>Hi. Did a search on deck and sealer and did not come up with much. Installed new deck last year and it was too cold to seal it. Stll looks new and I'd like to do it now. I have heard bad things about Thompsons in general and just want a good, robust sealer (no stain) to keep it looking good.
>Thompsons Orginal formula waterseal is what I use and the only bad thing about it is annual renewing , depending on the weather in your area. It was the first sealer out there and the Johnny come lately's with new and improved formulas , aren't in most cases as good and generally more expensive.
I tell people who want a more permanent approach to paint it.
>I just got done with a re seal of a cedar deck that is two years old. It now has what some would call a gym floor finish look. I use a product called Sekins(sp)SDR from Canada. Where the sun hits the deck hard every day, almost all day, this was some discolor but other areas looked as good as day one. This appears to be a much better product than any of the ones from Lowes, HD, etc. I think it is sold at paint stores only. Here in the Independence, MO area, Zeke's in the only store that has it. Hope this helps.
>I built my deck in 1990. I've used Wolman Raincoat on it ever since. It's a rain repellent with a cedar tint, but you can get natural (clear) or redwood tint as well. I generally re-apply to horizontal surfaces every 3-5 years after power washing it back to clear wood. I've only had to redo the vertical members (posts and rail spindles) once. It has stood the test of time for the last 18 years and still looks good. I've never had to replace a board. Some of the top rail caps could use replacement, not due to the finish, but due to the fact that some of them had a lot of heartwood in them.
Water beads like a wax job on a car. Some folks find that objectionable since the deck surface stays wet longer than normal wood that just absorbs the water. I'm a believer.
>I avoid painting anything that is outside and subject to wear. You may have to apply stain products more frequently but it sure beats scraping and sanding.
I use Sikkens Cetol products for outside use. Having said that, the sun is relentless and the deck or whatever will not maintain its new look forever.
>It's a clear sealer. It's as simple as that. With a few variations along the scale, clear sealers give up the ghost the quickest, and the coatings with the most solids and pigment (paints) will last the longest. Clear coatings can do little to prevent UV penetration (some, but not much). On decks, that's exacerbated by being a traffic area, as well as a collection site for wet leaves (and all the fun decomposition compounds they leach) and snow.
The beauty of clear sealers is they are easy to re-apply...
>Consumer Report just had an article on this topic, either their current issue or the one just past. You might check on it at your local library.
An alternative I will suggest...Check out "One Time Wood." It is not a sealer in the sense of the common sealers. Instead, it is a 100% solids material that cures by ultraviolet light (sunshine!). I used it on a new 2x pine patio table and benches three years ago and you cannot tell it has ever seen the sun. It looks as good now as the day I put it on. The only drawbacks of this material are cost and that it requires exposure to sunlight to cure. Without sunlight, it will NOT cure! Being too lazy to clean up, I put the old beater brush I used to apply it in the throw away bucket I worked out of in the corner of my shed, meaning to get to it later that afternoon. A week later I went to toss the mess away and found the brush still wet! No sunlight, no cure.
As for cost, you do get what you pay for. One home improvement guru, Gary Sullivan, I think, says (paraphrased), "You get what you pay for. Deck sealer costs $15/gallon/year. Choose how often you want to do the work." One-Time Wood lists for $85/gallon or $365/5 gallons on their web site. I forget what it listed for 3 years ago, but I do remember that I bought it for less at an area Ace Hardware than it listed for on the web site.
If my patio set is a good example, 3 years of bright sun, rain, snow, etc. tells me it will be a LOOONG time before I need to seal it again. For me, it was worth every penny. I HATE to stain/seal decks!!
>One internet forum has a wide range of views on One Time. Interestingly, almost all of the negative comments come from folks who have not actually used the product, only are skeptical of company claims. Overwhelmingly, folks who have actually used the product for its intended purpose sing its praises.
Best do some direct research on the Sikkens products. They are restricted/prohibited in a number states do to VOC laws and, depending on the product, you may be required to coat all six sides of each piece of wood, not practical on an existing deck. Plus the stuff can be very expensive ranging to $75 gallon.
Current write up in Consumers has Floods solid color at No. 1 and Sikkens Cetol SRD as No. 2. with the Sikkens at $27/gal. However True Value Woodsman UV is almost as good at $20/gal. If you're in one of the restricted States (like me in New Jersey) you might do well to give your wood a double coat of Floods Seasonite and wait 'till next year to let "them" get these formulas working. I did my decks last year with the new, supposedly VOC compliant formula by Wolman. I had a huge mess with the junk taking more than 2 months to dry and cure, so we couldn't use the decks because the stuff stayed sticky!!!! I was told afterwards that I should have sprayed the entire surface with mineral spirits!
>Thompson's original formula waterseal is a penetrating oil (read linseed oil), because it is a vegetable base product it needs to be renewed on a annual basis in most climates.
To call it a coating implies it is a film finish which it is not.
UV blockers are present in many "clear " products, such as Spar Varnish. Any exterior sealer will hold out water, Thompson's does it very well and like all finish products, needs to be maintained.
The water repellant ability of it is why I use it, forget hopeing the wood will retain its color, silver gray is nice , learn to live with it.
>I too went for the "One time" product , I did not have your luck in the wood maintaining it's appearence. They advertise this to hold up for seven years.
I got a gallon of the tobacco brown color for 92.00 delivered and applied it to a White Oak Bench and a White Oak combination bench and arbor I had just made.
The parts of the benches that are exposed to the most sunshine are nearly white now.
I was skeptical of the never cracking, checking , peeling, or fading for seven years when I ran across it on the internet, sounded to good to be true.
I am glad it worked out for you , I still have enough to recoat and I will eventually, I suspect go back to good old Marine Spar Varnish
>Okay, I slipped once and called it a coating instead of a sealer. It is in the generic sense of "one coats the wood with it". Either way, even with UV inhibitors in the finish, clear doesn't last as long. Pigments are better at blocking UV, and film finishes are better at resisting other forms of weather and physical abrasion. Marine finishes are less than clear, and even they don`t maintain their look for very long.
>Sorry your project did not last like you hoped, Fred. I used the clove finish on pressure treated 2x pine. I wonder if the difference in wood had an effect on penetration, curing, etc.?
It is amazing the results different people have with the same product. A friend used a particular brand of latex adhesive to install new marine grade carpet in his boat. I used the same brand to do the same thing one year later. His was perfect, while mine "bled" through each time it rained for several weeks, almost like it didn't want to cure.
I always wonder what gremlins are at work around my house.
>Well thankee Joe, I have a niggling thought about applieing it over Oak because of the high Tannic acid content , while your pine doesn't have that complication.
That's a level of chemistry I wasnot exposed ot .
Still , I amm going to do it over and let it fry in a Kansas July Sun.
BTW clove is the color I used , my 71 year old brain called it tobacco brown , which it is but clove sounds classier. ;-))
>Tobacco brown was the color of the edge of my grandpa's front porch down in the "holler." The closer you got to his rocking chair, the deeper the color.