Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

The satisfaction of discovering... (long)

Posts

The satisfaction of discovering... (long)

#1

The satisfaction of discovering... (long)

Brint in Richmond, VA

>...that this relatively inexperienced hobbyist can actually work wood with hand tools. ;-)

First, let me say that in the relatively short time I've been playing at woodworking, I've never been terribly satisfied with my handwork. The fences and miter slots on power tools have always offered a quicker (and surer) promise of a straight line, and though I would like to improve my hand tool skills, I get frustrated when I do poorly and there's no one else in my garage at the moment I can turn to and ask for advice on technique, etc. So the power tools tend to be my default choice.

Today, however, I was trying to cut scarf joints in 8-foot-long 2x8's for the fascia on my new workshop, and my little Delta chop saw just couldn't handle something that wide. The tablesaw is still packed away (waiting for me to get the shop ready to move it in), so I figured I'd have to try to hand saw the scarf.

Even though I went slowly with the hand saw and checked the cut line on both sides as I progressed, the results on that first board weren't pretty. I managed a fairly pronounced "sweep" away from the cut line by the time I got to the bottom edge. Of course, I couldn't be sure of sawing the exact same sweep on the matching board, so with expectations of myself at a pretty low level, I pulled the not-terribly-sharp Stanley block plane from one of the moving boxes (haven't yet found the box with the stones and sandpaper). What the heck, I thought -- I don't have anything to lose by trying.

Luckily, my Workmate (which I rarely use for anything more than just a horizontal storage surface) was available, so I clamped the board on its edge and started hitting that scarf cut with the block plane. And then -- miraculously! -- the profile actually began creeping toward the cut line! Even with a less-than-scary-sharp blade, I was able to shave off the end grain without too much difficulty. By the time I was finished, I actually had a perfect (by framing standards, anyway) 45-degree scarf cut along the end of the board, with the cut line barely visible at the edge on both sides. And it was straight, too!

Now, I know this isn't as impressive as building a Queen Anne secretary, but I was just so, well, satisfied -- and kind of proud, in a humble sort of way -- to discover that hand tools could produce results every bit as precise as power tools. And in MY hands, no less! I'm definitely looking forward to practicing some more after I get the rest of the boxes unpacked. But since I didn't think my wife would quite appreciate my epiphany, I decided to blather on about it here, instead. Thanks for listening/reading.

Re: The satisfaction of discovering... (long)

#2

Re: The satisfaction of discovering... (long)

Carol - now in NC Nebraska

>Ah....

The sweet satisfaction of success. Enjoy.

And congratulations.

Re: The satisfaction of discovering... (long)

#3

Ellis Walentine

It gets better

Ellis Walentine

>Brint, congratulations on your "aha" moment and your newfound motivation to play with hand tools (and for sharing your experience here). It only gets better, the more you learn and the more you practice. It sounds like that plane of yours was nice and sharp; otherwise things might not have gone so quickly or so well. Truly sharp tools make all the difference.

Keep up the good work.

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: The satisfaction of discovering... (long)

#4

fitting vs assembly

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>For years I cut out wood parts with power tools and then assembled the results. Then I watched students at College of Redwoods fitting parts together by removing tiny increments of wood with hand tools and achieving perfect fitting results.

My, and probably others, failure with hand tools was a result of not knowing how sharp hand tools had to be, nor how to get here.

So if your aren't using planes and chisels to fit things together, learn to sharpen. the rest will come easy.

Re: The satisfaction of discovering... (long)

#5

Re: The satisfaction of discovering... (long)

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>It's not about the final product. It's about the journey that gets you there. Enjoy it.

Tom

Re: The satisfaction of discovering... (long)

#6

Re: The satisfaction of discovering... (long)

charlie belden

>In most instances, power tools will do the job quicker and easier - but WITHOUT any "AH" moments - the significance of which can't be

understood or appreciated if you've never experienced one - or more. Hand tools can be "AH" opportunities makers.

AND - hand tool work is STEALTHY!

Try using a miter saw or a joiner or router table at 10:30 at night in a residential area - on a week night. In my neighborhood that'll result in a "talk" with someone in the Sheriffs Department - which could lead to an "AH SH*T!" moment - hours - or days - in a holding cell.

I see several shooting boards in your future.

Many curlies to you - and maybe a few "one sided" curlies when you get everything sharp, tuned and set up "just so".

And wait a while before getting a lathe . . .

charlie belden

Re: The satisfaction of discovering... (long)

#7

Re: The satisfaction of discovering... (long)

Brint in Richmond, VA

>Great post - thanks.

And I already spend WAY too much $$$ on this habit -- er, hobby -- without venturing down the woodturning path...

;-)