Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

Hey Ellis

Posts

Hey Ellis

#1

Hey Ellis

lee beeden

>With regards to which oil I used on the milk Paint table,

WATCO butcher block oil&finish

'specially formulated for use on wooden butcher blocks, cutting boards, salad bowls and other applications which require a food safe finish......FDA compliant'

However it is a little off putting to see the Skull and Cross Bones on the labeling!!!

Thanks

Lee


img

Re: Hey Ellis

#2

Prime Example

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Of the often cited idea that every finish on the market is "food safe" once it has completely cured and dried. It's the solvent that they're warning you about

BTW: Last time I looked, there was not a single finish "approved" by the FDA. They do it the opposite way, by prohibiting a substance to be used as part of a food contact coating or item, for instance lead-content compounds.

Re: Hey Ellis

#3

Re: Prime Example

lee beeden

>Do you mean that this finish is not safe for direct food contact?

I had envisioned chopping the onions and garlic directly on the table, yes the table would get beaten up but thats just character!!!

lee

Re: Hey Ellis

#4

Re: Prime Example

Dan Donaldson

>At the risk of putting words in someone's mouth, I believe that what was said was that the solvents could be harmful, but they all evaporate away. The FDA does not certify ANY finish as "food safe", but rather tell you what you cannot have in it. In the case of most any finish, after it completely cures, there is not a risk to using it in food contact. There may be some that are bad, but not anything we would normally use,

FWIW, shellac is used to put the shiny finish on candies like skittles and in many other foods.

Re: Hey Ellis

#5

Re: Example

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Lee,

The stuff in that can is mostly hydrocarbon solvent that will mess you up if you drink it; hence the poison warning. If they didn't put that on, but said the stuff about "food safe finish", some dead brain would figure the stuff was safe to drink.

It is the resins and polymerized oil film that remains after the solvents have evaporated that is "food safe" just as are every other finish. As mentioned, shellac is used on items to be eaten (as well as time-release medications), because it is 100% safe. If, however, you choose to drink it when dissolved in the usual denatured alcohol, it'll render you a vegetable if it doesn't kill you.

The whole "food safe" hoopla got started because of lead based pigments and bulking agents in painted items.

Re: Hey Ellis

#6

Re: Prime Example

Dan Mitchell

>Lee-about 20 years ago I worked in some fairly upscale restaurant kitchens. Even then, they were phasing out wooden cutting boards in commercial establishments for plastic. The finish isn't the only problem with using wood as a food prep surface. It's porous (something made worse by knife action) and hard to clean & sanitize as thoroughly as a plastic cutting board, which can be run through the dishwasher. If I were you, I'd preserve that beautiful top's appearance and your stomach as well by going to a commercial restaurant supply house & investing in a couple NSF approved plastic cutting boards to use on it.

Dan

Re: Hey Ellis

#7

Re: Prime Example

charlie belden

>BTW: Last time I looked, there was not a single finish "approved" by the FDA.

Guess you missed shellac - used on "coated

pills", often to make apples shiny for the grocery store and I think it's even used on M&Ms

Re: Hey Ellis

#8

Some info ;-) *LINK*

Dan Donaldson

>Look here if you want to really be confused.


Wood vs Plastic

Re: Hey Ellis

#9

whats the answer here?

lee beeden

>I can, or I cannot use it for cutting my onions?

I don't want to mislead the customer here.

Lee

Re: Hey Ellis

#10

Of course you can use that finish safely.

on Henthorn

>It will be well cured in a relatively short time and be perfectly safe. Bare wood has been used as a cutting surface for centuries and is generally regarded as more sanitary than plastic, which has been shown to grow bacteria as well as cultures in the laborartory.

Re: Hey Ellis

#11

Re: Prime Example

Steve Schoene

>Just because shellac is used in food products doesn't mean the FDA had any particular roll. FDA has a list of ingredients that are approved for use, and a series of test standards to show that the leaching of these from cured products is adequately small. Some manufacturers may want to certify that they have done these tests on a batch-by-batch basis, to charge higher prices, but that still doesn't make it FDA "approved". There are lots of other materials used for coating fruits and vegetables and pills--shellac isn't unique in that application. For that matter, I'd bet that manufacturers using shellac to coat candies and pills aren't buying cans or barrels of Bullseye. even if in the US it may come from a Zinsseer subsidiary.

Re: Hey Ellis

#12

Re: Some info ;-)

Dan Mitchell

>Dan - I'm surprised opinion and research results are as ambiguous as they appear to be, that wasn't the case when I worked in food service 20 years ago. Of course, most any surface can be disinfected if done properly. As with most things, it's in the "done properly" where the trouble starts. I personally will continue to use plastic, particularly as opposed to a large block, because it's so easy to simply stick the board in the dishwasher after use.

Anyway Lee, it's a beautiful piece.

Dan

Re: Hey Ellis

#13

Re: Of course you can use that finish safely.

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>Bare wood has proven to be the best. Don't use mineral oil as it encourages the growth of bacteria.

Re: Hey Ellis

#14

Re: Cleaning Wood Cutting Boards

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Butchers' method that has worked for centuries is to wash with water and then rub down with salt, allow to sit, then brush off.

Plastic boards provide just as much opportunity for bacterial growth once they're used a few times and get cuts and scratches in the surfaces. Only commercial dishwashers use water anywhere near hot enough to sterilize anything. When domestic water heaters are installed they are, by code, set to no more than 115� to prevent scaldings. Some home machines have a "sanitizing" option where the drying coil is used to reheat the water in the rinse cycle to 170�, but it's almost never used and many plastic items people use will deform at that temperature.

Re: Hey Ellis

#15

what I have done for 40 years

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>It would seem that what to put on cutting boards is the most reoccurring Wood Central topic. At the risk of reawakening the people here that don't think this "finish" is a good idea (not sure if any have actually tried it) I will offer a suggestion that I think makes a lot of sense.

I use vegetable oil on all our wood, work surfaces. For as long as we have owned homes we have had a wood counter top work surface on each side of the stove. Everything except meat gets cut on it, and bread, pizza and other baked goods get worked on it. If I work enough dough on it the vegetable oil from some doughs keep it from getting dry. Otherwise, if it is dry looking, I oil it with what ever cooking oil is at hand. It gets wiped down with soapy water as needed and/ or scrapped, especially after working dough.

In case the point was missed, if you use the wood surface for working dough it is going to get oiled with vegetable oil, along with your wood rolling pin. It would seem to logically follow that adding some additional oil as needed is an acceptable, if not a good, idea.

One could get technical about what vegetable oil to use; I don't. Olive oil stays liquid for ever. The more unsaturated cooking oils will polymerized to a not very hard finish that won't bleed back out if the sun hits the counter.

We have a second "portable" cutting board that we butcher on. It gets scrubbed down with soap and water after use and oiled as needed with whatever is handy.

Re: Hey Ellis

#16

Re: I'm with Bill

Kneale Brownson Dreaming of the Snow in N. MI

>We've done the same for almost as long, except I always try to treat the wood surfaces with Wesson Oil. If the soap-and-water wipings down have made the wood look dry, I usually heat some oil and apply it warm, wiping on with a paper towel. The portion where bread dough gets kneaded never needs new oil applied, but the other area does very occasionally.

Re: Hey Ellis

#17

Re: Cleaning Wood Cutting Boards

Dan Mitchell

>"Only commercial dishwashers use water anywhere near hot enough to sterilize anything."

Mark - I was referring to the sanitizing properties of the detergent, specifically the chlorine in liquid types, rather than the temperatures reached.

I doubt salt would pass muster as a disinfectant in a commercial setting from a health code standpoint.

Dan

Re: Hey Ellis

#18

Re: Sanitizing

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Family had a small hotel in South Jersey for many years. The chef's assistant salted every cutting board each night. Never had a problem with the frequent Dept of Health inspections.

I believe the resturant/hotel code still requires commercial dish washing to go through a steam cycle, almost like an autoclave. We had a special 2-stage boiler just for the dishwasher water. When the baskets came out, you didn't dare touch them until they cooled down on the rack. They also used strong detergent, but the steam process was still required.

Re: Hey Ellis

#19

Re: Sanitizing

Dan Mitchell

>Maybe, but I'd be stunned if any jurisdiction's health code listed salt application only as an acceptable disinfectant.

Re: Hey Ellis

#20

Re: Salt

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Dan,

Didn't say it's the "only" way to do it, just that it's one method that appears to have been proven effective over time. Clearly, we can't run either wood or plastic through an autoclave to clean them. Was the sanitizing agent (chlorine) present in both a clorox wash and a salt rub? It's a good bet that it was with that salt rubbed into the wet boards. Plus salt is (probably) the single oldest known preservative for food. Are there bacteria that will grow in brine? I have no clue, but I use the same method in my kitchen on the wood cutting and carving boards I use, and nobody's gotten sick in the 40 years I've been cooking for the family. I do, however, soak my plastic boards in clorox water because it bleaches out the food stains and cleans the sink at the same time.

Peace

Re: Hey Ellis

#21

Used to clean my canteen that way....

John in New Mexico

>With a super salty solution (no bleach available). Its not the clorine from the salt, my understanding is that the salt provides osmotic pressure that effectively crushes the microbes. But I got that from an astro-chemist, so no idea how accurate it really is.

Re: Hey Ellis

#22

Re: Astro - ????

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Chemist? That wouldn't be someone closely "related" to Major Tom would it? |;-}}}}}}}}

Re: Hey Ellis

#23

well, most of them are 'out there"

John in New Mexico

>They study the chemistry of mature stars, star forming nebula, and pretty much everything in between. Its all based on radio emission from the objects and correlating those with experimentally derived frequencies from lab work.

Re: Hey Ellis

#24

Yup

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Maaajor Tom's Brigade

|;-}}}}}

Re: Hey Ellis

#25

Moses Yoder

Re: Cutting Board finish

Moses Yoder

>Studies have shown that just because plastic looks smooth does not mean that it is. Plastic often has pores/crevasses where germs get a hand hold and plastic boards have been proven to hold just as many germs as wood boards. I made a very nice cutting board finish by melting some beeswax (in a double boiler like system, putting a glass quart jar in a kettle of hot water) and mixing it with mineral oil. This wax like substance is then applied with a rag. These are all natural substances with no hazards.