Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

Finishing Cherry

Posts

Finishing Cherry

#1

Finishing Cherry

Barou

>I am completing construction of a cherry blanket chest to give as a wedding gift. For numerous reasons I had to use stock that has some limited sapwood in visible locations. Any suggestions as to the best way to conceal the sapwood and blend it in evenly with the surrounding heartwood. Of course I want to limit blotching in the process. Thanks for your help!

Re: Finishing Cherry

#2

Leave it be...just one opinion.

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>There are many opinions on this but mine is to say "leave it alone". It is very difficult to color cherry sap wood and have it look right. Eventually the heart wood will darken and whatever you did to the sap areas will have remained the same. So eventually they will look different again.

My opinion is to celebrate the natural beauty of cherry, sap wood and all. Apply natural finishes and let the sap wood be a distinctive natural feature.

Tom

Re: Finishing Cherry

#3

Ellis Walentine

Sapwood stains

Ellis Walentine

>I have had pretty decent results with walnut, but not cherry, for the reasons Tommy describes. Today's cherry will be brown in a year, so unless you want to anticipate its final color with your sap stain, it's a crapshoot. On the plus side, toning down the white of the sapwood will lessen the visual impact, regardless of whether you land squarely on the eventual color.

Personally, I'd try something here. Sapwood that isn't integrated into the design of the piece can be distracting. You can lessen that with a sap stain.

Let us know what you decide to do.

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: Finishing Cherry

#4

Re: Finishing Cherry

mdclor

>I seem to recall seeing something on this site where the designer had incorporated the sapwood into the design. Thereby highlighting the contrasting colors. Perhaps someone with a better memory than mine will be able to join in here. Does this make any sense?

HTH,

Merle

Re: Finishing Cherry

#5

Re: Finishing Cherry

Steve in Denver

>This doesn't really answer your question but it has a lot of good info regarding finishing cherry.

http://www.finishwiz.com/cherry.htm

Re: Finishing Cherry

#6

Re: Finishing Cherry

Bill Roland (Mt Juliet, TN)

>This was finished with shellac then wax about 7 years ago. I know I did not make the best selection on the wood but LOML likes it so it must be perfect. Ha Ha


img

Re: Finishing Cherry

#7

Re: Garnet shellac

Dave Mount

>as a general rule, I don't intentionally color cherry and I deal with sapwood as necessary by making it part of the design as others have said. However, if you have sapwood where it is distracting, you can soften the intensity of the contrast by using artist's brushes to lay down highly colored shellac (e.g., garnet) just on the sapwood. This is not going to make it match the heartwood, but it will soften the contrast using complimentary colors. It is also a pretty innocuous way to approach the problem, because if you don't like it you can strip it off easily. In this way, it is more forgiving than using dyes.

Be aware that not all cherry is the same color, both initially and after darkening, so you need to experiment with some scraps (and perhaps different colors of shellac) to see if you're happy with the outcome.

In a lot of commercial furniture they deal with sapwood by aggressively coloring all the wood. If one does that, I don't see the point in using cherry at all. The color of (relatively) unaltered cherry after aging is the main reason to use it in my book (I say relatively unaltered because the amber color of most finishes is an important component of achieving a warm color; if you use an truly uncolored finish like many water-based polys, the cherry looks cold and wan). If you're going to color cherry aggressively, you might as well make the piece out of woods with similar grain (e.g., maple or birch) and put all the color on in the finish.

The message here is that trying to color all the wood to blend in the sapwood is, in my opinion, undesirable because of what it does to the natural color. This is why I suggest selectively coloring the sapwood if necessary, because you don't mess with the heartwood in doing so. Again, do test pieces.

Plain orange shellac you can buy at the home center premixed (Zinsser is the most common brand), but it may not be dark or red enough for you. The more exotic colors are available from specialty suppliers such as www.homesteadfinishing.com or www.shellac.net among others (no affiliations).

Best,

Dave

Re: Finishing Cherry

#8

You guys make me look so smart!

Bill Hammond, Oregon Coast

>My neighbor is building and entertainment center out of Cherry and has had questions about finishing. I have been passing on information gleamed from here. I'll have to print out Bill Roland's picture of his work and show him. His wife thinks that the Cherry will stay nice and reddish-pink forever. Nice work too Bill, I see 'A cabinet to hold all my teapots' in my future. Your photo has gone into my folder of ideas to steal from.

Bill, on the Sunny Oregon Coast, where it's about to rain again

Re: Finishing Cherry

#9

Re: Finishing Cherry

paul in AZ

>Cherry is my preferred wood. As others have said, unless the sapwood seriously detracts from the design I have no hesitation in using it. Over time, the sapwood will mellow to a brownish color as the heartwood loses a bit of it's redness.

One thing I do is to use boiled linseed oil as a first finish application. Several wipe on coats pop the grain, accelerate and bring out the color change and I think facilitate the sapwood blending into the rest of the piece. Once thoroughly dry you can go to whatever final finish.

Tincture of time -a year or two- helps.

As others have said, if you are going to stain it why use cherry at all?