Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

Glue-up disaster (long) and a couple of questions!

Posts

Glue-up disaster (long) and a couple of questions!

#1

Glue-up disaster (long) and a couple of questions!

lee beeden

>I'm basically building my own version of this table( see pic). 4x4 legs, a solid 2 1/4" Birch top and I will also be painting the bottom.

Everything has been going just fine. yesterday I glued the front and back legs together with the short apron. Today its the two long aprons, to make the table a whole; and thats where the problems started.

I did a dry run and everything went ok. Because of the lack of long clamps I had to clamp from the drawer openings back to the legs for the front apron; and also join clamps together. All in all I knew this was going to be a little difficult.

To cut a long story short I wasn't quick enough and couldn't close a nasty gap on the front stretcher where the tenons enter the 4x4( back was ok), The glue had made everything swell!!!

As I said I was clamping from the drawer openings for the front stretcher.

One more turn of the clamp in desperation and I ripped a massive chunk off the opening on the front apron. Damm!!!

Then it was decision time, do I try to glue it back on...............No it would look terrible.

I quickly grabbed my mallet and smashed the front apron out, taking a chunk out of the 4x4 leg on the front side, just where the apron enters the mortise. Double Damm!!!

I think I can glue this back on but there is a chunk missing

So here are a couple of questions:

I came in for a cuppa and realized all the glue is now dry in the mortises. Glue doesn't stick to glue. Now that the leg is attached to the side and back apron its going to be difficult to work on. What would you do for the next glue up( i used regular yellow glue)

I have to fix that piece back on to the 4x4 leg which leaves a chunk missing, what would you fill it with? It is going to be painted.

Any feed back would be greatly appreciated.

thanks

Lee


img

Re: Glue-up disaster (long) and a couple of questions!

#2

Re: Glue-up disaster (long) and a couple of questi

Grant in Iowa

>Lee,

I don't know what to tell you to do now, but when I have something with many glue joints to glue up, I usually do it in stages.

On that type item, I'd start by gluing the first 4-6 pieces to go together, and then just dry fit everything else. Once the glue dries, take those joints back apart and glue another 4-6 joints and so on until everything is glued.

Another option is to glue up subassemblies such as the end leg assemblies, let them dry and then stretchers in the center and so on.

Just because you put it all together to align the first few glue joints doesn't mean all of it has to be glued at one time.

FWIW,

Grant in Iowa

Re: Glue-up disaster (long) and a couple of questions!

#3

Dale Lenz

Re: Glue-up disaster (long) and a couple of questi

Dale Lenz

>Lee,

If you are using pipe clamps, have the pipes threaded on both ends and get some pipe couplers, two female threaded thingys. Screw the pipes together until you have a long enough clamp.

I believe I'd attempt the glue up the following way: label your table ends North and South to keep this simple. Glue the M & T on the North end and drive home with a mallet, North end on floor, while you drive the South end. Very quickly glue the same on the South end and put the clamps on and squeeze up. Obviously, do a/two dry run first.

Good luck and let us know how it comes out.

Re: Glue-up disaster (long) and a couple of questions!

#4

Re: Glue-up disaster (long) and a couple of questi

Ralph Turney

>I don't know how to tell you this Grant, but he did do it in stages and still had problems...did you read his post?

"Lee,

I don't know what to tell you to do now, but when I have something with many glue joints to glue up, I usually do it in stages.

On that type item, I'd start by gluing the first 4-6 pieces to go together, and then just dry fit everything else. Once the glue dries, take those joints back apart and glue another 4-6 joints and so on until everything is glued.

Another option is to glue up subassemblies such as the end leg assemblies, let them dry and then stretchers in the center and so on.

Just because you put it all together to align the first few glue joints doesn't mean all of it has to be glued at one time.

FWIW,

Grant in Iowa"

Re: Glue-up disaster (long) and a couple of questions!

#5

Re: Glue-up disaster (long) and a couple of questi

Ken Platt (Granby, CT)

>Lee, I'm not entirely sure I'm getting the picture here, but the glue question has a couple solutions. One, sand the glue off. Piece of scrap a bit shorter and thinner than the mortise, wrap sandpaper around it, go to town. Sure, there'll be some glue left at the deepest reach of the mortise, but I don't think it should matter that much. If you actually have gobs of glue in there, start with a chisel. Or, use epoxy. It should stick to the glue ok.

As for filling a missing chunk, I assume you mean something substantial-sized? When I have one of these, I chisel out the missing section square, find as good a match for grain and color as I can, and cut a piece to go in. Since you are painting, you don't need to worry about the match, which is the most difficult part.

Hope this helps.

Ken

Re: Glue-up disaster (long) and a couple of questions!

#6

Re: Glue-up disaster (long) and a couple of questi

Jesse Cloud

>Hey Lee,

What a bummer!

Here's my two cents worth...

Sounds like you may be making your joinery too tight. M&T should fit together with firm hand pressure. If you need a mallet to drive the tenon home, its too tight and you might want to sand off a tiny bit of that tenon.

If you jury rig a patch, you will always be dissatisfied with that piece. Use a bandsaw to cut the damaged leg from the apron, cutting off the tenon as well. Make a new leg and connect to that apron with a floating tenon. Make a new front apron, too.

Re: Glue-up disaster (long) and a couple of questions!

#7

Re: Glue-up disaster (long) and a couple of questi

Glenn Madsen, SF Bay Area

>Been there. Done that. Lotsa tshirts in the drawer. They make decent shellac pads, eventually.

Several areas of good news:

Paint covers a bunch of sins and errors. So does a product called FixAll. It's really a patching plaster, but under the paint, only you will know. We will, too, but only if you own up to it here. It's not usually part of my furniture projects, but there's almost always a box of it in the shop. Dries hard. Sands well. Prime it first, but then you'll want to prime before the paint anyway.

On the glueup, I'd use a slow setting glue, with more open time. Titebond Extend is plenty strong for what you're up to. Similar chemistry to Original, but much slower set time. Gives you time to fuss with complex forms. I'd still glue up in steps, though, like you mentioned. You might even try a liquid hide glue, too. They can be reopened with a little heat or steam.

Band clamps. You can make your own, or use the kind the hardware store sells for tying down loads in the pickup truck. Or use cord to wrap around the outside, and twist a stick through to tighten. You don't need $200 worth of Besseys every time. They're nice, though.

Keep at this. It's a nice looking project. No need for it to be rev2 firewood.

Re: Glue-up disaster (long) and a couple of questions!

#8

Re: Glue-up disaster (long) and a couple of questi

Dean J in MN

>Long open time, and the ability to reverse (rather than break apart your table) glue?

Hide glue.