Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

New Stereo Cabinet (First project post)

Posts

New Stereo Cabinet (First project post)

#1

New Stereo Cabinet (First project post)

Jake Dahn (so MN)

>Hi all,

Been woodworking for a couple of years, and lurking here for about the same. Thought I would post a recently completed project. I aim for one larger project completed a year....

Since an addition to our family (first son 1&1/2 yrs ago) the need arose for some way to keep the little hands off of the electronics. My first suggestion of "just keep him away from it" was an exercise in futility. So this is the result.

Maple, clear coated with wipe on poly. Carcass is 1" thick by 22" wide by 23" deep and 39" tall. The base assy is 6" tall. Dimensions were made to fit the space and components, not to a golden rectangle

I forgot to take picts before sticking in into place....so they are less than optimal.

As Always, I try attempt something new for each project. This forces me to learn a new skill. It even comes out successful sometimes. This project "first" was inset doors. The turned out pretty well for a first attempt.

Since I use this forum to learn, I will post some of the errors I made on this so others don't have to repeat them.

1) Make sure your glue up table is flat. My main bench was full of clutter so I glued up the main carcass on my table saw out feed table.....which I thought was flat...but wasn't. Trying to unwarp 1" think maple doesn't work...the whole assy rocked a fat 1/16� and had a slight twist in it.

2) When sanding, make sure you didn't pick up any prior grits. After applying the second coat of poly, I noticed the tell tale swirl marks from the random orbit....I thought I had checked it over well, but maple really hides then. Luckily they were on the inside of the door.

3) After a prior blanket chest I found out how important grain matching is....You be the judge on this piece.

4) Blum adjustable hinges are great for being able to fine tune the fit of a door with a critical reveal.

5) Even if you think there is nothing under the towel sitting on your bench that you plan on flipping the completely finished carcass over on...check there are screws under it that will seriously mar the top of the case.....

6) Put handles on it before it leaves the shop....we really wanted it in place at the time to keep little hands away....Any suggestions on handles?

Any criticism would be appreciated. I have very thick skin and am always my harshest critic....

One thing I noticed is that the door frames appear a bit heavy. Next time I would make them at least 1/2 in narrower.

Thanks for the time to read this very long post.

Jake

Re: New Stereo Cabinet (First project post)

#2

Re: New Stereo Cabinet (Pict#2) 

Jake Dahn (so MN)

>


img

Re: New Stereo Cabinet (First project post)

#3

Re: New Stereo Cabinet (Pict#3) 

Jake Dahn (so MN)

>


img

Re: New Stereo Cabinet (First project post)

#4

Very nice work

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>

Re: New Stereo Cabinet (First project post)

#5

Re: New Stereo Cabinet (First project post)

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>You found some nice wood for that piece. Thanks for posting.

For decisions on things like door frame size I make a scaled drawing of the piece. I diddle with the sizes of things like door frames on the drawing till it looks optimum. If it looks optimum in the scaled drawing it will look as well in the piece.

PS I independently discovered the screw-on-the-bench issue.

Re: New Stereo Cabinet (First project post)

#6

Re: New Stereo Cabinet (Pict#1) 

Jake Dahn (so MN)

>


img

Re: New Stereo Cabinet (First project post)

#7

Re: New Stereo Cabinet (First project post)

Jake Dahn (so MN)

>Thanks, the case is hard maple and the door panels are bookmatched curly soft maple with some bird peck in it.

I did draw up a mock-up, just not quite to scale. From the mock up I realized that the top of the feet should line up with the door pannels, I didn't realize how much the edges of the case would add to the apparent thickness of the door frames.

Thanks for the suggestion. My next drawing will be to scale.

Jake

Re: New Stereo Cabinet (First project post)

#8

Re: New Stereo Cabinet (Pict#1)

ken raddon

>That my friend is a really nice piece. The only suggestion I have is next time use regular masking tape. Those blue tape door pulls you have are a bit of a distraction from the overall beauty and regular masking tape would blend much better.

Ken Raddon.

PS Kidding about the tape but not kidding about the "really nice piece."

Re: New Stereo Cabinet (First project post)

#9

Re: New Stereo Cabinet (First project post)

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Hello Jake,

Very nice piece of furniture. Congratulationbsd especially on the wood selection. Certainly no criticisms here from me. Having NEVER made ANY mistake myself, I found your list motivating. Maybe I can borrow some of your "do's and Dont's" to help explain some observations other people have made after looking at my furniture. :<)

George

Re: New Stereo Cabinet (First project post)

#10

Re: New Stereo Cabinet (First project post)

Jim Dillon

>Jake,

Very nice job (and wood selection) and I like your list of "errors" from this undertaking but I wouldn't call them errors - just learning experiences! I often use a simple 2-D drawing program like Delta Cad to help me visualize how different widths of rails and stiles will look. Someday I want to learn Google Sketch-Up to make the visualization even more realistic. Thanks for posting.

Jim

Re: New Stereo Cabinet (First project post)

#11

Re: New Stereo Cabinet (First project post)

Paul Woolson

>Jake, that's a lovely piece. I like it a lot!

As to you seeking suggestions on pulls/handles. I would suggest you go without. Perhaps use those little spring magnets on the inside that you push the door in and it, in return, pops it out a bit more so you can open it. Sort of like you'd see on glass doors of a stereo unit. Just my .02 worth. (you get what you paid for)

Re: New Stereo Cabinet (First project post)

#12

Ellis Walentine

Very tasty indeed

Ellis Walentine

>Jake, thank you for your lengthy post and all the nice pictures. Your "lessons learned" (not "mistakes") feature was very edifying as well. That's the kind of stuff we all can learn from.

Regarding stile and rail proportions, I would agree with you that these seem wide for such narrow doors. I think I would have made the stiles about an inch narrower and the top rail narrower than the bottom one. That is a very customary relationship on doors; your eye almost expects to see it. The different rail widths lend a subtle dynamic to the piece, adding a sense of perspective.

I think that some simple hand-carved rosewood or ebony pulls would add a nice accent. You want the pulls to be very functional, since these doors will get a lot of use. Touch latches work well, but the finish would be likely to pick up a lot of grime and wear from constant finger contact.

I like the way the box is modeled by the small reveal underneath it. Simple and effective.

Nice work. I'm delighted if WoodCentral helped you along the way.

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: New Stereo Cabinet (First project post)

#13

Thanks to all

Jake Dahn (so MN)

>Thanks to all for the comments and critiques.

Ellis,

The discussion door proportions was exactly what I was looking for. I knew something wasn't right, but I couldn't put my finger on it.

Jake