Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

Hardwood Flooring questions

Posts

Hardwood Flooring questions

#1

Hardwood Flooring questions

John T

>OK, not REALLY woodworking, but hey - there's wood involved....

Thinking about using the economic stimulus bribe to replace the ratty 15-year-old carpet in our living room (and maybe Dining room) with hardwood flooring.

I THINK I want solid wood, probably with one of the advanced (Aluminum Oxide?) finishes applied at the factory (vs. raw wood, finished on site). Hearing conflicting things, pro and con, about the bamboo flooring, and the "engineered" flooring products (Pergo, etc.).

My question is, should I even look at the engineered products, or just stay with real wood? (I think I know the answer to this one!). We have 2 small children and 3 big dogs, so wear is a big issue...

Any comments on Bellawood vs. Pergo (and their ilk?)

This will be on the first floor above a basement, and I think there's 3/4" plywood under the carpet. Is there some kind of underlayment I should use beneath the solid wood strips??

Also, is installation of T+G solid hardwood flooring something an above average do-it-yourselfer should tackle, or is it time to call in the pro's?

Thanks for any responses. Please feel free to contact me via email, if you feel this is not appropriate for the forum.

Thanks!

-John-

Re: Hardwood Flooring questions

#2

Re: Hardwood Flooring questions

Glenn Madsen, SF Bay Area

>We've been looking at similar projects.

The piece that I look at is "How long can we deal with having the main part of the house torn up?" The answer to that is "not really very long at all." So I'm looking at prefinished, engineered products.

18 months ago, we put down a panelized, no-glue, South American hardwood veneer product in my daughter-in-law's kitchen, over 60 year old vinyl (or similar) and concrete. I was there today, and it still looks great. Two of my sons did that job in about three hours. Bought that product at the Orange Borg. It's all real wood - just glued up into plywood. I'd never sand it down. Pull it up and replace makes much more sense. But that's likely 15 years away.

If the house is vintage style, and well constructed, then true to old style makes sense. True to 1950's California tract housing, though, just isn't needed.

If I had small kids, and could afford it, I'd write a check, and send the kids to the beach, or Grandma's place, for the day.

Re: Hardwood Flooring questions

#3

Re: Hardwood Flooring questions

ken raddon

>I have never laid it but seen it done a lot. Anyone could do it with a modicum of skill and patience. It really goes back to the previous post on how long can you stand the disruption and how big is the job?

I own a carpet cleaning business and would strongly steer you away from the pergo type floors. They don't look or feel like real wood to anyone in the business, (that doesn't sell the stuff).

Go with a wood that has the finish applied at the factory. Just lay it and love it.

Ken Raddon.

Re: Hardwood Flooring questions

#4

Re: Hardwood Flooring questions

Chuck Kettler Greenwood IN

>I put white oak flooring in my new home eight years ago. Finished with Glintza, one of the new high molecular weight finishes. Looked great, until my 3 boxers had to start digging in as they transitioned from ceramic to wood to carpet to wood to ceramic during one of their high speed chases. The damage is obvious in the right light. Something to think about.

Re: Hardwood Flooring questions

#5

Re: Hardwood Flooring questions

Barry Irby

>I have several thoughts.

One: the Pergo type products do not really look like wood, or feel like it and oddly, don't would like it either. they have a sort of hollow sound when you walk on them. None of this is really bad, just different. Not going to fool anyone.

Two: Some of those products are crap. They have a particle board or low density type backing that absorbs water. The finish is not nearly as durable as Pergo or the superior brands. If I were considering them, I would get a sample and soak it in water for several days. There should be little or no change. Some of them swell and get puffy. The edges curl up slightly and then get scuffed off. An effect not necessarily related to being thoroughly wet.

Three: If you use prefinished flooring, check and double check the finish. I used Bruce and the finish was crap. Wore out in a few months in front of the door to the deck. Now I am stuck with sanding away the vee grooves to refinish it. If I had known, I would have gone with some with better finish or put an addition coat or two on to start with.

Four: You can do it. I did it using a modified stapler that shoots 2 1/2" staples. It would have been even easier if I had rented a "real" air powered floor nailer.

Re: Hardwood Flooring questions

#6

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Don't do it, Barry...

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

>Sanding away the vee grooves is a LOT more work than you may think. If you want to do anything in the grooves, get a multi-head paint scraper and use a triangular scraper to scrape out the grooves. You could just do the worst of them, or do them all, it's still much less work than trying to sand off that much floor everywhere. Even if you do sand too much in a couple areas and get through the grooves, it's really not noticeable unless you are looking for it. The key is to work so hard that by the time you're done, you don't care if the floor is purple. ;^)

Jason

Re: Hardwood Flooring questions

#7

Re: Hardwood Flooring questions

Jim Dillon

>John,

I have no experience with the engineered/prefinished floors, but with my wifes help, have laid and finished T&G vintage wood floors. It is very doable for the ambitious DIYer. At the time, I picked up the book "Hardwood Floors" by Don Bollinger and it was super helpful.

Regarding wear from large dogs (we have four unruly 60-80 pounders), yes it can be a BIG problem. I have concluded that it sorta depends on the hardness of the underlying wood. One of our rooms with heartwood pine (a soft wood) is badly scratched, whereas the locust and oak (hardwoods) floors are still in pretty good shape after six years. While the finish (an oil-based PU intended for floors) remains largely intact, the soft wood dents from the dogs toenails. Hope this helps.

Jim

Re: Hardwood Flooring questions

#8

Thanks, I needed that........

Barry Irby

>I went to a lot of trouble to do a really good job installing the flooring. Very careful to do it well and staple the dickens out of it to eliminate squeaks. It worked. No squeaks after about ten years. But then the finish went to hell in less than a year and I have been Pi$$ed ever since. Just trying to work up the energy to refinish it. It is cherry colored stain on oak. The color is fine and I had considered scraping the grooves, but it was too daunting. Thanks for the advice. When things pick up a bit and I have some income again, I will take a shot at it. Come to think of it, I can sand the floor slightly and try to do the grooves, but if that does not work, I can always sand the heck out of it.

Re: Hardwood Flooring questions

#9

Re: Hardwood Flooring questions

Bill Roland (Mt Juliet, TN)

>About 6 years ago my wife and I installed over 2000' of pre-finished 3/4" solid Oak with Aluminum Oxide finish. Today it looks great with no worn spots. It is not that hard to install. We put down builders paper over the sub-floor, I did the nailing and LOML selected the pieces and laid them down behind me always leaving around 6" between adjacent joints. Rent a air nailer from the Borg or other rental place and don't get in a rush.


img

Re: Hardwood Flooring questions

#10

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

"Light Sanding" option...

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

>Personally, I have not done this, as all the floors I've finished/refinished were either new, bare wood, or the finish was long gone in many places. But, if the color is fine in the areas where the finish is worn, you could rent a floor machine (looks like a floor buffer) and get 16" or 17" sanding screens for it. You would just go over the whole floor with that, using maybe 180 grit (flip the screen after ~250 s.f., replace after ~500 s.f.). Vacuum, tack and put down a couple coats of finish. (I'd put down a coat of SealCoat first, then 2 coats of finish, just to be sure). If you're really motivated and use waterborne finish, you could be done in 2 days.

Jason

Re: Hardwood Flooring questions

#11

Ellis Walentine

Nice drive-by, Bill

Ellis Walentine

>You knew we'd all enjoy seeing your tasty Craftsman-style dining set. :-) Did you build it yourself?

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: Hardwood Flooring questions

#12

Thanks, Jim

John T

>Thanks for the reply, Jim - good advice.

We would be looking at either oak or ash - definitely something hard.

I'll look into the book you mentioned also.

Thanks again.

-John-

Re: Hardwood Flooring questions

#13

Thanks Bill

John T

>Thanks for the reply, Bill - will probably gear up to tackle this - that floor looks great.

One question -

did you really mean 6" between joints?? A bit confused what you meant....

Thanks again.

-John-

Re: Hardwood Flooring questions

#14

Thanks Barry

John T

>Thanks for the info, Barry -

Your comments are along the lines of what I'd heard and thought about the engineered flooring. I'll want to go with solid hardwood. Good to know we can do it ourselves (plus, it sounds like a good opportunity to buy some more tools!!).

THanks again -

John

Re: Hardwood Flooring questions

#15

Thanks Chuck

John T

>Thanks for the reply, Chuck -

I'm somewhat concerned about wear, as well, but it seems to me that at least with solid hardwood, sanding and refinishing are more of an option than with the engineered products.

Maybe some strategically placed throw rugs will keep wear to a minimum from my retrievers....

And it's gotta look better than the ratty carpet I've got now...

Thanks again!

-John-

Re: Hardwood Flooring questions

#16

Re: Hardwood Flooring questions

John K Jordan

>>Some of those products are crap.

>They have a particle board or low density type backing that absorbs water.

The Pergo flooring we are familiar with seems bulletproof. My friend installed it years ago and is still satisfied. He and his power wheelchair together weigh about 400 lbs so the flooring gets a lot of stress.

He put a piece of the flooring in a bucket of water and left it outside over the winter. It was as good as new in the spring.

JKJ

Re: Hardwood Flooring questions

#17

Thanks Glenn

John T

>Thanks for the reply, Glenn.

The house is a custom build, (we're the 3rd owners) and I've never really seen another like it. I think hardwood wouldn't look out of place (though the living room IS an unusual shape - sort of a lop-sided diamond).

I think I could tolerate having the room unusable for a long weekend while I do this alot more than I could tolerate paying somebody...

Thanks again!

-John-

Re: Hardwood Flooring questions

#18

Re: Hardwood Flooring questions

John in Calgary

>I have installed a small 10x12 room (our office, my wife had me paint it with six different colours of paint, then we sanded it to distress it for that old farm house look) full of 1x6 pine and it wasn't that hard, other than the crappy pine flooring we get up here in Canada. Too much of it was cut near the centre of the log, which led to cupping of the pieces and much cursing trying to get the tongue into the groove of the next piece. Its interesting how many people who walk on it ask how in the world we got it to curve like that - it is very comfortable since it conforms to the arches of your feet. This took my dad and I about a day and a half of steady (but not quick) work.

We also paid to have our 20x15 great room carpet replaced with hardwood for the very reason of how long it would take (at the time, we had a 3 year old and a 1 year old, so time was important). These guys pounded down all the hardwood (including removing the carpet and baseboards and cutting down the door jambs) in a day, and came back the second day to reinstall the baseboards. The parts they fussed with were the transitions to other floors (there were three different thicknesses they had to deal with, including our 1x6 pine flooring), the out of square stairway going up, the picture frame around the fireplace hearth and the final rows next to the wall.

Some observations from my own work and from watching these guys do our great room:

1) If you aren't going to stretch this out over weeks/months, rent a flooring nailer, it makes the work go very quick after you have the first rows down

2) under cut the wallboard for expansion before you remove the baseboards to give room for expansion (they laid the final row right up to 1/4" from the wall)

3) for transition to flooring that is lower than the hardwood, they undercut the backside. I would also rabbet the backside so you can overlay the jagged edge on lino that is probably hidden by the carpet edging (they undercut the backside so they didn't affect the factory finish)

4) for the final rows, face nail through the tongue when you can't use the flooring nailer any more. On the last row, they laid out the room to make it fairly narrow (less than 2"), cut off the bottom of the groove to make it into a rabbet, then glued it to the last full board, using wedges between the wallboard and the narrow piece to pull it up tight - this effectively makes that last narrow piece part of the final full board

5) measure, measure, measure, so your layout doesn't leave you with just barely more than a full board next to walls/flooring transitions/stairs/etc., and don't forget to look for wallboard humps (or else all your fine measuring will be for naught, DAMHIK).

John

Re: Hardwood Flooring questions

#19

Re: Thanks Bill

Dan Donaldson

>When the pieces come together end to end, you want those joints to be random and not too close together so that you don't end up with a line across the floor.

Re: Hardwood Flooring questions

#20

Re: Nice drive-by, Bill

Bill Roland (Mt Juliet, TN)

>Sorry to say I bought it @ Haverty's. LOML could not wait.

Re: Hardwood Flooring questions

#21

Re: Thanks Bill

Bill Roland (Mt Juliet, TN)

>That is 6" between joints in adjacent rows of planks. You don't want to have joints too close together. It does not look good and I am too old to remember the other reasons.

Re: Hardwood Flooring questions

#22

Makes sense now

John T

>I had originally envisioned a gap of 6" between the boards themselves.

I know the stuff needs room to expand and contract, but I figured 6" was overkill....

Yes, staggering the seams makes alot of sense.

Thanks again for the help.

-John-

Re: Hardwood Flooring questions

#23

Re: Hardwood Flooring questions

andre

>John,

I laid 1500 sq ft of 3/4" red oak prefinished with Al Oxide. Brand name Bellawood. It is not that difficult, as others have said rent a pneumatic nailer and get a good chop saw. I usually cut a bunch of small wedges that I use to keep the flooring off the wall for expansion purposes and to tighten things up when I approach the final wall. 15 # felt makes a good underlayment, some prefer rosin paper. Save the shorts for the closets in edges of the room. Ocean State job lots sells a kit that contains a couple of pry bar like tools that are surprisingly cheap and useful. Face nail the first rows until you get space for the nailer to operate. You will want a good dead blow hammer, a couple of blocks to drive the flooring into place. I have found the pneumatic nailer very helpful, especially when you are near the end of the day.

Re: Hardwood Flooring questions

#24

Re: Hardwood Flooring questions *LINK*

Ken Platt (Granby, CT)

>I did a couple rooms that size, and they turned out very nicely. So, you can absolutely do this yourself. One advantage to doing it yourself that you won't otherwise get is that you can match grain and color of boards. I thought of it as a large panel that I was making. I used Mirage brand, which seemed to be well thought of by the pros (I did a lot of reading, the Fine Home Building site is a good source)

I felt that the Mirage product was just beautiful, in my opinion as a woodworker. The boards were uniform, well machined, excellent straightness, and just spectacular wood. It is yellow birch, in the "natural" line, which by hardwood grading is probably something on the order of #1 Common. Lots of boards with curl figure.

I used a PC floor nailer. I bought a new one, and will sell it when I finish one more room (going to do Mirage there also, beech). I also found that having a variety of reversible-type clamps was very helpful for pushing boards into place tightly. I also second the recommendation on the Bollinger book.

Hope this helps.

Ken


http://www.miragefloors.com/us/us_index.html

Re: Hardwood Flooring questions

#25

Re: Hardwood Flooring questions

Fred Davis

>JohnT,

Regarding your flooring project, I read the many replies you got and thought one more wouldn't hurt since that is a job I have done scores of times in forty years of carpenter work.

You may not have heard all of this before , but trust me , it works, saves money, makes your wife think your a hero and the neighbors green with envy.

Since I read your going with Oak or Ash, and you are living with the work in progress , buy 3/4" V-grooved , end matched material that is prefinished or you go with a finish that is easy to repair.

That let's out all water based finishes, poly's and really only two live up to that standard of easy application and ease of repair.

A old line Swedish brand by the name of Glitza which requires their special primer coat to not void the garantee, this is a good product and spray cans of the finish are available for touch up of high traffic areas.

Because I have had to repair finish many times over the years, I prefer the oldest of all hardwood floor film finish which is shellac.

A novice can put it down with a six inch brush that will flow out flat and smooth the first time they try it. Repair of scratches only requires a brush stroke of shellac after a light hand sanding.

Drying time is the fastest by far of all the floor finishes.

I prefer glueing the boards down with PL 400 or 500 brand of construction glue which comes in quart size caulk tubes.

This only requires a blindnail ( I use a Sennco k model 1 1/4" narrow crown staple to hold the board in place until the glue dries.

The term blindnail refers to the practice of toenailing at a 45 degree angle above the tongue and below the top of the board so no fastners shows. This method forms a membrane with the subfloor and if the subfloor was glued down also , makes the floor system extremely strong.

This method also eliminates squeaks , it will bridge a gap up 3/8" of a inch , so the low spots in your subfloor caused by the lightweight 3/4" subfloor material used to span the distance between joists will not be a problem, later on.

BTW all nailed flooring sooner or later squeakes when you walk on it, can't be avoided regardless of the number of fastners used.

Fasten the first course of floor with very few face nails or staples in this case and a squiggle of glue down the bottom of the board and let it dry for 30 minutes and then have your helper lay out the boards ahead of you so you avoid adjacent joints, too many of the same length in one area and so on.

Before you start laying the floor allow 1/32" of side clearence to the walls paralell to the flooring for every foot of width of the room,then divide that number by two and leave that amount between your first course and the sole plate of the wall.

If your lucky the 1/2" of sheetrock will hide the gap and certainly the base will. B

Because the glue needs to stick to the subfloor, no paper is required or needed over the subfloor.

You need any more help , let me know.

FredD