Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

Powered Respirators - question. long

Posts

Powered Respirators - question. long

#1

Powered Respirators - question. long

Robert R. Clough - Tthorncraft

>If any of you saw my post below, you'll understand this post. I have Emphysema and Asthma. I am on various breathing medications, taking Pulmonary Rehab "forever" - and it works. I shall probably go on Oxy for heavy work (digging post holes, chain sawing, snow shoveling etc.) Now, I must get some form of powered respirator for the shop. I have recently tried a device that fit over the nose - it had a fan. Not enough air for me. I used to have a Trend face shield but it died several years ago and was not replaced.

I have checked out the new Triton and Trend devices. Both appear to work and articles indicate each works as described. The Triton appears to be bulkier and perhaps less easy to use (Matt Berger of FWW says it made him look like an escapee from a HAZMAT crew). The Trend appears similar to the shield I had several years ago. I remember it being relatively easy to use even with glasses (all masks are a nuisance - but breathing IS necessary).

Now, have any of you used either of these? If so, what results did you have? How easy are they to use? Is the air flow very good? E-mail if you prefer.

Re: Powered Respirators - question. long

#2

Re: Powered Respirators - question. long

Hamish

>Hi Robert,

Have you checked out the Aircap by Bradwest?. I have seen in mags that it came out better than the trend. Their web site is: www.bradwest.com. No connection.

Happy breathing, Hamish

Re: Powered Respirators - question. long

#3

Re: Powered Respirators - question. long

Barry Irby

>Robert, I don't have any of them, yet, so I can't answer, but this comes up often on the Turning Board. Post your question there and you may get more info.

Re: Powered Respirators - question. long

#4

Re: Powered Respirators - question. long

Chicago Bob

>Robert,

I work in the chemical industry and the folks I work with have evaluated everything from N-100 dust masks to high end/high cost 3M PAPR's for particulate protection; all have some wearability/useability issues.

I have tried them also in my hobby woodworking and have comfort issues.

Woodcraft sells a power mask positive pressure dust mask (cat # 147633) that I personally find very comfortable for extended periods of time. It uses what I believe is the equivalent of an N-95 replaceable filter and a prefilter - cost for the entire unit is around $65. You can use recargable batteries which last approx 8 hours in the high flow setting. Rockler also sells this mask.

My experience is this mask offers a high degree of protection, afforability, comfortable wearability, & provides a cool air flow around your face. (I don't work for Woodcraft)

The mask is made in Asia and was originally developed and certified for the nucl. industry for particulate. You can find out more by researching the manufacturer on the internet.

I was surprised at this cost to find a powered dust mask that actually worked well. I use it for turning and sanding without any problems.

Regards & good luck,

Bob Haines

Re: Powered Respirators - question. long

#5

Re: Powered Respirators - question. long

Don in Northern Arizona

>Robert,

Because of your health problems, I think you should go for a NIOSH rated system that filters to N100. The Trend, Triton, Aircap, etc. devices don't advertise a NIOSH rating for lung protection, though they sometimes list a NIOSH rating for eye protection, which tells me they probably don't have a lung protection certification. Some of them have BS or EN European ratings, such as THP1 or 2, but I can not find anything that tells me what these numerical ratings mean or how they compare to NIOSH. I suspect they do not thoroughly filter the finest dust particles.

This has been very frustrating for me as I have a strong wood dust allergy. I had the inexpensive powered air 3M unit that they no longer manufacture. It was similar to the Trend Air Shield and it did not filter well enough for me. I now wear a 3M 7500 half mask with N100 filters. It works very well. I put it on before I go in the shop and take it off when I leave. It is pretty comfortable except in hot weather. If you need positive airflow for your condition, I think you ought to consider a 3M Airstream or the equivalent MSA product. They may cost as much as a nice stationary power tool, but your health is priceless.

Don

Re: Powered Respirators - question. long

#6

Re: Powered Respirators - question. long

David G. Sparks

>Hello Robert,

I have an Airstream dust helmet that I used for quite a while. I see now that Airware America offers a HEPA filter option. I have a friend who has severe asthma and also turns wood. The dust helmet works well for him. The only drawback is the cost. It is very expensive for what it is, and replacement parts are way too much. I have been putting off buying a battery pack for mine because of the cost. Anyway, it might be an option that would be helpful to you. Here's where I bought mine: http://www.airwareamerica.com/index.asp?PageAction=VIEWCATS&Category=21