Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

Gummy finish, what happened?

Posts

Gummy finish, what happened?

#1

Gummy finish, what happened?

Alan Tolchinsky

>Hi All, I am finishing a small cedar box starting with shellac(dewaxed Zinnser) then wipe on poly. But it was taking a lot longer for the poly to dry and even felt sticky the next day. So I used mineral spirits to remove the sticky areas and reapplied the poly. This time it dried in two hrs. or so.

Some details: I wiped on the shellac, coat after coat as soon as the previous coat dried. I wiped on the poly the same day as the shellac was dry.

Thanks for any ideas on this slight dilema.

Re: Gummy finish, what happened?

#2

Why poly over shellac?

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>It seems to me that a straight shellac finish would be sufficient. Or a straight poly finish, unless the poly would react with the cedar, in which case, straight shellac.

Clint

Re: Gummy finish, what happened?

#3

Re: Why poly over shellac?

Alan Tolchinsky

>I like shellac because it fills up the pores fast so you don't need that many coats. Poly is great for a finish that is very durable. I have a shellac table top that somebody dripped some ice cream on. I didn't notice it until it was too late. Lesson learned there. But I still love shellac for many things as the only finish.

Re: Gummy finish, what happened?

#4

Re: Why poly over shellac?

Fred Davis

>Shellac is a great finish, but if you don't let it harden between coats , you get a gummy finish, if you use too old Shellac , you will

definitely get a sticky finish and lastly I found out the hard way that Aromatic Red Cedar if that is what you used will off gas and ruin a lacquer finish , months or even years after it was applied.

Might happen with shellac too although I havn't heard or seen it.

FredD

Re: Gummy finish, what happened?

#5

Re: Gummy finish, what happened?

Howard Acheson

>The issue is the cedar. Aromatic cedar can not be sucessfully coated with an oil based finish. The off-gasing of the cedar prevents the oil based finish from hardening. It will even soften oil based finishes that were originally hard.

The thing to do is to apply at least two coats of a dewaxed shellac being sure to get the surface fully covered and letting the shellac fully dry between coats. I'd give the last coat 3-4 days.

Like the others, I would suggest that shellac is a nice finish in itself and you may want to consider that.

As a final not, do not apply any oil based finish on the inside if the box will contain any cloth or clothing. An oil based finish will off-gas almost forever and every time it is opened, you will get a wiff of the finish.

Re: Gummy finish, what happened?

#6

Re: Gummy finish, a couple of ideas!

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>Lacquer based finishes work fine on aromatic cedar. The one in our bedroom is about 30 years old and was finished with only Deft Clear Wood Finish. The finish is as hard as the Hickory dresser standing next to it.

I've seen the problem with oil based polyurethane not drying correctly when it was not throughly mixed or was applied over an oil based stain that had not dried at least 24 hours.

Lee

Re: Gummy finish, what happened?

#7

Re: Gummy finish, a couple of ideas!

Fred Davis

>Lee, you may have gotten away with lacquer over aromatic cedar , by not ever letting it set in sunlight for a while.

I know for a fact from personal experience that the Cedar will off gas and bubble and crack a Lacquer finish.

I have never had the problen with Varnish over it tho.

FredD

Re: Gummy finish, what happened?

#8

Re: Funny, in shop class in 1957

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>I built a bookcase from Aromatic (Eastern Red Cedar). School purchased the "kits" to order. Actually the kit was just boards (not cut to length or width) and one piece of high grade cedar faced plywood for the back. I finished the bookcase with a brushed on oil based finish called Sherwin Williams Beauty Lock. (I am sure it was an alkaloid varnish because as I remember Poly's didn't exist then). The finish dried perfectly and still looks great after over 50 years of use. First it was in my mother's house - after she passed away, my middle son acquired it - It is still in use in his living room. Guess I was just lucky.

Re: Gummy finish, what happened?

#9

Re: Gummy finish, what happened?

Alan Tolchinsky

>Thanks for all the help. I'm going with a shellac finish to avoid any further problems.