Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Advice needed for Jointer purchase....

Posts

Advice needed for Jointer purchase....

#1

Advice needed for Jointer purchase....

Steve Woodall

>Hey All,

I am about to buy a new jointer and could use some good advise. I have narrowed it down to 2 different models:

1. Grizzly- 6", 1 1/2 hp, with spiral cutterhead. Here is a link:

http://www.grizzly.com/products/6-X-46-Jointer-w-Spiral-Cutterhead/G0452Z

2. Grizzly- 8", 3 hp, with 4 hss knife cutterhead. Here is a link:

http://www.grizzly.com/products/8-x-72-Jointer-with-Mobile-Base/G0656

I guess what I can't decide is whether the spiral cutterhead is worth giving up the extra 2 inches of width compared to the 8" with conventional blades. I can't afford the 8" with spiral cutterhead, so I have to choose between 6" with spiral or, 8" no spiral.

I would like to know your opinions on this. Also any other issues you think I should consider on these 2 units. Also if you think there is another product that is better in this price range, I would love to know what it is.

I am replacing a 1940 something, Rockwell 4", so I am sure either one will be a huge improvement.

Thanks in advance,

Steve

Re: Advice needed for Jointer purchase....

#2

Advice, neither

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I have run as many feet of lumber across a jointer as most on this Forum. I have owned a 3 knife machine since 1970 and maybe on 5 occasions I have had a board that was too wild to successfully joint (likely some black gum), in which case I sawed a glue edge on the table saw. It is sufficient pain to adjust 3 knives; I can't imagine the effort to deal with 4 for no additional benefit that I can tell.

The most important attribute of a jointer is length (PS. and an adjustable out feed table). It is vastly easier to straighten long boards on a long jointer, which is why I sold a 6 and bought an 8 when I could afford to do so. If you are into face flattening on a jointer, width will also be an important issue, which is a reason some spend for a 12".

Bottom line, buy the longest widest jointer you can afford and 3 straight knives will do fine with any domestic hardwood. A jointer is a precision machine and it needs to be made well. Others with experience can speak to whether the Griz is well made; I have no experience with this brand.

Re: Advice needed for Jointer purchase....

#3

JL

Re: Sort of the same advice...

JL

>You basically want the longest, heaviest jointer that you can get. The longer jointer table will allow you to support the boards you are jointing better. The mass will help you to get more accurate cuts.

The G0656 is longer (72") and heavier (500+ lbs) than the 6" jointer. The G0490 (also an 8") is a bit longer and heavier still.

If you don't plan on jointing a lot of wood with squirrelly grains, a straight knifed jointer should be adequate to your needs. If you do decided to upgrade to a spiral cutterhead later, the G0490 has a spiral cutterhead available.

My $0.02.

Re: Advice needed for Jointer purchase....

#4

It is easier to....

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>It is easier to add a spiral cutterhead later to a 8" jointer, than it is to add 2" inches to a 6" jointer.

Happy Woodworking!

Re: Advice needed for Jointer purchase....

#5

What do you do with it?

Barry Irby

>To make this decision, you need to think about what you do with it. If like many of us you use it ninety percent of the time for reasonably straight grained wood, then a standard knife jointer will serve you well, except on those few occasions when you have that exceptional piece of wood. OTOH, if you work with difficult wood most of the time, then you may actually "need" a spiral cutter head. I don't have a spiral cutter head and have never actually used one. I cannot tell you from personal experience whether they are the miracle of woodworking some think they are.

On really beautiful and difficult wood does it matter whether you ruin it on a standard cutter head or ruin it a little less on a spiral? Ruined either way. Maybe someone here can tell you form experience that one of these machines will let you joint Snally stuff with reckless abandon or if it is just somewhat Better than the other.

There are workarounds. If such wood is rare for you, find a buddy or other shop with a spiral head. I "plane" really tough stuff in myPerformax. I have put stuff through that that I don't believe could have been done reliably on any cutter head. You can make a sled for a planer to allow for face jointing. And there are (heaven forbid) hand tools, which some will tell you will handle these difficult pieces better than power tools. (Don't ask me about hand planing. On a good day, I might be able to find the one plane I own.)

Other than that, the others are correct. You want the longest heaviest most precise machine you can afford. Then some more width. And then a spiral head.

Another piece of half baked info. I have read that the joints with adjustment wheels and gibbed ways adjust slowly but with great precision. The ones with handles and the parallelogram adjustments adjust very quickly but with somewhat less precision. The precision is very important on the out feed table. The table and the knives must be set very accurately in relation to each other. Many people sett eh knives and then adjust the table to be precisely aligned. Supposedly this is difficult with some machines. A misalignment of 1/100" might be very significant. The Hand wheel is very useful here. OTOH, on the infeed side the quicker adjustment might be better. 1/100" is not as significant there. I think Grizzly makes machines that have the handwheel one out feed and the handles on the infeed, sort of the best of both.

Re: Advice needed for Jointer purchase....

#6

Re: Advice needed for Jointer purchase....

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>I owned a 6" Grizzly joiner (with lever adjustment) for 15 + years. It did everything it was supposed to do without any attention except initial setup and knife sharpening and changing. However when I retired 2~3 years ago, I needed, er - wanted, a wider planer as I do use mine for flatting the face of wider & longer boards. I purchased the spiral head Grizzly 8" with handwheels - It has been a joy to use. The longer beds make it much easier to flatten longer boards. (My son & I made all the window trim, baseboard and ceiling trim for his house from rough sawn white oak - some boards were 12' + long.). In your position, I would purchase one of the 8" Grizzly joiners, with the standard cutterhead. This gives you the ability to replace the cutter head with the spiral head in the future (current price for the 8" Griz spiral cutterhead is around $300).

My son purchased a Yorkcraft 20" planer with the Byrd head as a retirement gift. The spiral heads do wonders with knarly woods and tough to plane woods like Black locust. I really can't see any difference in the results from the Grizzly spiral head and the Byrd. When he purchased the Yorkcraft planer the Byrd head was on backorder so the vendor sent the planer first with the straight blade cutter head, then followed with the Byrd about 6 weeks later. This did give me a chance to evaluate the differences. In straight grained wood I didn't see any change, but in figured wood, wood with a knot, or hard to plane wood like locust, the difference was amazing. The spiral head virtually eliminated tearout. I actually fed an assembled white oak frame and panel door through the 20" planer, even the cross grain, rails came out free from tearout.

Re: Advice needed for Jointer purchase....

#7

Re: Advice needed for Jointer purchase....

Mike Fitterling

>IMO, spiral knives on a jointer are not as necessary as on planers. After all, the wood usually goes through the planer or some other process after jointing, which can take care of any tearout you get from the jointer. Bigger is better in a jointer. I used to own a 6" Grizzly jointer and it was an excellent machine; I only got rid of it when I found a gloatable deal on a Northfield 12". If you get the 8" you will have greater capacity, and if you have a future windfall, you can always replace the cutterhead with a Byrd pretty easily. I bought a Byrd head for my 15" planer from Holbren and highly recommend them. That all being said, of course it would be nice to have a spiral head on a jointer, but if you are like me with limited funds, buying machinery is often a balancing act. One of these days my 12'er will have a Byrd.

Good luck with your decision.

Mike

Re: Advice needed for Jointer purchase....

#8

Re: Advice needed for Jointer purchase....

Jesse Cloud

>Two ideas:

1)If you don't joint highly figured wood, skip the helix head.

2)If you need the spiral head and can't afford it on a new 8 inch jointer, buy a used jointer (try craigslist, maybe a want-to-buy ad, and then upgrade it to spiral.

I think, in the long run, you would be wasting $$ by getting a 6 inch jointer or getting a new 8 incher and then buying an upgrade later...

my two cents...

Re: Advice needed for Jointer purchase....

#9

Re: Advice needed for Jointer purchase....

Jim Dillon

>Steve,

My experience parallels that of the other posters. When I bought my 8 inch jointer 10 years ago, I did it for the sole advantage of the 8 inch capacity. While that is a very nice advantage, I've come to realize that the increased bed length and jointer weight are as important, if not more so. Last summer I had to joint a lot of 12 footers for an interior trim project and sure appreciated the beds extra length. In that case, I also used a shop portable stand to help on the outfeed side. If you can afford it and have the shop space, I would go with the longest bed jointer and the regular blades. My 2 cents.

Jim