Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

OT Wind generated Electricity question?

Posts

OT Wind generated Electricity question?

#1

OT Wind generated Electricity question?

Barry Irby

>Talked to a guy yesterday that told me he has a second home in Wyoming (?). Said they pay the power company $50/60 a month extra for the assurance their electricity is coming from renewable resources such as wind power.

I did not challenge this, but I have been thinking about it. Since I am sure the power company takes the power from their wind farms and dumps it on the grid with the rest of the power, how would I know the watts I got came from the wind farm? Clearly I am being politically incorrect here, but I don't understand. Other than to encourage them to do more wind power, why would I participate in this program?

Re: OT Wind generated Electricity question?

#2

Re: OT Wind generated Electricity question?

Tony - Memphis

>We have a similar program here through TVA. I support it and pay a little extra each month towards the green power program. They use the money to buy "green" power. I read about the program on the TVA website and it made sense to me. Can't speak for other programs, but I think it is worth a few extra bucks a month. If I knew I was staying where I am for a long time, I'd be making my own power, but the cost is so high, I'd have to eat it when I left this house.

Tony

Re: OT Wind generated Electricity question?

#3

Re: OT Wind generated Electricity question?

John in Calgary

>I think your intuition is correct - here in Calgary, the city has advertised our c-train (the local light-rail-transit) as running on wind power. While I believe that they use our tax dollars to buy xx kW-hrs of power from wind generation facilities (most likely 2 hours south of Calgary) there is no guarantee that those exact electrons actually make it to the c-train to run it, they just end up being dumped on the grid. In theory they are yours (you paid for them), but more than likely you are getting the electrons from the coal generation plants that provide most of the province's electricity.

As an interesting aside, Alberta had a moratorium on new wind power plants - the proliferation of these plants, which do not provide steady-state power generation, can only make up a small portion of the total province's power generation, since you have to ensure that you have adequate excess capacity to cover wind generating sources for when the wind doesn't blow.

John

Re: OT Wind generated Electricity question?

#4

Simple support of renewable resources

Tim Greif - West of Chicago

>That's all that program is. I also participate in someting similar. Where I live, we can voluntarily opt in to add an additional "X" dollars a month to purchase energy that is derived from a wind farm in our area. We derive absolutely no economic benefit - it's simply a feel good thing.

No, there is no way you can be sure the energy you receive is coming from the wind farm, any more than you can be sure of the source of the crude that made the gallon of gas you put in your car. The point is, that extra money allows the utility to help keep the wind farm in business feeding the grid.

And while I'm really not into the whole "green" movement in general, I do believe that any activity that encourages the use of renewable resources for energy or other purposes is a good thing.

Re: OT Wind generated Electricity question?

#5

Re: Simple support of renewable resources

Gene Gauss

>I'm an advocate for nuclear power, and the power companies around here dump a lot of power from nuclear power plants onto the grid, but they don't offer the opportunity to buy that power, as they do for the other sources of "green power", nor for hydro, which they also have a lot of. I suppose, they don't offer comparable prices for "nuclear" or "hydro" power because they're a lot cheaper to produce than the environmentally "in" power sources, like wind, etc.

Re: OT Wind generated Electricity question?

#6

No one would . . .

steve mackay

>Yes, the power generated by the wonderfull wind farms DOES get dumped onto the grid (probably hundreds of miles away from your area distribution system.). Its much like telling a small community that the nuclear power plant ( wich I'm all for by the way !)outside of town will effect THAT TOWNS electric needs.The propoganda in your electric bill makes it sound like they are diverting this power to YOUR house in some majic way. Not so. It is an attempt to get you to "subsidize" the project. If they can con enough customers into this they then can justify applying for federal subsidies. Don't get me wrong . . . I'm all for wind power, but the powers that be need to sell the idea in a more honest way.

Re: OT Wind generated Electricity question?

#7

Re: whose electrons are these? hijack

mike hamilton

>I never have understood electricity. Somebody spins copper 200 miles away, excites a bunch of electrons and my lights work. Are they really transferring electrons in a directable flow, or are they transferring the 'excitement'?

Curious and ignorant,

Mike Hamilton

Plainfield, IN (used to be home of an electric utility)

Re: OT Wind generated Electricity question?

#8

It Seems to me........

Barry Irby

>That there is some level of fundamental deception or at least misdirection going on here.

As I understand it, the amount of power on the grid has to be VERY carefully managed. Supply has to closely match demand. They can't just put a bunch of generators on the line and crank out a huge amount of excess power and let it just go to nowhere.

Conversely, the supply cannot fall below demand. Many sources are continuous and somewhat adjustable rather easily. Some are not. Wind farms fail to produce when the wind stops blowing or if it blows too hard. Solar "fails" at night. Without some sort of backup system to carry the grid through those periods of mindlessness or darkness, you have to have something else to generate the power. And that source has to have full capacity. Therefore, it seems to me if you build wind or solar plants, you must also have matching capacity in coal, gas, or nuclear. So, the intermittent sources may save fuel, but not the cost and challenge of building the other plants.

Re: OT Wind generated Electricity question?

#9

Re: It Seems to me........

mike hamilton

>The flip side of this is load-management: being allowed to throttle down some demands, pricing electricity lower at times of low consumption to try to entice demand to move (to better use generating capacity), etc.

It seems the real drive is to put off building extra base generating capacity as long as possible. Between environmental arguments, NIMBY attititudes and the tendency to litigate, it's pretty tough to build new base generating plants today. Some day we will have to pay the piper...

Mike