Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

Steel Wool Tainting my Finish

Posts

Steel Wool Tainting my Finish

#1

Steel Wool Tainting my Finish

Ken Bellock (Houston, TX)

>Last night I was rubbing down this couch end table with 0000 steel wool, before putting on the third coat of finish. When I was blowing off the table with compressed air afterwards, the pores in the red oak looked a little darker to me. When I looked closer, I noticed that many of the pores were filled with little bits of steel wool, over the whole table... I spent over an hour trying to clean it all out, but still couldn't get it all. Am I doing something wrong, or am I buying the wrong brand/type of steel wool? I'm getting whatever brand they sell at the BORG by me. The finish is a mixture of tung oil, BLO, and polyurethane.

Thanks for the help.

Ken


img

Re: Steel Wool Tainting my Finish

#2

Alan Young

Iron + Tannin= Black

Alan Young

>Ken- Is it dark because the steel wool bits are just lying in the pores?

Or is the wood actually changing color? Iron will react with the tannins in oak to turn the wood black.

Perhaps switching over to a Scotch Brite pad will accomplish the smoothing action you are attempting to achieve with out leaving shreds of metal along the way....

Alan

Re: Steel Wool Tainting my Finish

#3

Re: Steel Wool Tainting my Finish

Steve Schoene

>Yes, the wrong steel wool for use between coats. If you want steel wool at all, what you want is made by 3-M or Mirkla and comes in grey pads of synthetic material.

But sandpaper does a much better job at cutting off dust nibs and other defects, and used on a sanding block can also help flatten the finish while steel wool just follows the hills and valleys.

Re: Steel Wool Tainting my Finish

#4

Re: Iron + Tannin= Black

Ken Bellock (Houston, TX)

>There was lots of little bits of steel wool stuffed into the pores. After spending an hour trying to get it all out, it looked like areas of the pores were now black, even though I couldn't see the bits of steel wool any more.

Thanks for all the tips, lesson learned...

Re: Steel Wool Tainting my Finish

#5

Re: Steel Wool Tainting my Finish

jerry

>Steel wool (of any manufacturer) should never be used between coats of finish. It is very hard to remove every bit of it and any that remains will show up as black spots right away of later when water vapor gets to it. If you must use steel wool use after all the finish has been applied.

Regards

Jerry

Re: Steel Wool Tainting my Finish

#6

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Also...

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

>...NEVER use steel wool with any sort of waterborne finish. The wool bits will rust and make a mess of your finish/project. As Steve said, sandpaper, or, if you must, synthetic wool (ScotchBrite and the like).

Jason

Re: Steel Wool Tainting my Finish

#7

Don't know if this will help....

Ron Bauman

>When you are done rubbing out take a piece of paper and wrap it around a pretty good magnet. Pass the magnet/paper slowly over the finish, lots of steel wool will come up. Probably not all, then unwrap and toss the paper and your magnet is clean. Then use compressed air.

Re: Steel Wool Tainting my Finish

#8

Re: One other thing..

Dusty Yevsky

>A couple of other things. You might be able to remove the dark stains by applying some oxalic acid mix to the table. You can get this in a good paint store. I've also seen a product called "Deck Brightener" that had O acid as the main ingredient.

In situations such as carvings and whatnot, where you need to use a metal wool, get some bronze wool at a marine supply store. A bit spendy but no rust or stains.

Re: Steel Wool Tainting my Finish

#9

Thanks for all the suggestions!

Ken Bellock (Houston, TX)

>Thank you to all for your suggestions. I'm sure the magnet trick would have helped a lot during the clean up. I'll take another look tonight to see how bad it is, and either find the chemicals, or sand it out and start over if it's too noticable.

Thanks again!

You gotta just love that sinking feeling in your stomach, when after hours of work, something catches your eye that's just not right....

Oh well, knowledge is expensive!

Re: Steel Wool Tainting my Finish

#10

Re: One other thing..

Jack

>This won't help this time, but for knockoing off dust nubs and scuffing the surface between coats of finish, for years I've been using paper bags! Fold one so a seam shows (either on the bottom or side of the bag) and rub it across the surface like sandpaper. The edge of the seam shears off dust nubs and other imperfections like a mini-scraper, and the coarse surface of the bag scuffs the surface adequately to allow the next coat of finish to adhere. It's quick, easy and leaves very little residue, which can be easily blown or wiped off. Best of all, I get the bags for free whenever I buy groceries.

It also works great after the last coat of finish, to smooth the surface before a coat of wax. I have pieces over ten years old that I used this technique on, and not one has shown any signs of the finish delaminating. With an ocassional coat of lemon oil, they all look as good as new.

Per the other comment about magnets, try using a stack of rare earth magnets, and a damp cloth rather than paper to collect the dust. Good luck, and if all else fails, sand it down and start over on the finish (been there, had to do that).