>A friend has two natural edge slabs that he is preparing as table tops (coffee table and sofa table). The redwood (California) one has most of the bark intact; the maple piece (some curl, some burl, some bird's eye) has some bark inclusions in the interior knots, but most of the edge is bark free.
I suggested finishing by wiping on a thinned Shellac (Seal Coat), and likely brushing the rougher edges. Since one will be a coffee table, it may need more than shellac for durability. So I suggested poly over top of that. A second option, as I have read Ellis suggest in other posts, is to leave it as a shellac finish; the advantage is this option is the 'repairability' of shallac.
So any specific considerations or advice for natural edge slabs?
>If you want to strengthen and fix bark, whether inclusions or edges, carefully soak with thin CA glue (turning suppliers sell it in pints and quarts). Allow to set up and repeat until it stops penetrating. Then sand and finish as usual. Note that using it in quantity must be done in well ventilated area, preferably outside, as the fumes are nasty while setting.
Other options: very thin epoxy resin, and very thin polyester resin (PolyAll 2000). Both made for wood restoration so that they will penetrate and then set to make a wood/resin composite.
>Unless the bark is tightly adhered, I strip it off and wire brush the edge. Here's an example of English yew with the bark left on. It's finished with a urethane modified linseed oil.
>I mix dry pearlescent pigments into clear solvent lacquer. The pigments are actually finely ground mica flakes that are treated to produce the pearl effect. Depending on the treatment and base color over which they are applied, a spectrum of colors are possible. The pigments are made by Kremer, of Germany, and they're sold by Sinopia.
>Natural edges can be treated any of several ways, but your choice should be dictated by the particular use of the piece. For coffee tables, dining tables, bartops, etc., it is important to work the edges so there are no sharp edges or spiky protrusions to catch on clothing or elbows or knees. Since those edges are also subject to a lot of contact and wear, I wouldn't particularly recommend keeping the bark, or at least not much of it. Redwood bark is soft and flaky and probably won't stand up to much abuse, even if you stabilize it. The bark inclusions in the maple are a different story, as they are not as vulnerable.
I'm not a big advocate of shellac as a final finish, especially for utilitarian surfaces like table tops that get a lot of abrasion and abuse. Polyurethane varnish is a fine choice, although to me it doesn't look as natural and is not as repairable as Waterlox or other tung oil/phenolic resin varnishes. These other varnishes are softer and more flexible than poly, so they will acquire a duller appearance with extended use. The customer should be the one to decide how the table will be cared for and what kind of personality they want in the look and feel. To me, natural-edged tables call for natural-looking, close-to-the -wood finishes. I've seen a lot of redwood slabs with heavily built film finishes and they look too plastic for my taste.
I suggest you (or your friend?) prepare a few samples and see what you like best.
Here is a picture of a natural edge 32-year old kitchen table (2 inch x 3 x 6 feet) of ours made from oak. The only finish the table has seen is Watco Danish oil. I'm sure no expert in this, but seems to me that the basic integrity of the bark/wood interface is more important than the finish used. Haven't put a fresh coat of Watco finish on this table in probably 10 years, so it is a little dingy looking right now. Hope this give you another perspective.