Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

Husqvarna vs Stihl

Posts

Husqvarna vs Stihl

#1

Husqvarna vs Stihl

Frank Orfanello

>This is probably like asking about table saws but...

I need to cut a lot of dead trees on my property and I'm thinking of getting a saw. In looking around I see a Husqvarna 353G and a Stihl MS250C seem to be comprable models.

Does anyone have any thoughts about these saws? or others? or chainsaws in general?

Thanks for your help.

Re: Husqvarna vs Stihl

#2

Re: Husqvarna vs Stihl

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>For me, reliability, ease of maintenance, and performance to the ability of the tool are the important factors. Though not the same model, my Stihl Farm Boss has satisfied all three criteria. It has never failed to start from cold on the second or third pull and maintenance is minimal. The bar and chain are easy to replace and adjust, and I haven't touched the engine since I've had the machine in ten years. And the engine has more than enough power for the standard bar. I wouldn't hesitate to get another Stihl.

Clint

Re: Husqvarna vs Stihl

#3

Jim in Burlington Ont.

Both good

Jim in Burlington On

>Can't fault either saw. Personally I'd buy the one you could get the cheapest. See if you can get a extra chain thrown in for the price.

Re: Husqvarna vs Stihl

#4

Re: Husqvarna vs Stihl

Howard Norman

>I own a small Stihl and a larger Husqvarna. They are both good brands of chain saws. I am not familiar with the particular models that you reference. If both are sold by the same dealer I would buy the lighter weight of the two, if they are sold by different dealers I would buy from the dealer who seems to have the more complete service department and you think will continue to be around for 5-10 years.

h

Re: Husqvarna vs Stihl

#5

Re: Husqvarna vs Stihl

Rod Peterson -- Ormond Beach

>For many years I thought the Stihl was the be all and end all of chain saws, although I had yet to own one. I just wasn't in a position where I could justify one. I remember when we had property in NC and were planning to move there that there was a Husky dealer in town, but no apparent Stihl presence. I asked the guy about it and he basically said what others are intimating—they're both good saws and the popularity of one or the other depends more on the presence of a dealership than differences in quality.

When I moved to Ormond Beach, I saw there was a dealer out at the edge of town who had both Stihl and Huskies. I still didn't need one, so I just filed the knowledge. Then in August, 2004, Charlie came to visit and I had a lot of tree on my roof that needed getting off soon. I went to the dealer and learned that although they could still service Stihl they no longer carried them. So, I bought a Husqvarna.

I really don't have any complaints about it other than the first time I used it I could not get it started. It seems that listening to the dealer explain the procedure and also reading it properly in the manual are very useful parts of the process and failure to do so is not the fault of the machine. I haven't had a problem since, and the saw works just fine. I subsequently bought a Husky leaf blower, which is a first class piece of gear, too.

A couple of years ago, I discovered a Stihl dealer in town. If I had known about them at the time I would have bought a Stihl from them, although that would have been based on a prejudice I held for a long time with no legitimate foundation. I did wind up buying a string trimmer from them, and it, too, is a fine piece of equipment. Now I say buy whichever one is nearest and who can service them (although except for retraining in the start procedure, I've not had to have any done). They are both fine pieces of equipment with a good reputation.

By the way, Lowes is selling Huskies. I don't know that they're the same line as at the dealer. Might by penny wise and pound foolish to experiment, though. Stihl, on the other hand, is dealer sales only. I don't believe they permit their dealers to sell on the internet, either. Don't hold it against them, though. I think chainsaws are pretty reasonably priced for the utility and service they give.

I've had a lot of fun with mine. Worth every penny.

Rod

Re: Husqvarna vs Stihl

#6

Re: Husqvarna vs Stihl

Thomas S Stockton

>I've had both and what it really comes down to is what your local independent saw shop carries and then price. I curently have the ms250 and an 039 the 250 is a great little saw very light and nice power for it's size. A lot depends on the size and types of trees your cutting I find the 250 is a little underpowered cutting oak that is over 10" and i usually use my larger saw for things like that. Local loggers around here almost all run sthil a few use Husky but I think this is more a regional thing.

Tom

Re: Husqvarna vs Stihl

#7

Re: Husqvarna vs Stihl

John K Jordan

>Frank,

Deciding between the two, I think the biggest factor is the local dealer. If I had a good local dealer who sold one brand, I would buy it over the other.

JKJ

Re: Husqvarna vs Stihl

#8

Re: Husqvarna vs Stihl

David Best

>I put a Husky and a Stihl side by side,(comparable models) and there was a lot of plastic on the Husky,compared to the Stihl.

I now own 5 Stihl chainsaws, all "Pro" models.

As of today I am halfway through cutting 20 full cords of firewood !!!

Enough for 3 years.

Hope this helps, David

Re: Husqvarna vs Stihl

#9

try each

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I went to the store predisposed to buy a Husky. On a whim I cut a log with each and for me the Stihl was more comfortable. I still don't like the looks of it but I try not to look at it while it is comfortably cutting.

Which is most popular seems to be regional. This part of the world is Stihl country. It is all I ever see at saw mills and in the woods. Opposite where my brother lives in NY.

Buy the biggest motor you can afford so the saw does the work and you do less. .

Re: Husqvarna vs Stihl

#10

ebd

Re: Husqvarna vs Stihl

ebd

>One thing that I would factor in if you plan to cut wood to use for turning. Doing that frequently requires ripping cuts and that means lots of very long slivers rather than chips. The Stihl ejects these kind of cuttings far better. The Husky has a much smaller ejection slot and clogs. Though both are very good I still like the Stihl better. Can't say why exactly except that trying my brothers Husky made me appreciate my Stihl more.

Re: Husqvarna vs Stihl

#11

Re: Husqvarna vs Stihl

Dennis E. Peacock

>Frank,

I have a Stihl MS-361 Pro saw. Really nice saw and it will cut like no other saw I've ever had. I have been through 4 chainsaws in my time and as you do your homework, you'll find that make Arborists and loggers use Stihl...as well as Husqvarna. The pro's that I've talked with really rely on both, but Stihl seems to be a prefered brand in most camps.

Either one, when a proper sized saw is purchase, will do you very well and last you a very long time when properly maintained. Find you a saw that is the exact size you need and then purchase the next size up. That's what I did and I've never been sorry.

Dennis

Re: Husqvarna vs Stihl

#12

Re: Husqvarna vs Stihl

Curly Smith

>You might think about moving up from the "occasional use" chainsaw to the "mid-range" chainsaw if you really have a lot of wood to cut. There's not much, if any, difference in price but there is a big difference in performance.

Re: Husqvarna vs Stihl

#13

Re: Husqvarna vs Stihl

Dan Collins

>I've got a mid-range Stihl that takes a lot of abuse trimming trees and cutting firewood. I have a big Husky that I use with my chainsaw mill. Both brands work great. The big Husky was cheaper than the comparable Stihl, so I tried the Husky and it works great. I actually think the starting controls on the Husky are slightly easier to comprehend, but the Stihl does start right up every time. I have owned each saw for about 3 years. The only service required was that the chainguard broke on the Stihl. Good Luck.

Re: Husqvarna vs Stihl

#14

Re: Husqvarna vs Stihl

r payne

>I can't say anything about either saw you asked about. However Echo is also a good saw. I've had their arborist saw for 3 or 4 years without any problems. There are other good saws out there as well.

ron

Re: Husqvarna vs Stihl

#15

biggest motor

John K Jordan

>>...Buy the biggest motor you can afford

I think that statement should be qualified.

A larger engine does have more power but it is also heavier and more difficult to handle, especially if you have any physical issues such as shoulder or wrist pain. A lighter weight saw is easier to carry into the woods, easier to use all day, and I think much quicker at tasks where the saw is moved around a lot like removing limbs from a downed tree.

My experience: I have two Stihl saws, one much smaller and less powerful than the other. I reach for the larger saw when cutting "big" wood, but the smaller one is my first choice for everything else and gets a lot more use. And even though it is less powerful, it sill cuts even very hard wood well with a sharp chain.

JKJ

Re: Husqvarna vs Stihl

#16

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

A qualifier...

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

>What you said is definitely true when working waist- to shoulder-high. But, I've found that when working below waist level, the bigger saw is the way to go--with a longer bar you don't have to bend as much. Plus, even though they are more tiring, with a bigger saw, I can cut down and cut up a 60-ft. tree in about 2 hours because the larger engine won't even notice the medium-size branches.

Jason

Re: Husqvarna vs Stihl

#17

Easy: Stihl

John Weber

>I have a Stihl blower and trimer - EXCELLENT! My main chainsaw is a Jonsered, also excellent. I also have a smaller Husky chainsaw - average. If I needed a new saw, I would go straight to the dealer and find one I liked. They have plenty of models so you can get the exact features you want.

Re: Husqvarna vs Stihl

#18

Re: Husqvarna vs Stihl

Frank Orfanello

>Curly,

That's what I was going to do on my own, but the local dealer who carries both and has a good reputation around here convinced me to go with what I need. He spent a fair amount of time listening to my needs, wants and desires, and recommended these two.

Re: Husqvarna vs Stihl

#19

Re: Husqvarna vs Stihl

Frank Orfanello

>Thanks to everyone who responded. As suggested the dealer makes the difference. One local dealer with a good reputation carries both saws. He recommended either of the two. Another dealer who is closer and I know better recommended the Husky, he doesn't sell Stihl, but he says he does service them.

I think I'll see if I can try each one out.

Thanks for the great advice.

Re: Husqvarna vs Stihl

#20

Re: Husqvarna 353G

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Frank,

Note that the 353G has heated handles. Nice in the winter, but not much use this time of year.

My small saw is a 15yo Stihl 023. My big saw is a Husky 372XP pulling a 28" bar. Very different saws. If I were to replace them, I'd stay within the same brands, although I'd go to the Stihl 260 pro with an 18" bar. That saw has exceptional balance.

Consider the Husky 455 Rancher. Bit more power and more speed.

Either way, plan to run premium gas for smoother performance, and idle your saw for at least 60 sec. before turning it off.

mm

Re: Husqvarna vs Stihl

#21

Re: Husqvarna vs Stihl

Rusty

>I have a 394xp husky with a 38 inch bar.It is a great saw.all the loggers up here have switched to huskies.Made to run at high rpm all day long.

Also have a cheap poulan which I work hard does fine but it isn't a husky.

Re: Husqvarna vs Stihl

#22

Re: Husqvarna vs Stihl

John McGaw

>I have a Stihl Farm Boss of about the same vintage and also find it perfect for my needs. I took the step of switching to an 18" bar and standard-pitch chain about five years ago. Not that the old 20" bar and fine-pitch chain didn't work perfectly well but using a more common chain makes buying replacements easier.