tenon cabinet doors on Saturday.

I've never owned a belt sander, but when one of my sons brought one by the other day, I had a number of projects spring to mind that could use this thing.

I don't use the LN chisels for carpentry. But there is a lot of carpentry to be done, it seems.

Oh, and I have a DeWalt plate joiner. Works for me.

Wish I could spend some more time on the sweet stuff. I love to see Tommy's.

Re: Which biscuit joiner

#23

Re: There's different types of work, Tommy

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>Glenn,

Thanks for the compliment. Much appreciated! I agree with you. Plate joiners are not worthless. They have useful applications, especially with cabinets (I.E. face frames etc.) and for MDF work etc.

Like some others have said, eventually many of us find out that plate joinery is not the final joinery frontier. However, as you also see, those who have transitioned to other joinery methods aren't giving up their plate joiners. We all know they can be handy for some forms of work, as you have very well indicated.

Thanks for adding some good points!

Tommy

Re: Which biscuit joiner

#24

Re: Now that I've got most of the "cutting" machin

Dan Mitchell

>Thanks everyone for the very helpful relies & links. I do have a tenoning jig & cut the tenons on the TS. I ended up making a dedicated router jig out of some scrap to enable me to quickly & accurately cut the mortises. This is a small table, top is only about 12" square, so while I do agree mortises & tenons are the strongest option, my guess is pocket screws or biscuits would have also sufficed for most any strain this application would likely be put to (ok, Falling Fat Festus not withstanding... ;-) I had not heard of the case of a swelling biscuit producing a lump on a panel glue-up. This sounds very plausible, and could particularly be an issue when using a thin-veneered sheet material where sanding ability is limited.

Dan