Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

hardwood flooring installation

Posts

hardwood flooring installation

#1

hardwood flooring installation

Rick in Colgate, Wi

>I'm flooring a small 11'x 12' room with 3/4" oak tongue and groove prefinished boards. I've done floors in the past and always rented a pneumatic nailer with staples. I was wondering if for this small room if I could use my 15ga finish nailer or is this not a good idea?

Rick

Re: hardwood flooring installation

#2

Re: hardwood flooring installation

Barry Irby

>I don't think the gauge has as much to do with it as the length. I used a big construction stapler that shoots 2 1/2" long half inch crown staples and it worked great. I ground the snoot on it so that it would fit closer into the vee at the top of the tongue. I loved it to a friend and he made a shoe for it that held it up at the correct angle and that made the job a lot easier. Remember that this technique does not give you a surface to tap on and does not drive the boards together. You have to seat them well before you staple.

The staples should be long enough to penetrate all the way through the subfloor. This is important and prevents or reduces what are called nail pops, where the nail backs out.

Re: hardwood flooring installation

#3

Re: hardwood flooring installation

Bill Earl

>Should work. I did an 8x12 entry hall in oak, purpleheart and jatoba that way.

The flooring staples were no match for the denser hardwoods, so I switched to the 15ga finish nailer & doubled up on the nailing schedule. It has been 8 years and there are no squeaks.

Re: hardwood flooring installation

#4

Re: hardwood flooring installation

andre

>I installed a couple of rooms with 3/8 prefinished oak flooring. I used a Bostich 15 ga nailer with a tip designed to fit flooring. I got quite a surprise when one of the 2 1/2 inch nails must have hit a nail in the subflooring and came back up thru the flooing and into my hand. The nails Ibrads?) just weren't stiff enough and bent right around to find the easy exit path.

The guy I was working with, an experienced carpenter of 25 years, got the angle just a little bit to shallow and the brad came thru the flooring and into his hand. Both of us shot ourselves within 15 minutes. I don't think this relates to just the 3/8 flooring.

Re: hardwood flooring installation

#5

Re: hardwood flooring installation

Bill Howatt

>If you do it carefully and perhaps put in some extras it likely will work but if you have a warranty issue guess what they will say caused the failure. Probably not much of a risk if your subfloor condition and dryness meets the specs.

Bill

Re: hardwood flooring installation

#6

Re: hardwood flooring installation

Justin

>For 3/4 you would want something with a head on it to keep the boards down, & a ring shank to hold the nail to the subfloor. I always worry about doing anything more than a repair with staples.

Peace

Justin

Re: hardwood flooring installation

#7

Re: hardwood flooring installation

John from Cincinnati

>Rick

I have installed quite a few hardwood floors over the years using air and arm powered floor nailers. I would absolutely not use a 15 gauge finish nailer to install anything but the first couple of courses that are too close to the wall to use a floor nailer. The 15 gauge nailer will only produce a fraction of the holding power of a dedicated floor nailer. You may not really notice for a couple of years but the seasonal movement of the floor and the slight movement produced by walking on the floor will work the 15 gauge finish nails loose.

I think the serated edges on a Porta nail type flooring nail holds the best but flooring staples hold very well also. If you are skeptical just nail one down with the 15 gauge and then pry it up. Do the same with the floor nailer and you won't believe how much more force it takes to get the piece off the floor. The long and short of it is that the 15 gauge will eventually give you a loose, squeeky floor that will make you curse every time you walk over it.

John

Re: hardwood flooring installation

#8

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

I agree...

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

>I've put down a few floors, and for 3/4", I will not use anything but cleats. And, yes, they are extremely difficult to pry back up without trashing the piece if you notice a defect too late (or screw something up).

Jason

Re: hardwood flooring installation

#9

Re: hardwood flooring installation

Rick in Colgate, Wi

>Thanks for the replies. I was able to locate a pneumatic floor stapler that I can borrow to do the job. Better to be safe now than sorry later with a squeaky floor!

Rick

Re: hardwood flooring installation

#10

Re: hardwood flooring installation

Hamish

>Over the last few weeks there have been a number of questions about laying hardwood flooring and how to nail them down securely. But I remember a few years back reading an article in a woodwork magazine about laying t&g hard wood flooring, and they recommended glueing the strips together to form a slab and then to leave a 1/2 inch space around the walls for movement. The flooring was laid over a thin foam sheet, the same type as used in floating floors.

Would this be practical and a good idea if the floor was to be laid over a flat concrete sub floor?

Re: hardwood flooring installation

#11

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Hardwood over concrete...

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

>There are two ways I know of to get hardwood over concrete.

1. Lay sleepers on the concrete (attached, of course), then run plywood diagonally (least chance of telegraphing seams), roofing felt, then your hardwood T&G. The downside is that you lose room height.

2. Glue down 3/8" engineered hardwood (it's essentially plywood with a thicker veneer layer on top. Be careful here, as I've seen products out there that use softer woods for the intermediate veneers, so they don't support the "show" veneer well--this means the top layer will dent easily.

Option #2 is by far the cheaper and easier of the two, but option #1 will last much, much longer.

Jason