Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

Shellacing Suitability and Maintenace

Posts

Shellacing Suitability and Maintenace

#1

Shellacing Suitability and Maintenace

jacob

>I would like to refinish the interior and exterior surfaces of my front door with fresh mixed waxed shellac. It opens onto a porch so it receives direct early morning sun but is protected from the rain.

My understanding of shellac is that water causes it to turn milky. Is that from dampness and humidity (making it unsuitable for exterior surfaces), or must it be hit directly by the rain to be affected (meaning my door will be ok since it is protected by the porch)?

Previously the door was finished with shellac but I don't know how long ago. By the time we bought the house, the shellac had become rough, raised and scalely in texture. What causes that? How long does it take? Can it be avoided?

How long will a shellac finish last? How often does it have to be redone?

Please advise. Thanks,

jacob

Re: Shellacing Suitability and Maintenace

#2

Re: Shellacing Suitability and Maintenace

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Jacob,

You've asked a number of questions that I, not being a recognized (or even unrecognized) authority on shellac, can't answer. But I will still try to help.

"Waxed" shellac is used where a softer, more flexible film is needed. It is, however, much more subject to water damage. The whiting you mention is either the wax content becoming saturated with water vapor or water vapor that has gotten behind the film and is trapped; same thing can happen with a wet glass left of a table surface.

I suggest your first step is to remove as much of the old finish as you can. Since shellac readily redissolves in alcohol, I suggest you give the piece a sustained alcohol bath and good scrubbing with a synthetic wool pads. Once you have the old off, you'll be better able to judge what to do next. When it comes to reapplying a finish, you should consider a more durable option, at least for the exterior portion. Spar varnish is the weapon of choice here as it's resistance to UV breakdown is unrivaled among the finishes you are likely to have available. 2 or 3 coats will give you long-lasting protection.

The inside of the door can be redone in shellac if you insist, but I recommend a dewaxed variety like Zinsser's SealCoat or mixing your own from dry flakes. However, note that it's not going to be a very tough finish, and for an entry door you may be better served by using polyurethane, either oil based or waterborne.

I use a lot of shellac in my finishing routine, but it's never the final topcoat.

Hope this helps.

mm

Re: Shellacing Suitability and Maintenace

#3

Fully Agree

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>

Re: Shellacing Suitability and Maintenace

#4

Re: Shellacing Suitability and Maintenace

Steve Schoene

>For the exterior I wouldn't use shellac. Why do you think it was previously finished with shellac--that seems a very unusual choice. Old lacquer is often dissolvable in alchol so that test isn't all that reliable. For that matter lacquer isn't a very good exterior choice either, but I could imagine a builder saying--shoot it with something and hang it.

A lighter colored paint will last the longest. If you have to have a clear finish then go with a good marine spar varnish. Being covered so you don't receive all day sun means you have a decent chance of getting some longevity with the spar varnish, but you still should use one of the good ones, not one from the local home center. Good brands are Interlux Schooner, Epifanes, Clear High Gloss, and Pettit Captain's. Yes, these are pricy but will cost less over the long term. Follow the manufacturer's directions entirely.

Watch the door carefully, especially at the bottom where it receives more sun, and as soon as you see the sheen dulling, it's time to clean, scuff sand, and apply a refresher coat.

Re: Shellacing Suitability and Maintenace

#5

Re: Shellacing Suitability and Maintenace

Mike Fitterling

>I wish I had all the details handy, but I have read that there is a clear "paint" that does very well for a clear exterior finish. It is a mixing base, to which colors are addesd, but which by itself is clear. I have not tried it myself.

When I did my cypress front door I used a true marine finish that I picked up at West Marine. It was called WoodPro, Premium Wood Finish and was West Marine branded. It has held up very well; really, looks like the day I put it on and it has been at least two years. It does impart some color to the wood, but it looks nice. Also, any of the true marine varnishes made by the likes of Epiphanes, etc. will do a pretty good job--much better than shellac.

Re: Shellacing Suitability and Maintenace

#6

It's exterior Acrylic Neutral Base

Bill Hammond, Oregon Coast

>Try before you buy. In the can it looks like milk but dries clear. It is usually UV rated but I am not sure that the planned for pigment is not part of the rating. So without the pigment it may not have as good UV protection as with. However is is exterior so the moisture will not be a problem. Note that there is no yellowing from this finish. I have used it and after about 2 years it's still crystal clear. Our winters here are wet, it rains sideways and salty. About 70 to 100 inches a year and the finish has stood up to that.

Your milage may vary, not legal where prohibitec by law, you must be over 18 - 21 in some juristictions, if your wife finds out she will kill you, and other disclaimers..

Bill, on the Sunny Oregon Coast

Re: Shellacing Suitability and Maintenace

#7

Re: Shellacing Suitability and Maintenace

jacob

>MM,

Thnks for the reply. From yours and other replies I got, I think I'm gonna go with shellac to warm up the color of the door (now that I've stripped off the old stuff I find it's really rather ugly) then seal it with a good quality marine spar varnish. Unless you tell me otherwise.

However, your response brings up another question. I had heard that "the only commercially prepared dewaxed shellac is SealCoat from Zinsser" so I assumed the shellac I am using is waxed. The vendor couldn't tell me otherwise. But what I am actually using is dry flakes by J.E. Moser mixed with Bekhol, a combination of alcohols and acetate by H.Behlen. Reading your response it sounds to me like all dry flakes are DEwaxed. Is that so? Is that better for my door?

Thanks again, Jacob

Re: Shellacing Suitability and Maintenace

#8

Re: Shellacing Suitability and Maintenace

jacob

>Hey, Steve,

Thnks for your reply. In it you ask why I think my front door was previously finished with shellac. It's because it had a nice warm brown color and a hard, raised, scaly surface. My understanding of shellac is that it's the only thing out there that gets a hard bumpy surface when it gets old. Is that true? What causes that to happen? How long does it take? Can it be avoided?

You also mention lacquer is not a good exterior choice. Is shellac considered a lacquer? What are some other examples?

Thanks again, Jacob

Re: Shellacing Suitability and Maintenace

#9

Re: Shellacing Suitability and Maintenace

jacob

>Mike,

Thks for your reply. Once I got the old finish off the front door, it looked rather ugly so instead of going with the clear paint idea, I'm going to shellac it a few times to warm up the color and then seal it with a good marine spar varnish, hopefully the WoodPro you mentioned.

Thanks again, Jacob

Re: Shellacing Suitability and Maintenace

#10

Re: It's exterior Acrylic Neutral Base

jacob

>Bill,

Thanks for the reply. Please see my response to Mike.

Jacob

Re: Shellacing Suitability and Maintenace

#11

Re: Shellacing Suitability and Maintenace

Glenn Madsen, SF Bay Area

>There's no reason that the flake variety of shellac needs to be dewaxed. It may be either. On Moser's container, it should say.

A waxy shellac would, when allowed to settle, have a cloudy layer at the bottom of the jar.

A waxy shellac would be a poor undercoat for anything but other shellac.

You can get dewaxed shellac from a number of sources. I have used www.homesteadfinishing.com with great success. Jeff Jewitt's place.

Re: Shellacing Suitability and Maintenace

#12

Re: Wax On, Wax Off

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Ah, Jacob-san, problem you pose is a bit flakey, indeed. So . .

Merely because your shellac came in dry form means little, ancient distinction between form and substance comes to mind. Seek out the container label; if it says "dewaxed," the planets are aligned auspiciously for you. If it says nothing about being dewaxed, you have further work or more scheckles to shell out. "Buttonlac", "Seedlac" and "Instrument" shellacs are rarely, if ever, dewaxed. Many luthiers (instrument makers) prefer the wax content because the shellac is often their final finish.

You can make your current mix into wax-free shellac by carefully filtering it several times through drip coffee filters; the wax molecules are too big to pass and will remain in the filter. You will find that the filter will clog and need to be replaced before long; this is caused by the wax and any impurities, which will be a syrupy residue in the bottom. Of course, if you happen to have a bottom-drain centrifuge handy, that works as well. You can make this filtering process go a bit faster if you allow the mix to sit for a week or so in a clear glass jar. The dissolved wax content is heavier than the dissolved resin, and will tend to sink to the bottom of the jar as a cloudy layer. You can then carefully pour off the top layer. This won't get all the wax, but will help the filtering process.

Repeat the filtering several times until the shellac runs through a fresh filter cleanly and you're go for application.

I buy dewaxed shellac from Jeff Jewitt at Homesteade Finishing, however, I've also taken to filtering everything I mix before I use it. I have noted a distinct difference in the shellac before and after filtering with the "after" product being much clearer in the jar. Since I use shellac to both seal and sometimes tone a piece which is then top-coated with waterborne finishes, the purity and clarity of the shellac is very important to me.

mm

Re: Shellacing Suitability and Maintenace

#13

Grasshopper asks...

jacob

>Thank you Honorable Shellac Master. Student has one last conundrum:

Am I right to assume that because the old finish on my door was covered in small, hard, brown bumps, that it is old shellac? Is there anything else that also develops this kind of surface, or is a good way to identify shelllac? What causes it? Is it inevitable or avoidable? Why does it only sometimes occur? Why? Why? Why?

Grasshopper

Re: Shellacing Suitability and Maintenace

#14

Re: Grasshopper asks...

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>It is very easy to identify a shellac finish. Just take a drop or two of denatured alcohol (don't use rubbing alcohol as it contains a lot of water and may or may not work), and wet an inconspicuous spot. If the finish is shellac, it will almost immediately become "sticky" as the alcohol will redissolve the shellac. Lacquer (nitrocellulose) can be identified in a similar manner by using lacquer thinner. These are the only two finishes that I know will "redissolve". Other finishes polymerize and are not re-soluble. I have purchased several pounds of shellac from Talas http://apps.webcreate.com/ecom/catalog/product_specific.cfm?ClientID=15&ProductID=17400

The material has always been great and the prices beat any I have found on the web. They carry a variety of shellac - both dewaxed and standard.