>I've been working with my daughter-in -law building three wine storage racks using David Mark's design. They are made of red oak plywood with walnut banding as a front frame.
She wants to stain the racks (her choice of color) and then put on a durable finish. The latest issue of Wood magazine has a table showing the results using various finishes. We think the shellac finish or the varnish finish would be the best choices. I've always put two coats of Trewax (with carnuba wax) on the furniture I've built.
Could I use the shellac finish and then put Trewax on top? The varnish finish might be more durable, but I don't want to deal with the fumes.
Please help. I don't mind experimenting with my own furniture, but don't want any failures down the line with these wine racks that she has put so much time into.
BTW this has been a great experience for both of us and certainly has cemented our relationship.
>Choice of finish usually boils down to moisture resistance, abrasion resistance, ease of application, and appearance. If you are allergic to fumes, that could also be a factor unless you get a vapor respirator.
For a wine rack, which will likely be indoors and dry, and which will not be subjected to abrasion or moisture, you can pretty much pick any finish that looks good to you and is within your ability to apply. Even your wax finish, which offers little in the way of abrasion or moisture resistance, would be fine, although wax doesn't add any color or depth to wood, either, so it tends to look rather understated and bland. Another thing about wax: properly applied, it dissolves and reamalgamates the previous wax coat, so "two coats" is really one coat. After buffing, all that is left is one thin layer of wax only a couple molecules thick. The reason to use two coats is to make sure you hit all the areas; you can do that with one carefully-applied coat.
Finishes are generally either penetrating or film-forming. "Danish oil" finishes (a total misnomer) are examples of penetrating finishes, because they don't dry to a hard film on the surface of the wood. They offer little abrasion resistance and not much moisture resistance, but they are easy to apply and dry dust-free and smooth. YOu can apply several coats and get a slight build with successive coats.
Film forming finishes include shellac and varnish, as well as lacquers and production finishes such as catalyzed lacquers and more esoteric formulations. They all have their place in the finishing arsenal, and they all have their pros and cons.
Shellac is not alcohol resistant, so if you use it, keep the wine in the bottle, not on the rack. Ordinary shellac, like standard orange or white Zinsser Bulls-Eye® shellac, contains a small amount of wax, which makes it more susceptible to water marking and possibly less effective as a sealer and barrier coat. It is usually sold in a 3-lb. cut (three lbs. of dry shellac flakes to a gallon of alcohol), which is rather thick and should be thinned with denatured alcohol for brushing or wiping. SealCoat®, also made by Zinsser, is dewaxed, so it is more acceptable as a finish. It comes in a 2-lb. cut, which is fine for brushing right out of the can, although still a little on the thick side. Shellac is not easy to brush evenly, unless you thin it down to about a 1-lb. cut or thinner. It dries very quickly, so overlapping brush strokes cause overlapping films that you can feel and see. It would be tricky, though not impossible, to brush shellac on something with a lot of small, intersecting surfaces like a wine rack. Practice is essential. In fact, practice is recommended for any finish you're using, especially if you haven't tried it before. Some craftsmen wipe on their shellac finish, using a rather thin mixture and a small piece of cotton cloth. This offers a bit of control over where it goes and can result in an even build if you do it right. A coat of wax applied over the shellac with some fine Scotch-Brite® is a nice finishing touch.
Varnishes are easier to brush because they don't set up as quickly, and your brush marks and overlaps "flow out" or level themselves into a nice even surface film. The downside to slower drying is susceptibility to dust, so you should take care to prepare your finishing area before varnishing anything. Vacuum up as much dust, clean overhead fixtures that might drop dust, etc. Don't despair if you get a few flakes of dust in the finish. These can be lightly leveled with some 320-grit Dri-lube (stearated silicon carbide) sandpaper wrapped around a solid block of MDF or hardwood. Varnish offers more protection from moisture and alcohol than shellac. It comes in oil-based formulations, which usually add a bit of warm amber color to the wood, and water-based formulations, which dry faster and are more "water-white" in appearance. Some varnishes have different resins in them that give the film different characteristics. Polyurethane varnishes are very popular because they are highly abrasion resistant compared with other more flexible varnishes. They are also somewhat harder to repair, should that become necessary. A relatively recent trend has been to wipe on polyurethane varnish instead of brushing it. This affords you a bit more dust control, since the film is thinner and dries a little faster. Wiping also tends to impart a "close-to-the-wood" appearance instead of a heavier film. This might be a good option for your daughter's wine rack. You can wax over varnish after it is completely dry as well for a smooth feel.
A production shop would probably spray a coat of lacquer on a project like this, as they do on most things. Lacquer goes on really fast and dries to a strong film in no time.
>Here is the wine rack I build a few years ago. Made of ash with a light stain and urethane finish. holds just short of 600 bottles. We homebrew and make lots of wine. Getting just about time to do the strawbery rhubarb.
>Ellis gave you some wonderful advice, but there were a few technical glitches. Please allow me to make a couple of minor corrections, and I will end with what I feel would be both the easiest and best finish for this project.
Statement:
"Finishes are generally either penetrating or film-forming."
Actually, they are either film forming or non-film forming, but that has nothing to do with penetration. Both film forming and non film forming finishes can penetrate or not, depending primarily on the molecular weight of the resin involved.
For example, UV cured polyester is film forming, and forms a thick, plastic film. One acoustic guitars manufacturer tried a formula only to find it bleed all the way through the wood to the other side. That's because the monomer, prior to being cured, was very small and penetrated very deeply. In contrast, wax, which is not film forming but rather stays soft indefinitely, usually does not penetrate wood well at all, but instead sits on the surface.
Statement:
"Film forming finishes include shellac and varnish..."
True, but Danish oils are actually thin varnishes, so by that correct listing, they fall in the film forming group.
My finish suggestion for your wine rack? Wipe on polyurethane gel. It is very easy to apply, can be built as thin or thick as you like, looks great, and holds up beautifully.