Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

Completely OT, Patching a muffler

Posts

Completely OT, Patching a muffler

#1

Completely OT, Patching a muffler

Barry Irby

>My son's girl friend left her car with me for the week end. (she borrowed my pickup) As she pulled away she announced there is a hole in the catalytic converter. I have not looked at it, but it is a noisy devil. Honda Civic about ten years old. Is there a cheap easy way to patch it? What are the alternatives?

Re: Completely OT, Patching a muffler

#2

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

You could try...

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

>...JB Weld and a piece of steel. Sand both the catalytic converter and the patch steel with 80 grit for good tooth first. I don't think aluminum would hold up to the temps a catalytic converter reaches.

It would be a temporary patch at best, but it beats $100-200 for a new converter.

Jason

Re: Completely OT, Patching a muffler

#3

Re: You could try...

steve mackay

>I've seen the JB used before and it held up longer than it probably should have. Just forget that " tape " stuff they sell for exhaust pipes. Won't get thirty seconds.

Re: Completely OT, Patching a muffler

#4

Re: Completely OT, Patching a muffler

Bill Howatt

>You might check some places that sell auto parts for a pipe that will fit in place of the converter. They may have clever names that imply they are for testing purposes and the like since they are probably illegal. If you do find and use one, the car will, of course, not pass any emissions test.

Bill

Re: Completely OT, Patching a muffler

#5

Re: Completely OT, Patching a muffler

Gene Gauss

>I too have gone the "test pipe" route in the days before emission testing, but in my youth (long before catalytic converters), a split open tomato can and some baling wire helped for awhile. Depending on the shape, maybe the tomato can (or sheet metal) and some long hose clamps might make a relatively simple fix for awhile.

Re: Completely OT, Patching a muffler

#6

I'm at a loss......

Barry Irby

>I went out in the drive and propped the car up on some planks and slid under it. I still don't have an excellent view, but I looked at it and I felt it from below the engine to the tail pipe. As much of it as I can see and feel seems fine. No holes, no rust. I tried it with the engine running but the noise seems to come from everywhere and I am by myself and don't have anyone to rev the engine for me.

Is there a chance that it has some sort of internal damage that makes it noisy? Or is the hole somewhere on the engine and I have not found it yet? It has a sort of deep throated roar (for a four cylinder Honda anyway). I am waiting for it to cool down so that I can run it without the fan, hoping the leak will show up.

Any more hints?

Re: Completely OT, Patching a muffler

#7

Re: I'm at a loss......

Bill Howatt

>No experience with that model or much with any later models.

Look around the engine for any "heat ducting" that may have holes. This type of thing used to be common with carbs. Could be a bad gasket where the engine manifold joins to the exhaust pipe.

The noise usually is loudest where it is leaking. If you had a strictly internal leakage in the converter or muffler, the noise would be loud at the tailpipe.

You may have to "feel" around the manifold with your hands to detect the pressure pushing out if you can't see anything. Naturally, this is a burn hazard.

My dad had a garage when I was a teenager and I worked there summers and weekends - cured me of any love for cars and engines but I admit the experience has been very handy over the years. I had a friend, Skin Dickson, whose dad had a competing garage in the same small town. He summed it up best when I asked him if he was going into the garage business. "Only 2 people make their living on their back - a hooker and a mechanic!", he said.

Bill

Re: Completely OT, Patching a muffler

#8

Thanks.....

Barry Irby

>You Said.....

"My dad had a garage when I was a teenager and I worked there summers and weekends - cured me of any love for cars and engines but I admit the experience has been very handy over the years."

My dad had a farm. I pretty much got the same thing from that. I learned I did not want to be a farmer. There were some good and useful lessons, but I'm still glad I'm not a farmer.

Re: Completely OT, Patching a muffler

#9

Re: I'm at a loss......

Chuck in ND

>A roar ? Are you sure it doesn't have one of those exhausts the kids put on those imports nowdays ? LOL Sounds like someone was pulling your leg. Did they ask you to fix it ? If not I wouldn't touch it.

Re: Completely OT, Patching a muffler

#10

Re: I'm at a loss......

Dan Donaldson

>You might want to check the gasket between the manifold and the pipe. That can cause leakage.

Re: Completely OT, Patching a muffler

#11

Re: Have a potato?

Al Stokka - Cambridge, Iowa

>Barry,

You don't need no stinking helper!

Information gleaned from Car Talk, NPR, over many years:

While the engine is running, stuff a potato into the tailpipe. If the engine dies, the exhaust system is reasonably, tight. If the engine keeps running, the car has an exhaust leak. This will also afford you the opportunity to locate the leak without an assistant. Walk, or crawl, around the vehicle listening and feeling, carefully, for the leak.

Good luck,

Al

Re: Completely OT, Patching a muffler

#12

Re: Have a potato?

Barry Irby

>That's funny! I actually thought about doing that. Just wasn't sure it was a good idea or safe. I visualized launching the potato and killing the neighbor's dog.

My son and the Girl friend are out of town and I am not going to bother them. He told me "the Catalytic converter has a hole in it", but I assumed that meant in the outside of it as in leaking to the atmosphere. He's even less of a car guy than I am and now I wonder how he knew that. Did they have it looked at or did he just assume it? Is the hole and external hole or and internal one? And (I was meddling, trying to be helpful, thinking that if it were as easy as putting a patch over a hole I would do it and that would hold it until the next inspection which is in December. May be time to let them grw up and deal with it themselves, especially since I have very lttle idea what I am doing.

Re: Completely OT, Patching a muffler

#13

Wrecking yard replacement or Meineke+money!

Art Silva

>

Re: Completely OT, Patching a muffler

#14

Re: I'm at a loss......

John in Calgary

>Could be a broken bolt at one of the flange sets or at the manifold (same result as a leaking gasket). The bolts on exhaust systems can be a bear to remove without breaking them, so be careful about tightening up the bolts unless you are ready to spend the rest of the weekend fighting with the exhaust (you'll probably have to pull out your grinder/dremel to remove the remaining bolts when you break the first one).

Re: Completely OT, Patching a muffler

#15

Re: Verify it's the Cat

Brian in Brighton

>I would get it up on ramps and verify it's the cat. I tend to doubt it. The muffler is easy enough to change if you have access to a welder. A lot of muffler shops will tell you that they can't change a factory muffler since it's welded in place. This is complete BUNK! They want to make more money selling you a cheap tube set. Most small local muffler shops or little shops should have a welder and be able to change the muffler for a couple hundred bucks or less. They sell mufflers at auto parts stores and most 20 somethings that have ricers like the civic know how to change one out, since they put those annoying loud things on them.

If the cat needs to be replaced it's a lot of money. Probably over $1000. And I don't think they can be patched. It's probably her muffler.

Brian in Brighton

Re: Completely OT, Patching a muffler

#16

Not only that

Dan Donaldson

>The header pipe and the cat are usually stainless steel rather than the normal pipe specifically so that they don't rust out. One big failure mode for cats is running a mixture that is too rich such as having a couple of non-firing plugs that dump raw gas into the converter. This will usually plug it up and make replacement necessary. Other than that or physical damage, they seldom have problems.