Re: Tap/carrot roots are a myth
Sgian Dubh
>Your right Tom. Roots conduct the essential minerals and water found in soil into the sapwood in the trunk, branches and leaves of trees. These essentials come from decaying organic matter, beneficial fungi, natural minerals and precipitation found mostly in the top layers of rich fertile soil. About seventy five percent of tree roots cluster in this rich source of nutrients with only a minority going deeper than about 600 mm (24�) into the relatively barren subsoil. Most of the roots of a large tree radiate roughly 3 or 4 metres (10�- 12�) from the trunk, but the finest roots may spread out twice as far as the trees' canopy.
As is ever the case the above statements are generalisations. There is a direct correlation between a tree species typical lifespan, the above ground mass of the bole, branches, leaves, flowers, seeds, etc., and the below ground mass of the root system. Fast maturing trees concentrate their energy from seed germination to maturity on developing and maturing the above ground mass to the detriment of root development. They have greater mass above ground than they do below and a comparatively short lifespan. They are not best suited to coping with stress.
Trees with long life spans will develop much more substantial root systems accompanied by significantly slower development of overground mass from the outset. The root mass is greater than the above ground mass. The production of seed during the lifetime of a tree with this type of growth ratio is usually miserly compared to fast growing trees with low root to overground mass proportions.
The silver birch grows fast, puts down a fairly small root system, matures young, reproduces profligately, stresses easily, and dies quickly. Oaks are exactly the opposite: slow growing, large root mass, late maturing, reproduce frugally�comparatively speaking, steadfast under stress, and are long-lived.
One type of tree that does put down deep roots are the phreatophytes such as the north American mesquite, Prosopis pallida. They have adapted to desert conditions by developing extremely long and deep penetrating roots able to find moisture. Slainte.

The above photograph of a fallen beech tree gives an indication of just how small a tree's anchor to the ground can be. The trunk of this tree to the point of the first branching was roughly 12 paces as it lay on the ground. The fine roots would have spread further but the soil clad root ball lying above ground had a diameter of about 5-1/2 paces. Notice that there is no tap root, and that as the tree fell the roots tore up a flattish plug of soil only about 2 feet thick.