Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

veneer over hardwood

Posts

veneer over hardwood

#1

veneer over hardwood

mdrechnowicz

>I am currently working on a clock made out of quartersawn white oak. It is a sort of craftsman style tall clock with frame and panel construction. It has two panels per side approximately 11 1/2" wide by 17" long and 54" long. Both sides of the panel will show when the clock is completed. The orignal plans called for 1/4 " quartersawn sawn white oak plywood for the panels. I had some nice looking 1/4 sawn hardwood with great figure on both sides so I figured I would resaw it and use it bookmatched for the panels. When I resawed it however, the inside did not have very nice figure, it was streaky without a lot of flake. I was thinking about veneering the not so nice side with some nicely figured veneer but am not sure that would work. From what I have read about veneering, one should always veneer both sides of a surface to prevent warping. Since the solid wood and the veneer would both be 1/4 sawn white oak would this work? If not I was thinking about making my own veneer out of the good side of the wood and veneering both sides of some birch plywood. Would this be a better approach? I have a drum sander so sanding down the resawn wood is not a problem. I'm also open to any other ideas.

Thanks,

Mike

Re: veneer over hardwood

#2

Re: veneer over hardwood

Tony - Memphis

>I don't see why it wouldn't work. Since the veneer and the solid wood are not exactly the same, there may be a bit of difference in the expansion and contraction rates (ie one may be slightly flat sawn and the other quarter sawn). I don't adhere to the veneer both sides philosophy personally. I've done several panels on one side only and never had any issues. I don't have any experience "veneering" with wood as thick as what you are describing though, so, hopefully, someone else here has and can chime in. Good luck with your project. Of course, another option is to buy some nice thin veneer and veneer on a stable substrate such as mdf or some nice baltic birch. How about a report and picture when you get done? Sounds like a neat project. One last thought, you might try posting at the Vacupress sight forum. Daryl has done it all and is very helpful.

Tony

Re: veneer over hardwood

#3

Re: veneer over hardwood

Ed Mulligan, Cape Cod

>True, it is best to balance a panel by veneering both sides. If the panel is unsupported plywood, say for a table leaf, it will surely warp if only one side is veneered.

But your panels are supported within a frame which will negate any tendency to warp. I think if you use yellow glue which has some �give� to it you will be OK. A rigid glue might cause problems. Definitely run the veneer grain the same as the panel.

Birch ply veneered on both sides would be more work at this point but if you went this way you could glue the plywood panel in place making the frame much stronger.

Ed

Re: veneer over hardwood

#4

Re: veneer over hardwood

Brian in Sandusky, OH

>Veneer both sides, keep the grain of the veneer in the same direction of the substrate, and you'll be fine.

Re: veneer over hardwood

#5

Ellis Walentine

In this case...

Ellis Walentine

>...I think you could get away with the one-sided veneering/lamination idea. I'm not saying that the panels won't tend to cup -- which they probably will because of the differing thicknesses of your laminates and the presence of that glue layer between them -- but as someone mentioned, your frame will keep the panels flat as long as the frame members are stiff enough to overcome any cupping forces in the panels. I have done this on occasion and gotten away with it. You just need to deal with engineering conditions one project at a time.

If you have time, you could conduct a one-sided veneering experiment. Make up a sample panel, but don't put a finish on it or put it in a frame. Subject it to different moisture conditions and see how it behaves. If it cups, see how much force it takes to flatten it; then decide if your T&G frame arrangement is strong enough to exert that force. If it is a Craftsman style design, it should be plenty sturdy enough.

There is a classic Roycrofter tall clock in the South mezzanine of the Grove Park Inn in Asheville, NC that probably experiences a lot of swings in humidity in the course of the year, and its panels look perfect after almost a hundred years. Here are a couple shots I took of that clock and the inscription on the front panel. What an inspirational piece of furniture!

Ellis Walentine, Host



Ellis Walentine, Host