Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

Chair - request for advice on how best to buy the

Posts

Chair - request for advice on how best to buy the

#1

Chair - request for advice on how best to buy the

North of the Border

>wood.

This is the first time I'm trying to build a chair. The image shows the cutting list given on a chair plan. For items A - K (please disregard items L to Q), I figured I need these oak boards cut as per my specs for me from my lumber yard (I don't have a thickness planer) for one chair:

A, B - 1 1/2"x 4"x 105"

C,D,E, J,K - 1 1/8" x 4 1/2" x 64.5"

F, G - 1 7/8" x 3" x 32"

H - 5/8" x 1" x 17.5"

I - 3/8" x 1 1/4" x 15.5"

1) Based your furniture building experience, is it the best way for me to order the boards (allowing waste from the saw blade (1/8"))? Or would you have a different configuration?

2) Also, I want to do two chairs, do I just buy twice the wood according to the above spec? Or is there a better way?

3) I suppose I can use scarp red oak to make loose tenons for the white oak mortise joints. Am I right?

Thanks a lot. I plan to get the wood in a couple of weeks.


img

Re: Chair - request for advice on how best to buy the

#2

Off the Top of My Head....

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Afternoon Woodguy,

Considering what my head is made of, advice on wood I give with confidence, be it good or bad advice! FWIW:

I thihk it will be a costly and frustrating enterprise, as you will depend on others to dimension the wood for you, and every piece is different which mean many set-ups. Further, from my own experience, I always am having to tweek the components, as to length, thickness, and angle. This often leads to making another component.

I applaud your aspirations. Build a prototype of poplar first to establish a learning curve and tweek the dimensions. Then go buy your oak ( and hopefully a thickness planer )and duplicate what you have already done. Your final product will look better and have better construction. Your prototype can remain in the shop, a trophy of your learning experience.

George

Re: Chair - request for advice on how best to buy the

#3

Re: Chair - request for advice on how best to buy

Jesse Cloud

>I agree with the Colonel's advice. A prototype is a good investment of your time, especially if its your first chair. A planer would be a good investment, too.

Do you have the other tools you will need (jointer, bandsaw, etc.)?

Can't tell where you are from, but I'll bet there's another woodie not far away who would let you use his planer for a while....

Shouldn't be a problem making the floating tenon out of a different type of wood.

Re: Chair - request for advice on how best to buy the

#4

JL

Re: Always buy more than you think you will need.

JL

>You didn't say what sort of chair that you are making, but I will "presume" that it doesn't involve any turning.

I usually sort through the bins at the lumber yard that I use. I typically get FAS (First and Seconds) lumber that has been straight line ripped and surfaced on two sides (S2S). The lumber I get is reasonable quality. But - you have to figure on knots and surface imperfections. There may be an objectionable bow or twist in the lumber. There may be some end checks. So you will have to take all of this into account.

I usually cut my lumber 1-2" over finished length when I rough it out. I usually cut my lumber to reasonably near width.

Re: Chair - request for advice on how best to buy the

#5

Re: Chair - request for advice : Thank you all!

North of the border

>

Re: Chair - request for advice on how best to buy the

#6

advice

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I dreaded a customer showing up with a cut list. So this advice is colored by a person with experience from the other side of the fence. On the other hand I also recall being in your situation 40 yeas ago.

1. Do you pan on woodworking beyond this project? I will assume a yes.

2. Overcome the urge to buy exactly the minimum amount of lumber to just make the chairs assuming everything worked out perfect (it won't). Any left overs will be used in a future project.

3. What in a chair is 105" long? I will presume this size is the sum of various parts.

4. Lumber isn't sawed to yield a 1 7/8" thickness. However, if you are careful you can coax this thickness from standard rough 8/4 lumber. The other thicknesses are sawed from the 8/4 as needed.

5. Spend some quality time laying out your cuttings on the plank to minimize waste. At least a 9" rough width would be nice as it will enable two 4" cuttings or a 3 and a 4 1/2 side by side. It is usually easy to find a 9" width in 8/4 oak.

Recommendation: buy a couple of rough 8/4 planks of moderate width or one wide one at least 9" wide per chair. A #1 common grade will be the best value if you can find this grade. Locate someone with a jointer and planer to help you fabricate the necessary parts. Eventually you will need to own a jointer and have access to a planer to make hardwood objects of this kind. This seems like a huge amount of lumber per chair.

Re: Chair - request for advice on how best to buy the

#7

Re: Thanks for your advice which I was looking for *LINK*

North of the Border

>The material that I need for this chair comes from the side chair plan that I got from FW. The cutting list is attached in my first message. The link to the plan is shown below. Like you, a number of people seem to be saying that's a lot of wood for a chair but that's what the plan (which I've checked) has laid out. My neighbor has a jointer and I would see if he has a thickness planer. Since when I usually do projects, I buy lumber at the right thickness, and I don't want to have too many tools that I use once in a while. For small thickness needs, I can use a router and a jig to do the job. Anyway, thanks for your insights and I'll amend my original list of stock.


FW side chair

Re: Chair - request for advice on how best to buy the

#8

Re: I looked at that plan

Glenn Madsen, SF Bay Area

>That's a nice chair.

Plan on the templates. And plan on building more than two chairs. They will be popular additions in the house. Yours, and at friends and families homes.

Once you get the pattern down, building more is not too big a problem.

And I'd see if I could come up with the $300 for a modest surface planer, if there isn't one immediately available to use. I bought mine early on, and it's been really useful. I bought the Ridgid at Home Depot, but there are half a dozen decent machines in the market.

Thickness planing with a router is a PITA.