>Several days ago I posted about my Redbud tree. It is apparently brittle and has broken in several places. Several limbs have come off in ice storms and the major upright is split.
Would it be better to apply some sort of permanent surface over the jagged splits so the bark would have an easier time closing the wound?
The split in the upright is about a half inch gap. Should I file that to help it heal. What should I use? Cement? Epoxy? Nothing?
Cinch the gap as close as possible. Maybe even go up higher with rope or ratchet straps to draw it together before installing your threaded rod. Use only an insecticide on the wound. Do not try to seal the area as this will only promote rot and a place for insects to breed. The tree should do fine.
BTW I just planted a 10' Forest Pansey redbud yesterday. It is truely a beautiful tree.
>Thanks, The gap is about a half inch. (hold your hands up about a half inch apart. The area is slightly larger than that.) Apparently it has been cracked for quite a while. The edges of the bark are healed and curling inward. I put a one inch wide nylon strap around the limbs about a foot above the crack and tried to draw it back together, but no luck. I made a loop around the limbs above and then wound it tight with a stick. It did not seem to help. I considered a band clamp and may try that tomorrow.
I have had this tree about twenty years or more. It is one of my favorites. Comes out beautiful burgundy red and then fades to green by the end of the summer. When frost hits it the leaves turn yellow. I have a dogwood next to it that comes out green and then in the fall it turn burgundy. They sort of reverse.
I have quite a collection of trees. Eight or ten Dogwoods and a similar number of Redbuds and about forty or fifty Japanese maples. Actually, there are more than that, but that is the different ones.
If you are tree shopping I could recommend a few. Look for a Redbud "Mexicana". Tiny leaves, blue green and leathery, about the size of fifty cent pieces with a pie crust edge. My favorite dogwood is a Cornus Kousa "Wolf Eyes". Green and white or cream foliage. The foliage is so spectacular you have to walk right up to it to see if it is blooming.
>but it takes a long time to put the old folk tales to rest :)
Cabling and bracing is very much an art and science.
A picture would sure help in the diagnosis. there is a good chance that a handy person could take care of a redbud without calling an arborist.
What is the trunk diameter below the split? Did it split at a very Y shaped union where both upper branches are close to the same size and met in a very tight V? If so, that's what's called 'included bark'. What you actually have is two trunks that are growing from one point and they aren't, as you found out, growing together.
For now, try to pull the two leaders back into place. Be sure to pad the straps or use a wider ratchet strap. YOu could crush or damage the bark by using a strap that is too narrow. Think of thread vs. flat webbing...or showshoes.
I might not get back to WC for a couple of days. If not, be sure to write to me. I'll help anyway I can or try to hook you up with a qualified arborist near you.
>In the previous picture, that is a ten foot ladder leaning in the tree. The tree must be about 25' tall and maybe 30 feet wide. That a Cherokee Sunset peeking around it from the right.
The split is about ten or twelve feet off the ground and the trunk at that point is about 6" in diameter. The two branches are about 4". As you can see, they don't take off ans a particularly narrow angle, something over forty five degrees. The bark has started to heal and the wood inside the split is somewhat weathered so this has been there for a season or two. Just did not see it sooner. The strap is about a foot above. You can see the end of the stick I used to wind it tight in the Picture. I was unable to pull the crack back together. Now that I think of it, there has probably been a year of growth, reinforcing it in this position. I am concerned the bark will move into the crack and try to completely fill it and become a bark inclusion.
That's why I was asking if I could fill the crack with something that would cause the bark to bridge the gap. I also see that that might cause it to retain water and start the rotting process.
What about a steel rod through the upper limbs in place of the straps? I was thinking stainless to prevent it rusting out and reduce the chance of poisoning the tree.
Or would it be better to just replace the strap every year to hold it until the wound is thoroughly healed?
Also, the bark on the main trunk is grey and sort of ropey and some of it is loose. You can see the dark area where I brushed it off. It was loose and practically fell off. Is this part of the growing process or is there something else going on?
>Ask This Old House dealt with the same type of problem last season. Apparently the way to take care of the problem is to cable the two leaders together on the inside, above the split.
>That illustration from TOH could have been better.
Installing the cable at about 2/3 height is the goal but can be negotiated. The higher the better to gain the most mechanical advantage.
Do NOT chisel the bark away to seat the washer on the through bolt. Arborists stopped doing that years ago. No need to make a large wound in the tree.
There are several non invasive cabling systems that have been developed that eliminates another wound. These systems use special ropes/slings/splices to allow the tree to move more naturally up top.
>Could you post a picture or description of the non-invasive techniques. Or tell me where to search for the info. I want to fix the tree or at least prevent further damage.