Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

dovetail jigs

Posts

dovetail jigs

#1

dovetail jigs

Robert J Weaver

>Ok guys first time here. I am looking to buy a dovetail jig, was looking at the leigh jig 24" at woodcrafters on sale for $449.00 And the guy showed me the new omnijig 77240 24" jig $599.00. Just was wondering if anybody had either one of these jig and could give me some insight. I liked the omnijig but is it worth $150.00 more. I have never used one so anything you could tell me would be a help.

Re: dovetail jigs

#2

take a serious look at the Keller

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>vastly easier to learn to use.

Re: dovetail jigs

#3

Re: take a serious look at the Keller

Dick Coers

>I agree with Bill. The Keller is the best template on the market. Less than $175 as well. The biggest benefit of the Keller is that the fit of the joint is not based on the height of the bit. On jigs like the Omnijig, stock prep must be perfect. A cupped board will raise the comb slightly and the joint will be loose.

The second benefit of the Keller is that I use it upside down on the router table to cut the dovetails. Well, all except for cedar chests. All the dust heads towards the vac hookup on the fence that is a distance away, and I don't have to lift and fight the balancing of the router. I've used the Leigh, Porter-Cable, and Akeda. You will always get the most consistant cuts with the Keller.

If you do look at the new Leigh super jigs, look at the way the template knob clamps to the support. The twisting motion of the knob contacting the support will scoot the template if you don't watch it.

Re: dovetail jigs

#4

Re: dovetail jigs

Tom Rex

>I have the Leigh D4 Dovetail Jig. Love it. I've used it for 9 drawers and have not had a problem. Don't know anything about the Omni Jig.

Re: dovetail jigs

#5

Re: dovetail jigs

del schisler

>i have the Gifkin dove tale jig and find it very good I use it all the time I make jewelery box's and I find it to work's with out any problums You can see it here I bought mine from here also

http://japanwoodworker.com/dept.asp?dept_id=13640

Re: dovetail jigs

#6

Re: take a serious look at the Keller

Tony - Memphis

>I had a Leigh, but never was satisfied with the joint quality vs the price. I sent mine back to Leigh to look at, had folks at Lee Valley look at it, etc., but was never satisfied. Even the joint that the folks at Leigh sent back with it didn't look that great vs the price. I returned it to Lee Valley and got the Keller. I have been pretty happy with it. I just work around its limitations. I've been chopping them by hand lately though. Don't get the wrong impression, I wasn't looking for the perfect joint, but I decided that for what the jig was producing, I do as well much cheaper. The folks at Leigh and Lee Valley were great to work with. The owner of Leigh is very nice and very concerned that his customers are happy. And of course, everybody knows that Lee Valley is the standard in customer satisfaction.

Tony

Re: dovetail jigs

#7

Re: dovetail jigs - consider the AKEDA *LINK*

charlie belden

>When it comes to ways of cutting dovetails with a router and a jig or template there are plenty of options out there in quite a price spread.

If you want to have the jig/template dictate your parts width then there are a host of relatively inexpensive (relative to the LEIGH, MultiRouter or AKEDA) ways to go.

BUT - if you want to have a dovetailing method that'll adapt to your stock width then variable spacing narrows down your choices. The MultiRouter is in the $2500 bare bones, $3000+ loaded, but it'll do a lot more things than a dedicated variable spacing dovetail jig will do. That leaves the LEIGH and AKEDA. The "New" LEIGH jigs are "3rd Generation" jigs - evolutions of the original D4. The AKEDA is a "4th Generation" dt jig - designed from the ground up to a) eliminate the shortcomings of the LEIGH (support for the front of the router, a better clamping systems, better dust collection, NOTHING sticking out all over hell and NO fine lines to align to each other) and b)

easier and more intuitive to use (40+ page manual vs 163 page manual) .

ALL the variable space dovetail jigs share a common "challenge" - getting the router bit's depth of cut right - because that's a function of your stock thickness - despite what the OmniJig brochure says.

Attached is a link to a BUNCH of stuff I put together about the AKEDA - with some comparisons to the LEIGH - to support my opinion of the AKEDA.

Note: I paid the going price for the AKEDA and have no affiliation with AKEDA or any of its sellers. My money - my opinion - with facts to back it up.


More than you ever wanted to know about the AKEDA

Re: dovetail jigs

#8

Re: about the AKEDA

Glenn Madsen, SF Bay Area

>I love mine. It does very well what it does. When I need to do a bunch of dovetails for drawers, etc., that's what gets used.

It doesn't want to do thick stock. At least I don't seem to be able to get it to do thick stock. I either use a different joint, or cut them by hand.

Which is what I do when the DT's are for showing off on an art piece...

The Akeda is what I bought when Woodcraft didn't have the Keller jig I wanted those several winters ago... It replaced a now given away POS from one of the wood retailers.