Wood movement in Qtr. sawn oak
Randy Stukenberg
>I am making a bar top out of qtr. sawn red oak. Most of it is about 24" wide, one part 36". How much will this expand/contract? It will be in an air conditioned basement.
Thanks!
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Wood movement in Qtr. sawn oak
Randy Stukenberg
>I am making a bar top out of qtr. sawn red oak. Most of it is about 24" wide, one part 36". How much will this expand/contract? It will be in an air conditioned basement.
Thanks!
Re: Wood movement in Qtr. sawn oak *LINK*
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey
>Randy,
The dimensional change in a particular wood depends upon several factors. First is to determine the actual variety. You mention that your stock is "red" oak, but this is often confused with common "Black" oak. The difference can be significant. Check the link and run down the lists of images under common names to better tell which you have. Then apply the following formula:
D2=D1[Ct/Cr(Mf-Mi)] Translation: Final Dimension = Present Dimension times the net of Change Coefficient (either tangential or radial for the species) times the net of highest moisture content less the lowest MC.
So with a 24" wide board of (real) Red Oak at starting at 11% MC going to 8% it works as follows, after factoring in the radial coefficient for quartersawn Red Oak which is 0.00123 that:
x= 24x[.00123(11-8)]
x= 24x(.00123x3)
x= 24x.00369
x= 0.08856" which is about 1/12" of an inch total change
If you were working flat-sawn Red oak, the coefficient would be .00369 or roughly 3 times as much for tangential shrinkage.
Black Oak's numbers are .00123 and .00230 so you can see that tangential black oak is more stable while both are equal in quartersawn stock.
You can find the coefficient values I plugged in in the US Forestry Wood Handbook at Chapter 12 available at the second link I'll post in the follow-up.
Hope this helps
Wood Species
Re: USFS *LINK*
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey
>
Wood HandBook
Re: OOOps
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey
>Forgot the last step.
Final dimension would be 24" less the shrink (when getting drier) of 1/12" 23-11/12".
Now if your basement is more humid than your shop, you should plan on the board expanding by the same amount if the moisture content change is the same.
You're going to have some seasonal changes, winter to summer, as well, but to calculate them you'll need the actual change in the MC of your wood when installed.
Thanks!
Randy Stukenberg
>Thanks, Mike. That's what I was looking for.
an unanswerable question
Bill Tindall, E.TN
>It won't move at all if the humidity doesn't change. I have a piece of flat sawed walnut 12" wide and in my shop it has moved less than +/- 1/32" over the past 3 years I have tracked it.
The Tables you will find are averages. So your piece may move twice as much or half as much as the table value.
And if that wasn't enough, these is some affect on response to humidity that depends on how much the lumber was dried during the drying process.
The bottom line is that it is best to design so that what ever it moves, it doesn't matter.
Oops!
Randy Stukenberg
>Sorry! I meant to type "Mark."
Welcome, but
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey
>Bill's response is also correct. The formula is an assumption and it ability to predict is dependent on information we don't have. Don't forget, if you seal the wood on all sides, the seasonal change will be lessened although not eliminated. You do get to see the difference in movement between plain and quarter sawn wood.
Couple good answers here
Ellis Walentine
>Bill is correct in saying that it depends on the variation in relative humidity within the wood, so your design should anticipate the high and low expected MC over the life of the piece. Mark's analysis will help you determine what to expect from a typical sample of a given species, which may or may not be typical. A few other factors enter the equation: First, the finish you put on this piece will retard the exchange of moisture in and out of the wood. I'm told that varnishes retard about 75% of the transfer (epoxies are best, in the 90%+ range), which means that local or seasonal variations occur more slowly than they would with unfinished wood. By the time summer is over, the heating season will start reversing the expansion trend, maybe even before the wood reaches its expected maximum dimension, were there no finish there to retard moisture transfer. (Do yourself a favor and put an adequate finish on the underside of this top to avoid cupping stresses in the wood.) Another thing is that the seasonal swings tend to decrease over time, like a sine wave that gets smaller over the first couple years and then stabilizes at this lower expansion rate. On a piece like a freestanding bar top, wood movement might not even be an issue.
Let us know if there are more specific concerns about this particular design.
Ellis