Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

Saw Stop Contractor's Model

Posts

Saw Stop Contractor's Model

#1

Saw Stop Contractor's Model

David Yoho

>For anyone interested in Saw Stop's new contractor saw that's soon to be released, I got an up-close look at one this weekend. Saw Stop dropped one destined for the Chantilly, VA woodworking show off at the Workshop of Charles Neil for the get together they were having on Saturday.

Although the one in the picture is the base model, there are a number of upgrades available for this saw. The fit and finish is excellent and the price is more affordable than their cabinet saw. The saw has a 1-3/4 HP motor.

Charles demonstrated the stopping ability several times with a few old blades mounted on the saw. He put a piece of wood against the miter gauge with a hot dog on top of the wood and pushed the miter gauge as though making a cross cut. The instant the blade sensed the hot dog, there was a loud thump when the blade dropped below the table and the cartridge made contact with the spinning blade. It all happened so fast you couldn't see it. The hot dog did not have a mark on it - NONE!!

I've seen the hot dog demo online but seeing it in person is incredible. Charles was telling us that if the cartridge fires, you can send it back to Saw Stop and they have a way to determine if there was skin contact causing the cartridge to fire. If so, they replace the cartridge for free.

So, anyone interested in the contractor model, it will soon be available where sold.

David


img

Re: Saw Stop Contractor's Model

#2

Re: Saw Stop Contractor's Model

Chuck in ND

>I find it rather odd that the saw doesn't have cast iron wings or a Biesemeyer fence.

Re: Saw Stop Contractor's Model

#3

Accessories

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Afternoon Chuck,

Mine is very well equipped and is currently situated in the back yard next to my Pinacle Super Duper BBQ. I ordered the saw with a special accessory hot dog dispenser. With that accessory, I can demonstrate the safety feature of the saw and cook dinner at the same time. In this age of multi-tasking, its a real time saver. In lieu of cast iron or stamped steel wings, I installed a shop built end grain maple cutting board and used mineral oil for a finish.

George

Re: Saw Stop Contractor's Model

#4

Re: Accessories

Chuck in ND

>lol George, you may want to add a condiment rack for ketchup, mustard, relish, and sauerkraut, for those nights your prepareing bratwurst.

Re: Saw Stop Contractor's Model

#5

Re: Saw Stop Contractor's Model

Mike Galloway

>Hi Chuck

As David mentioned this is the base model that you are looking at. You can order it with other options like cast iron wings, better fence and mobile base. It will all depend on how much you want to spend.

Mike

Re: Saw Stop Contractor's Model

#6

That is a terrible terrible idea.

Ed Snow

>I know this will be really unpopular but this is not opinion just fact. I use sawstops, I teach/taught on sawstops. The fullsize one is proving to be chincy piece of " ". Until they get the electronics and the manufacture figured out they cannot issue a chincier version of what they had.

The saw has too many damn parts, too many vibrations. The combination results in what can only be described as a below average cut. Plus with the flakey 80$ a pop electorics eating sawblades and cartidged despite being set within in the tolerances noted it just turns into a massive pain in the butt. Now all of those little things that add up quickly in the big saw will only do what, add up way faster in a lesser saw.

To note, my comparisons tannewitz's, a greenlee, various euro sliders, and your run of the mill pm66 and unisaw. None of these saws have ever cut as poorly as the sawstop.

You have heard me gripe about it before, anymore I am just fed up.

Re: Saw Stop Contractor's Model

#7

Re: That is a terrible terrible idea.

Howard Norman

>Interesting comments about the SawStop Ed. SawStop seems to have developed a "cult" of advocates in North America. When you have a cult they tend to overlook a lot of things.

Re: Saw Stop Contractor's Model

#8

Re: That is a terrible terrible idea.

David Yoho

>Ed, I take it from your reply you speak from experience about the SawStop. I don't doubt what you say either. However, I know someone using the SawStop cabinet saw every day for quite some time now and says he hasn't witnessed the same things. As hard as he works that saw, I would tend to think he'd notice something like you noted by now. Maybe it's an inconsistency in QA - who knows!

I must also note that he still has or had a Unisaw, PM66, and Jet Exacta together in the shop (sold the Delta). He told me just the other day how much he liked the quality of cut on the SawStop over the others.

So, we have two differing experiences about the same product. Not uncommon in today's times. Ultimately, I think folks will need to evaluate things for themselves based on all the facts they can gather when it comes to making a purchase like this.

David

Re: Saw Stop Contractor's Model

#9

Re: That is a terrible terrible idea.

Ed Snow

>That is true, although in my experience this is not limited to just one saw. This is three of them. I admit I push a saw to its limits. This is not hobby use or even semi pro use this is very high end furniture. The saws just are not up to par in my opinion. This is not an isolated opinion several other of my peers agree.

It is very clever and has saved a lot of fingers but at my level of work it just won't do. Like I said before despite my opinion I have a very hard time recommending any other saw, for what it does and for the people who ask me it is a good saw for them, if they can work around its limitations.

Re: Saw Stop Contractor's Model

#10

Re: That is a terrible terrible idea.

Fred Davis

>For the people who may have saved their fingers by using Sawstop instead of their brain, they will undoubtedly find some other painful way to mutilate their hands,with bandsaws, changing the bit in a plugged in router or shaper,they also are the ones who in trying to save a few bucks will not opt for magnetic starter switches on their stationary power tools.

FredD

Re: Saw Stop Contractor's Model

#11

Re: Rant about Saw Stop any model

Bob Entwisle in NJ

>See Chuck, you can get it with a Biesemeyer fence! You just have to pony up more cash!

It's amazing to me that people will buy this product from a company and inventor whose first attempt, or non-attempt at marketing it was to lobby the government to mandate it as a safety feature on table saws. Interesting post by a professional with actual experience on the machine saying it's a substandard table saw too, regardless of it's 'safety' features. I find it intriguing that the company is now offering to replace the cartridge if it misfires. Or are they offering to replace it if it encounters skin? Not clear about that one.

I remember when the SawStop was first posted about on WC about 8 years ago. My opinion of this device and the individual/company have not changed.

I imagine that they will make enough campaign contributions to the right (wrong) politicians, and get it legislated into schools as the only table saw allowed in shop programs etc. And eventually they will get them legislated into our shops too. Hopefully I�ll be gone by that time.

I will admit that I am not taking a logical approach to the SawStop, as logically it seems like a good, if not fantastic, safety device, my objections to it are a passionate reaction to the idea of a company that was created to build the saw stop not because they wanted to build a better tablesaw, but because they were unsuccessful in marketing the idea to existing saw manufacturers, and then were unsuccessful in getting the government to mandate it, so they ended up having to build and sell table saws in order to push this device out into the marketplace. They continue to use scare tactics regarding safety to market it. By their having spent the money to build a company to fabricate and market this tablesaw, their ultimate payoff has to be to get the device to be mandated by the government.

Re: Saw Stop Contractor's Model

#12

Re: Rant about Saw Stop any model

David Yoho

>I've seen the passionate debates on this issue here and elsewhere before and almost hesitate to respond. So, I'll just inject a few facts as I know them.

From what I've heard, Saw Stop will replace the cartridge for free if it shows it fired due to skin contact. Evidently some kind of electronic signal senses this and is stored in the device and can be read by the folks at Saw Stop when it's sent back.

As far as the quality of their cabinet saw, from what I've seen there's a lot to like there. Powder coated instead of painted, and a trunnion system that is beefier than those on a PM66. The mounting holes for the fence rails have holes that line up with each other without using slotted holes and the hand wheels are machined well and work smooth.

These are the facts as I've seen them. I'm not trying to start another SawStop war here but just provide some information that folks may want to know if they're interested in this product.

David

Re: Saw Stop Contractor's Model

#13

Re: Saw Stop Contractor's Model

Chuck in ND

>Hi Mike, my point was if I was going to shell out that kind of cash on a saw, I would expect the fence to atleast be industry standard. I feel the same way about the extension wings.

Re: Saw Stop Contractor's Model

#14

Re: Rant about Saw Stop any model

Rob Stokes in North Vancouver

>Bob - when Sawstop first came out and started to lobby the product safety commission (etc.), I got loud. I was (and am) passionate about people going to market that way and considered the tactics slimy, underhanded and very "un-American". And I still do.

But in my (many) postings (on many sites)and in my (several) communications with the company itself where I carried on the same tirade with the same intensity, and where I continually slammed Sawstop for their business tactics, I always dared them (Sawstop) to put away the foolish and arrogant games, and to simply compete in the largest capitalist marketplace in the world. If indeed they had built a better mousetrap, their future would be secure. If they had simply built another gimmick - their future would be a chapter in the history books.

In my last communication with Sawstop (over a year ago) they assured me that for now, the slime tactics have been put on the shelf and they are focusing their efforts on the product, and on marketing the product directly to their target consumers. Which is as it should be.

The very fact that the heart of this conversation pertains to the fence and whether or not it should/could come with a Beisemeyer style is pretty heartening. It's one of the first threads I've read in a long time that actually discusses the saw as a saw, not so much as a gimmick. And perhaps that's proof that Sawstop is actually starting to make their name and claim their piece of real estate based on functionality and merit, not on slime tactics and attempted Government intervention.

If so - this is good news, and as with the true competitive marketplace, this can only benefit us (the consumer) in the long run.

Rob

Re: Saw Stop Contractor's Model

#15

Re: Rant Off, (sort of) Thanks for the replys

Bob Entwisle in NJ

>To all, I apologize if my SawStop ranting raised anyone�s blood pressure.

David,

Thanks for clarifying the skin contact replacement cartridge issue, and the technical issues about the powder coated finish, and heavy trunions. I�m not certain about the issue of holes vs slotted holes for the fence rails, but presume it means that the rails and table and wings are fit accurately and thus slotted holes are not needed to achieve proper alignment.

Rob,

You have obviously pursued this to a much more serious extent than my mere ravings. I do have to question what the assurances from a company that used the �slime� tactics originally, are worth. The assurance that the slime tactics have been put on the shelf only makes me think that they are saving them for a more opportune time.

With my view of the SawStop, I take the fact that the heart of this conversation was about the fence as an indication that the company is gaining legitimacy in the marketplace. To me it is an indication that their tactic of building and marketing a tablesaw is working. Once they have established a viable product in the marketplace, I think they will go to the �shelf�, and once again, lobby for the safety feature to be government mandated. Am I correct in assuming that SawStop et al, hold significant patents on the device and technology? If so then once they get it legislated, SC, PM, Delta and China Inc. will all be licensing SawStop, or be forced to withdraw from the marketplace, thus our choices will be eliminated. I hope I�m wrong.

Our freedoms are generally not swept away all at once, but subtly nibbled away, one insignificant bit at a time.

Anyhow, I�ll let this rest for now. I�m obviously (to me anyway) turning in to a cynical old man, and I�m only 50, er 51�.

Thanks for tolerating me.

Bob