Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

OT: Oak floor refinishing

Posts

OT: Oak floor refinishing

#1

OT: Oak floor refinishing

Dean Lapinel

>I have a red oak floor that had previously been finished with a water poly. The finish lasted a good 10 years but the floor (red oak) looked bland.

Time to refinish and I'm told:

1 That 90% of our state prefers acid cure (glitsa, precision)and that the finish warms up the wood. I believe that but the formaldehyde fumes seem to be a pain.

What is most of the country using?

2 That the acid cure can be top coated with water poly (street shoes)after 24 hours and another says after 1 month (initial finish needs to dry)Which is true?

3 Two out of three estimators say that the floor molding should stay. One says the molding needs to be removed AND the bathroom pedestal sink and toilet need to be removed (the other two didn't mention this)

Is there a right answer or is this just a preference?

4 No one wants to do a stain and oil poly (satin)...something we once had in another house that looked great and lasted a long time. Is this possibly because it takes longer (more work)?

Thanks for any advice. I could really use some guidance and the internet is not great for this subject and I was suprised that Fine homebuilding (index) didn't have much.

Re: OT: Oak floor refinishing

#2

Re: OT: Oak floor refinishing

Chuck in ND

>Staining would take longer because they would have to make sure every little bit of old finish was off the floor or it wouldn't stain evenly. Water base Poly dries alot quicker than a oil base Poly, meaning less trips to the jobsite, plus useing a flamable finish may not be covered in their liability insurance. When I did floors we prefered the baseboard or cove molding came off first, the toilet would be nice also. The cheapest bid isn't allways the cheapest in the long run. I still prefer oil base Poly for the durability and the amber color it produces over the years.

Re: OT: Oak floor refinishing

#3

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Ways to warm it up...

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

>...and still keep the fumes down.

1. A coat or two of Zinsser SealCoat shellac. The alcohol in the finish is a bit stinky at first, but does dissipate quickly (a matter of hours), particularly if you can open the windows.

2. Go with a good waterborne finish like Bona-Kemi's Mega or, even better, Traffic. They are considered "clear" finishes, but do have a slight amber color to them.

3. (This one would be stinky.) You could put down a coat of a wiping oil of some sort first (before the shellac, like Danish Oil, Tung Oil, Boiled Linseed Oil, Antique Oil, etc., or even Minwax's "Natural" stain.

IMO, oil finishes are yesterday's news...R&D is mostly in the waterborne arena if you want to stay away from acid-cure.

Re: OT: Oak floor refinishing

#4

Re: OT: Oak floor refinishing

Paul Leuba

>When our poly floors were refinished a couple years ago, the contractor strongly advocated a water based. Before I would agree to it, I did a few test pieces of the finish on scraps of red oak testing different stains and different gloss levels. We ended up going with Minwax Natural stain on the floor, followed by a satin water based finish. The resulting floor color is a close approximation of the aged poly finish, but not quite as amber. The original floor had 30 years to age the poly.

We are generally pleased with the results as far as the color emulating oil based poly, but we have learned that the water based finish is not nearly as durable as the oil based poly.

My personal belief is that for low traffic areas, and areas where the traffic will be carried mostly by area rugs, water based finishes are fine. However, they are not suitable in my opinion for high traffic areas.

Paul in Hunt Valley, MD

Re: OT: Oak floor refinishing

#5

Re: OT: Oak floor refinishing

Chuck in ND

>I would have to agree that the oil base poly is tougher than a water base poly. Another thing to consider is no matter which of the two finishes, oil or water, gloss is tougher than semi-gloss, and semi-gloss is tougher than satin, gloss is the most durable.

Re: OT: Oak floor refinishing

#6

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Hate to say it...

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

>...but none of that is empirically true. SOME oil-based polys may be tougher than cheap waterborne ones, but the high-end waterborne polys are quite durable (and they often come in a two-part formulation). And, among the quality finishes, sheen has zero effect.

Jason (refinished more than a few floors professionally)

Re: OT: Oak floor refinishing

#7

Re: OT: Oak floor refinishing

Dean Lapinel

>How about these issues?

2 That the acid cure can be top coated with water poly (street shoes)after 24 hours and another says after 1 month (initial finish needs to dry)Which is true?

3 Two out of three estimators say that the floor molding should stay. One says the molding needs to be removed AND the bathroom pedestal sink and toilet need to be removed (the other two didn't mention this)

Is there a right answer or is this just a preference?

Re: OT: Oak floor refinishing

#8

Pull the sink and tolite

Dustmaker Mike

>if you can. I am no floor finisher nor do I play one on TV, but I hate to walk into a bathroom and see it done half A@#ed. When I work in a bathroom to paint or redo a floor I pull everything off the walls and floor. That way if I ever decide to change a fixture I can do it and know the finish under it is the same as the finish around it. Just my two bits. Sitting in Rainy Eindhoven waiting for the weekend to head to D�sseldorf.