Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

detail sanders which one is best

Posts

detail sanders which one is best

#1

detail sanders which one is best

Michigander51

>I need to get a detail sander to use for removing stain and finish sanding on furniture. I am condidering the Bosch 1294VKS as it has different shaped tools that would get into corners etc. I looked at the Fein Multitool, but from reviews I have read the sander doesn't work all that well. I need to be able to sand to 180 grit without tool marks. Does anyone have experience with this sander or with another that you think is better. Are accessories like sandpaper readily available for this sander. I would appreciate your input.

Thanks.

Michigander51

Re: detail sanders which one is best

#2

Re: detail sanders which one is best

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Afternoon Michigander,

I have both a Ryobi detail sander and P+C profile sander. I use the detail sander more often, but not extensively. Frankly, I'd rather use my hands or a sanding stick, modified to suit the job at hand. The Ryobi does work acceptably well for a lower end tool, but not as good as me. The P+C profile sander was a Christmas gift from my kids, so I keep it in plain sight in the shop. Its not worth plugging in, in my opinion.

George

Re: detail sanders which one is best

#3

You're Too Nice George

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>My FIL gave back the PC I got him. As a sander it sucks (without the vac hookup), but it's not bad as a marking tool. The profile blanks wear right through the paper and make nice black marks.

Oh, you were looking for a profile sander? Sorry, don't have one of those.

Haven't tried the Bosch lately, but a friend has one he uses for sanding into corners, and likes it for that.

As far as profiles go, you're better off making your own shaped block.

mm

Re: detail sanders which one is best

#4

Re: detail sanders which one is best

Glenn Madsen, SF Bay Area

>I really like my Fein, although not so much as a sander. I seldom use one of those. The Fein does so many other neat things, though. And as as sander, it works all right.

If you watch the David Marks show on television, you note he makes his own sanding sticks and pads. Those work well for me, particularly where I don't need the power sanding capability.

Otherwise, hand sanding is just fine.

Re: detail sanders which one is best

#5

Re: detail sanders which one is best

steve mackay

>I've had two models of the Craftsman version. Neither one was "all that". When SWMBO bought me the first one I said I was going to pitch my sanding block. Glad I didn't. The second was a rebuild that I inherited so I gave it a second chance. No better. Kind of like all gizmos. I'm sure theres something they do well but they don't replace as much as the comercial leads you to belive.

Re: detail sanders which one is best

#6

Re: detail sanders which one is best

Steve Schoene

>I had a Bosch a while ago, and gave it up at a tag sale about two moves ago. I have the Fein and like it quite well. Considerably more agressive at removing material, and if you are patient and let it do the work it can leave a nice finish--though I would always do a touch of hand sanding when finishing furniture. It does have capabilities to add special shapes, and some things that no other detail sander can do, such as cutting door casings flush to hardwood floors. Actually plenty of tasks were it is the only tool that's not totally specialized that can do the job. And, tough and reliable.