Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

Festool Domino

Posts

Festool Domino

#1

Festool Domino

vance hough

>Looking into getting a domino by festool. I know that it is expensive. My question is the domino system as strong or stronger that a traditional mortise and tennon?

Re: Festool Domino

#2

Re: Festool Domino

ScottS

>I'm not an expert on this by any means, but I do recall reading that a floating tenon has strength "nearly identical" to a normal tenon of the same size... It was probably in some woodworking magazine or other, but I couldn't tell you which one.

Re: Festool Domino

#3

Re: Festool Domino

Jesse Cloud

>Hey Vance,

A Festool domino is a strong as any 'floating' tenon, which as said above is almost as strong as an integral tenon. There is also the benefit of getting a perfect fit every time.

The downside of the Domino is that the maximum depth of the mortise is 28 mm, a little over an inch. This is plenty deep for most applications (cabinet work, chairs, small tables, etc), but might fall a little short for heavy work such as exterior doors, large tables, etc. There are some workarounds for making deeper mortises with the assistance of a router, but then the advantage of the Domino is lessened.

On the other hand, its a snap to make multiple mortises with the Domino and two or four small tenons is probably just as strong as one huge one.

Bottom line is that I have built lots of stuff with the domino, some of which takes a great deal of stress, and no problems yet!

One more good thing about Festool, the used tools keep their value. When I see a used Festool for sale on cragislist, its usually 90 to 95 per cent of current retail, probably less than they paid for it a couple of years ago. So, if you try the Domino and don't like it, you can always sell it for close to what you paid.

No affiliation, just a fan.

Re: Festool Domino

#4

Re: Festool Domino

McKay Sleight

>I used the domino for the first time making a three tiered bunk bed for a "extreme make over" type thing. My students and I tried it out and found it to be very easy to use and easy to switch the cutter for the different sized tenons. We used it to attach the head board stretchers. Worked extremely well. I liked it, but I am not sure that I would go the money. There are other systems that do a similar cut,(maybe not as easy or precise)but for far less money.

Re: Festool Domino

#5

Ellis Walentine

Pros and Cons

Ellis Walentine

>Loose tenons that are tight and glued well are plenty strong -- I'd say at least as strong as a conventional tenon, although I don't doubt that some zealous engineering lab has pronounced one or the other stronger. In the case of softer woods, the Domino's solid beech loose tenon is probably a fair amount stronger than an integral tenon. And the fact that the Domino tenons are pre-compressed means that they will swell for a really tight fit when glued.

The depth-of-cut drawback that Jesse mentioned is particularly true for joints larger than those in cabinet doors and face frames. I would not use the Domino for larger tables or any kind of interior or exterior door joinery. For a full-size door, you need tenons at least 1/2" thick (5/8" and 3/4" are common sizes) and they should penetrate the rail by at least half the width of the rail. We used to build entry doors with 3/4" x 4" x 6" loose tenons -- way out of reach of the Domino. That said, for smaller work, it is a slick and nicely engineered system, like most of the things Festool makes.

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: Festool Domino

#6

Re: Festool Domino

Brian Gray in Sandusky, OH

>I'm on the road right now, so I can't look it up...

But wasn't there an article in FWW where they showed lab results where a floating tenon was stronger than an integral tenon?

I don't remember the specifics...just seem to remember those results.

And I own the Domino. Expensive, but I won mine in a raffle.

:)

Would I shell out the cash for one? Yep. It's a very nice machine.

Re: Festool Domino

#7

Re: Pros and Cons *LINK*

charlie belden

>I have to respectuflly disagree with Ellis re: the DOMINO being suitable only for face frames and cabinet doors. See the attached link - and the page following it.

Now to the strength issue and "true" / "traditional" mortise and tenon joints vs loose tenon M&T joints.

One of the critical determinants of the strength of a "true" mortise and tenon joint is how well the end of the tenon seats flush to the back of the mortise. A gap at the back of the tenon becomes the weak point fo the joint merely because you created a void leaving the grain above and below the void unsupported. THAT is where the joint will often fail, not at the tenon/mortise interface.

Now if you've made a "spit tight" mortise and tenon joint - with no gap behind the tenon - you know that it's hard to seat the tenon because your compressing air behind it which, because of the fit, has no way to escape (ok so in porous oak that's not a problem - but that's an exception to the rule). Things get worse when you replace the compressible air with uncompressible glue.

Using the DOMINO, with the proper depth of cut for the loose tenon you selected - you get NO gap behind the tenon - and - because of the grooves in the sides of the loose tenons - air, and glue - have a path for escaping - with NO compression issue.

Regarding the need for BIG BEEFY tenons - there are several advantages of using multiple "smaller" tenons - one being an expansion/contraction issue. The tenon is side grain but the top and bottom of the mortise is end grain. Wood expands more, in some cases twice as much, acrossed the grain than with the grain. Distributing the resulting forces over several areas of the mortise part rather than concentrating them in one area has benefits for the integrity of the joint.

Where loose tenon mortise and tenon joints have a real advantage over traditional/true mortise and tenons is when the tenon is angled - the latter gets into grain direction and strength problems that the former avoids.

I think some of the belief that "true/traditional" mortise and tenons are stronger than any alternative is based more on familiarity and tradition than on facts.

One must realize that the "old world" furniture makers made furniture for a living. And since time was money, if one joint could be made quicker and easier than another - well - guess which one won?

Think about it. One mortise and one tenon - the layout, sawing, chopping and cutting vs four smaller mortises and tenons - four times as much layout and four times as much work.

Loose tenon mortise and tenon joints couldn't be used because mortising end grain was a) more difficult to do and b) more prone to splitting the end grain mortised part. If it was too time consuming and/or too risky - well it probably wasn't part of the common practices of the trade - strength not even being an issue.

With a router based, template guided jig - like the LEIGH FMT and the MultiRouter - the mortising end grain "challenges" are eliminated, or significantly reduced. Side grain or end grain - the spiral router bit cutting the mortise doesn't care which it's cutting.

BUT - you've still got to do the the layout lines - though only the centerline/centerline intersection is required to align the jig - and its template - to the part. And you have to do the marking AND jig set up - for every part - not for each type of part - but EVERY part.

(OK, so if you are very careful and very meticulous, you can set of the jig/machine for one specific joint - on one end of the parts - in order to save some time. BUT that puts the burden on YOU to be very careful and meticulous when you do production mortising.

Put a wrong part in the set up, or orient a part wrong and you can end up with THREE identical parts of one part type when you only need two - and only ONE of another when you need two. Think Table Legs to Apron joinery.

OR - you can end up with parts that go together properly - but one or more of your "show faces" may not actually end up showing - and more significantly - may end up with the Ugly Face facing out - for the world to see.)

One of the many handy things about the DOMINO is it's Left/Right symetry - the retractable stop pins' inside distance to mortise center line is ALWAYS 37 mm (about 1.46" ). And once you've cut a mortise, you can use either end of IT to register a retractable pin to cut another mortise with a centerline exactly 37 mm away. For longer "reaches" to centerline, you can use the easily and accurately set "outrigger" retractable pins, which can also be easily set to be symetric left and right.

Then there's the Clamping Thing, the Fence Alignment Thing, the "Take This/These Parts OFF in order to mortises in parts that must be placed in the jig horizontally -THEN Put It/Them Back On in order to mortise end grain parts which must be positioned vertically in the jig - against a vertical fence which you not only have to reinstall, but adjust to make sure it's square to the jig's table top . . .

I've been working on a comparison of the LEIGH FMT, the MultiRouter and the DOMINO using a simple table with apron - joined with loose tenon mortise and tenon joints - as a real world example for showing what each method requires in terms of mortise layout, parts clamping, parts orientation and parts manipulation required for each.

What I hope to do is show what's required to cut the mortises for the sample project - with the important details clearly illustrated and annotated so folks who've never actually used a jig/tool or machine - on a real world application - can see and understand what is REQUIRED of THEM.

I then want to then come up with the time to do each operation, then multiply the time/operation by the number of times each must be performed to complete the sample project. A side by side comparison table of minutes per operation for the project and the total time to complete ALL the mortising will show where one is quicker than the others. By breaking down the time by operation it should be clear were one jig/tool/machine is "better" than another - objectively and quantitatively.

I also hope to include the little quirky, irritating things encountered when actually using each of these jigs/tools/machines that don't show up in reviews/evaluations - or manufacturer's instructions (for obvious reasons).

Any experienced LEIGHT FMT and/or MultiRouter USERS out there who'd care to collaborate on this project - with full control over your part of the comparison?


"DOMINO"ed Door

Re: Festool Domino

#8

Re: Festool Domino

Steve in Denver

>I've heard there is going to be a slight design change due to patent infringements. The steel reference pins are going to be replaced by plastic "flappers." Not sure when this is happening, but I highly suggest getting one with the steel pins.

http://festoolownersgroup.com/index.php?topic=3428.0