Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

Dust collection on a comp slide miter saw

Posts

Dust collection on a comp slide miter saw

#1

Dust collection on a comp slide miter saw

Dan Mitchell

>I have a Bosch 5412 CSMS which is pretty good for chopping 2x4's (for the price, it should be A WHOLE LOT better at miter cuts, but I've yet to get it to do that very well at all ;-( Anyway, other than the inaccuracy of the cuts, one thing I hate about it is the way it spews sawdust all over. Anything that ends up in the tiny, 1.5" inlet dust bag at the rear of the blade is purely by accident & amounts to maybe 20% of the total production. I know capturing sawdust with any miter saw is difficult, even more so on a slide, given the wide area over which it can disperse the stuff on all the motions of the blade. Anyone come up with anything like an answer for this? I have a 2 HP/4" Penn State dust collector which I'd like to connect the thing to, if I can figure out a reasonable set up. Maybe some kinda sheet metal trough connector to the collector & running the width of the saw's rear?

TIA

Dan

Re: Dust collection on a comp slide miter saw

#2

Re: Dust collection on a comp slide miter saw

Chuck in ND

>Sounds like your on the right track. http://www.rousseauco.com/downdrafter/index.htm

Re: Dust collection on a comp slide miter saw

#3

Very interesting!

Dan Mitchell

>I was thinking of fabricating something out of sheet metal, a fair amount of work, given that I don't have a shear, brake, etc., but after seeing this, I'm thinking I could throw one together out of a carefully selected plastic bin & 4" flange for almost nothing and very quickly! The Rousseau one's $89 on Amazon, it comes with a stand (which I don't need) not a terrible price for the set up, but it really looks very easy to replicate. Only down side I can see is it's a bit bulky. Great idea, thanks for passing it on!

Dan

Re: Dust collection on a comp slide miter saw

#4

Re: Very interesting! *LINK*

Don Evans

>Dan:

Take a look at the ariticle here on WoodCentral. This is the way I solved the problem and it is still working great.

Once you remove the "bag" that is now on your saw, the dust will not be restricted and will flow out the rear port of the saw straight towards the dust collection port. The point being, even with the slider all the way out front at beginning of the cut, the dust is still directed towards the rear. Note in the picture that shows the inside closeup my saw is locked at it's move "down" position, if I ever rebuild this thing I'll move the rear dust port up about an inch.

Also, I used 1/4" plywood for top and bottom, I'd use 1/2" next time, it's just that I had this on hand and never expected the first attempt to last 5 plus years so far.

Don


Miter dust hood

Re: Dust collection on a comp slide miter saw

#5

Re: Very interesting!

Ed Mulligan, Cape Cod

>I have a Downdrafter and am satisfied with its performance. It has a 4" dust port. I think if the dust port were larger (and the dust collector was big enough) it would work even better.

Since you intend to make your own, consider a larger dust port.

Before I got the store-bought version, I had a design in mind that started with a plastic trash barrel sliced in half on the long axis. FWIW.

Ed

Re: Dust collection on a comp slide miter saw

#6

Re: Dust collection on a comp slide miter saw

Mike in Savannah

>Dan, and/or anyone else with this model, I've been dealing with its inaccuracy problems for a long time now and have tried almost everything with very inconsistant results. Any feedback or ideas on this? Or did I just get stuck with one that was dropped on the floor?

Thank's BTW, for the DC solution. I'll build one like that for sure.

Mike

Re: Dust collection on a comp slide miter saw

#7

Cut Accuracy

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Dan & Mike,

Your accuracy issues may be your blade rather than the saw. The 12" blades (especially the fine cutters) are known for wobble and flexing in the cut, especially in hardwood. This is because they are thin kerf blades ultimately designed for cut capacity in a general construction context rather than extreme accuracy for furniture makers. I had the same problem with my Makita LS-1211.

Problem was solved by going to a full kerf blade that is much stiffer plus using clamps on both sides of the cut to hold the wood rock-steady. No more wavy cuts on my saw.

This is why the 8" and 10" sliding saws are known for their accuracy.

mm

Re: Dust collection on a comp slide miter saw

#8

Re: Very interesting!

Dan Mitchell

>Don-Thanks for the link, I keep forgetting about the WC articles. Looks extremely effective.

Dan

Re: Dust collection on a comp slide miter saw

#9

Re: Very interesting!

Dan Mitchell

>Ed-My collector does have a 6" inlet, which is divided into 2 4" ones with a Y. n you tell me the approximate dimensions of the hood on your Downdrafter? Thanks.

Dan

Re: Dust collection on a comp slide miter saw

#10

Re: Cut Accuracy

Dan Mitchell

>The blade is thinner by about .02" than the WWII on my table saw. Wish I could put the Forrest on there & give it a try! Might be doable by setting up a wooden spacer on the table, at least for testing, though off the top of my head I'm not sure they're both the same arbor size.

I have read elsewhere also that the blade may be an issue, but I have been reluctant to replace it for fear of throwing good money after bad. I've also been told before the 10" is more accurate, at the time I got mine I wanted the most capacity I could get, since I wasn't sure I'd be getting a table saw in the near future, which I did end up doing.

It's kind of aggravating, I didn't buy a cheap piece of crap, the saw got good reviews on Amazon and in at least one magazine, it LOOKS like a very nicely designed & executed, robust machine, yet I can't produce a gapless miter to save my life. Awhile back I futzed around with tuning the various cuts using the "cut a wide board and flip it to double the error" method, I may try this again now that I have a jointer & a good straightedge.

BTW Mark, please tell me exactly what blade you replaced your OEM one with.

Thanks,

Dan

Re: Dust collection on a comp slide miter saw

#11

Re: Blade

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Dan,

I'm sorry to say you can't buy the blade I have anymore. Carlo Vendida sold JESADA Tools and the blade is a JESADA 12" 90-tooth 1" bore TCG Ultra-Smooth miter. You CAN, however get about the same thing. CMT makes a similar 96 tooth blade, and I seem to remember comments that Carlo was getting his blades from them.

I have no doubt that Forrest makes more than one. You might also check out the other makers like Ridge Carbide and Freud. Just be sure you're getting a full .125" kerf miter saw blade with a plate thickness above .095" (but NOT a .145 plastics blade or a bigger table saw blade). I would suggest you contact Forrest directly for a recommendation.

Hope this helps

Re: Dust collection on a comp slide miter saw

#12

In Fact

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>My blade looks almost exactly like the Forrest 12" Chopmaster #811869 carried by Woodcraft at $130. The grind is identical with 4 points and a flat.

Re: Dust collection on a comp slide miter saw

#13

Interesting observation

Tim Greif - West of Chicago

>When I first used my Makita LS-1220 CMS, I was getting what I perceived to be inaccurate miters on some picture frames. The problem seemed to be solved by making a bit slower cut and firmly clamping the piece to the saw table. I think the blade was actually forcing the piece to move, ever so slightly, when held with just hand pressure. I never gave the blade flex any thought. Hmmmmm - now you got me thinking. I've got a Makita 12", 96 tooth blade on it.

Re: Dust collection on a comp slide miter saw

#14

Re: Stock Makita Blade

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Is a thin kerf blade on the slider (LS-1211). Don't know about the CMS. If you have a mic, check the plate thickness and tooth width to know for sure. Thin kerf blades usually come in at about .105 on the tooth and less than .090 on the plate.

mm

Re: Dust collection on a comp slide miter saw

#15

Re: Stock Makita Blade

NickB

>I have a 10" scms (Makita 1011), and recently switched from the stock (thin kerf) blade to a full kerf blade. You can feel the extra load from the wider kerf, but I think the new blade cuts better and it is much less flexible. The Makita stock blade is pretty good, but the full kerf strikes me as more accurate.

Nick

Re: Dust collection on a comp slide miter saw

#16

Re: In Fact

Dan Mitchell

>Thanks Mark, I'll check it out. 130 bucks though...

Dan

Re: Dust collection on a comp slide miter saw

#17

Re: I Remember

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>"Jeez, I spend $750 for this saw and now I gotta spend another $130 just to make it cut the way it should?" I asked the very same question, Dan. But the new blade turned a construction saw into a precise woodworking tool. I, like others, made the "bigger is better" mistake when I should have gotten a smaller saw. But that's what this board is about, learning from others' mistakes.

mm