Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

Review of reviews -- Workbenches (Long)

Posts

Review of reviews -- Workbenches (Long)

#1

Review of reviews -- Workbenches (Long)

Ken Garlock, Collin County Texas

>To start with, I am beginning the process of building a real, beat it with a mallet, workbench. For the past 5 years I have been using my 'work door', an el-cheapo door supported by two HD saw horses. Two weeks ago I ordered and had delivered a 2 1/4 inch by 30" by 96" maple top through McMaster & Carr, and made by John Boos & Co in Effingham IL.

This whole process got me in researching workbench building.

I bought:

Making Workbenches by Sam Allen

The Workbench Book by Scott Landis

Workbenches,from Design & Theory to Construction and Use, by Christopher Schwarz.

The Workbench, by Lon Schleining.

After reading all four offerings, I am going to rate them as I see them starting with least rewarding to very best.

1. The Workbench Book, by Scott Landis.

This book is more of a survey of workbenches, than a detailed explanation. Yes it has some interesting pictures of bench parts, and drawings, but is short on examples that can be directly used.

2. Making Workbenches by Sam Allen

This book is a reasonable offering. It has many black&white drawings and several examples of workbenches along with parts lists. A person could build a usable bench using the ideas and examples in this book

3. Workbenches,from Design & Theory to Construction and Use, by Christopher Schwarz.

Now we are getting into the real thing. This book has many examples of most all the things you do or might want in a bench, and even more. Example, how often do your use the Crocher on your bench? Oh, you don't know what it is, well buy the book. Chris is also a big advocate of wedge and draw-bore pinning of M&T joints. He also give instruction for building a modern English bench, and a French style bench. Lastly, he includes several tables giving characteristics of those woods that can be used in workbench construction. This is a book worth adding to your library. Note to Ellis, your review of this book reads like a sales pitch at the state fair.

4. The Workbench, by Lon Schleining.

This book wins out of all for multiple reasons. It has many excellent color pictures of the benches used by accomplished wood workers. Lon looks at the individual parts of a bench in detail, and includes a set of exploded drawing for a bench that the 'new guy on the block' can build. He also shows exploded views of benches used by Sam Maloof, Tage Frid, and others. He walks you through the detailed steps in building what he calls "A New Clasic.". Lon stays on topic, and educates the reader in building a bench. Add this book to your shelf.

IF you only want to buy 2 books, get #4 and #3.

That is my story, and sticking to it,

Ken

Re: Review of reviews -- Workbenches (Long)

#2

Re: Review of reviews -- Workbenches (Long)

pecker

>I only ever bought #1, and was disappointed. It was aimed more at people who want to read about workbenches than those who want to build one.

Re: Review of reviews -- Workbenches (Long)

#3

Ellis Walentine

Hmm

Ellis Walentine

>Those are pretty harsh words about my recent review, Ken. Sorry you didn't like it. Apart from my enthusiasm for the book, did you find any factual errors or unwarranted conclusions in the review?

Regards,

Ellis

Re: Review of reviews -- Workbenches (Long)

#4

Ellis...they have a point....

Roger Lance in GR, Michigan

>its hard to imagine that that Landis guy filled his book with a lot of words and discriptions of workbench tops, bases, and vises...and then actually made a historical review of benches and then featured benches of Klausz, Dunbar, Tarule, Vandal, Fortune, and Kirby and someother unheard of guys...certainly not very inspirational...I guess its sorta miraculous that I was able to build a bench years ago by reading all those words over and over and looking at the few pictures and diagrams in the thing...so now its better to have more pictures and less words...and I think your review only had one picture and a lot of words.

Re: Review of reviews -- Workbenches (Long)

#5

Re: Review of reviews -- Workbenches (Long)

GolfSteve in Calgary

>I think a person's response to these books depends on what one is trying to get from the book.

My review of these books is in a completely different order from yours. I rank them from best to no-so-best as follows:

1. Landis' Worbench Book - gives a great overview of a number of bench designs and gives detailed drawings of how to build the most common benches. Sure his drawings are missing a few details, but the drawings are just as good as those in any other book. Landis also gives probably the best description of the Klausz bench - which is what I wanted to build - so naturally, perhaps, I found this book to be the best of the bunch. He tried really hard to describe how to build a tail-vice, but until I actually built one I didn't understand his instructions.

2. Woodworker's Journal October 2004 Issue - this magazine had two articles on building a Klausz and Kirby bench. This was a great issue and the articles covered several points that the Landis book skimmed over. I think these articles have been reprinted recently. The drawings in the article gave a few dimensions that were missing from the Landis drawings.

3. Schleining's The Workbench is a pretty good book. The photography is great and there are some good ideas hidden here and there. I found that this book complemented Landis' book - but did not replace it. He does a pretty good job describing the construction process for one bench (which I think had been published earlier in a FWW article or vice-versa).

4. I've only breezed through Schwartz's book at Lee Valley, and since I've already built my bench I'm no longer as interested in bench books as I used to be. However, nothing in the book grabbed my eye as interesting. I found the black and white photography very bland. I think he tries to revive a few old designs and argues for certain design features but, not being interested in a Hotzapffel bench, my eyes just glazed over. Obviously I'm in the minority here because almost everything I've read about his book gives it glowing praise. I have enjoyed Chris's Popular Woodworking articles about workbenches and his posting on the various blogs and forums.

5. Sam Allen's book did not inspire me at all. Perhaps it was the lack of pretty pictures or the dated appearance. It looked like a good step by step instruction manual on how to build a bench, but it was incredibly boring to read - not something that would inspire me as I sipped my Scotch in bed before falling asleep to dream about benches.

At the end of the day, I think you have to use these books to decide what type of bench you want. Then, using the book that best represents what you want to build, come up with your own design and build it.

I found that I relied most upon the Woodworker's Journal article for the actual construction process, but I read Landis' and Schleining's books a number of times for inspiration and design ideas.

Cheers,

Steven

Re: Review of reviews -- Workbenches (Long)

#6

Oh, just relax ;-)

Ken Garlock, Collin County Texas

>Actually Ellis, I got a good chuckle out of it. It shows that you still have your writing skills in tune. I should have inserted a ;-) at the end of my comment.

In any event, I liked Chris' book. It is a good KISS approach with good basic knowledge.

In addition, I like the new quarterly WoodWorking Magazine that Chris edits. It is great to have a magazine that is not loaded with advertising, and deals with honing skills.

How is your crochet?

Ken

Re: Review of reviews -- Workbenches (Long)

#7

Ineresting Steve.

Ken Garlock, Collin County Texas

>Steve,, you know what they say about opinions.... Yours is just a valid as mine. Everyone will take away something different from each of the books.

Happy to hear your list,

Ken

Re: Review of reviews -- Workbenches (Long)

#8

Ellis Walentine

Regarding the WWJ article...

Ellis Walentine

>...I happened to write that article, at least from Frank's standpoint, and there was an incorrect dimension that showed up in the final plan. Any competent woodworker would have caught it immediately, so I trust it didn't throw you. If you need to know more, ping me and I'll dig back and find the offending dimension.

Cheers,

Ellis

Re: Review of reviews -- Workbenches (Long)

#9

Re: Review of reviews -- Workbenches (Long)

Thomas S Stockton

>I found Scott Landis's book very good and built a bench using it taking the features from a bunch of the different designs he had in the book.

I looked at Christopher Schwarz' book at the bookstore and it looked like a good book to me and I would very much consider buying it if I were building another bench.

I've only glanced at Lon Schleining but kinda felt like it was Finewoodworking doing what they seem to do a lot of these days and doing the same thing over and over. Especially after Landis' book which I consider a must have book. I will admit that I'm jaded on the FWW topic and it is just my opinion and it is probably a real good book.

Never seen Sam Allen's so I can't give an opinion.

If I were buying today it would be between Scott Landis and Christopher Schwarz' book and would decide by sitting down with each in the store and seeing which one fit my style best.

I think the biggest mistake you could make in building a bench is to totally copy someone else's without making modifications that fit your own style and taste. I think that is what I liked about Landis' book is that it had a lot of great ideas in it as well as enough plans to make almost any bench you wanted.

Tom

Re: Review of reviews -- Workbenches (Long)

#10

Re: Review of reviews -- Workbenches (Long)

Jay St. Peter - SoMD

>I've read 3 of the 4 books. Well, I guess I should be totally honest here and say I've read the Schwarz book front to back and I've gone through the other books and read the majority of them (not necessarily in order). In all honesty I found them difficult to completely read.

Here's my take. If you're building a bench:

1. Read Chris Schwarzs book. It really tears into the fundamentals of a good bench. It is detailed in the theory and helpful in making the decision of what you want out of your bench. Once it gets to actual construction, it is focused on the benches that Chris chose. So if you choose something else you'll need to look elsewhere. Plus, it holds your attention enough that you can digest the concepts.

2. If you want more detail on building what I'll call more complex bench designs, Schleinings book is more about that stuff. It's good there, but a little less helpful in choosing features. It has been a while since I read it, but I remember it tending to favor a more complex is better when concerning vices and such. Sort of a more exciting to talk about and build than the simpler designs. But, it is a little dry reading sometimes anyway.

3. If you want inspiration for making a really nice bench with contrasting wood and nice dovetailed features, Landis' book has some real nice pictures. Really, that's why I buy Landis' books. I love seeing and reading about peoples shops, benches and toolboxes. Even though there is more to the book, I find the other books cover it better. The plans aren't real detailed, but they are probably enough for me to build one of the benches in the book. If you need every part detailed to the nth degree, this book doesn't have that. It's mostly overviews.

I had the Schleining and Landis books when I built my bench since the Schwarz book wasn't out yet. Even though I had both books, I still chose a hybrid of a couple magazine articles as my bench (including an older Schwarz design). I don't know if either book helped me or not. My goal was a solid, easy to build and functional bench. I don't think either of those books favors that. The Schwarz book is very much into questioning why spend the extra money or effort unless there is value in it.

Jay

Re: Review of reviews -- Workbenches (Long)

#11

A vote for Landis

Jim Shaver Oakville, Ont.

>Hi,

With the volume of recent books available on benches it is hard to choose one book to decide on a bench.

I made mine 5 years ago and used the Landis book for much of my research and detailed construction. I still think it's the best.

I researched a lot of actual benches as well when I was making mine and the combination of that information, pictures I took and the landis book proved to be my best guide.

:-)

My bench is a Shaker like bench, you can find it in Shop Shots here at WC.

Take care,

Jim

Re: Review of reviews -- Workbenches (Long)

#12

Re: A vote for Landis *LINK*

Jim Shaver Oakville, Ont.

>Here is my bench

Take care,

Jim


My Work Bench

Re: Review of reviews -- Workbenches (Long)

#13

Jim, That is a darn nice bench

Ken Garlock, Collin County Texas

>

Re: Review of reviews -- Workbenches (Long)

#14

Re: Review of reviews -- Workbenches (Long) *LINK*

charlie belden

>Tried to post earlier but appears it got lost so am trying again.

A woodworking bench YOU design and make to fit YOUR needs and style of work probably isn't to be found in ANY book. And normally by the time you get around to designing and making YOUR bench you're probably going to "borrow" ideas from as many sources as you can find. And if you need plans to build one you either have to be good at adapting it to your situation - or live with what someone else found worked for THEM - but might not work quite as well for YOU.

If you do solid wood furniture your needs are going to be quite different from those of a ply and face frame maker. For the former the bench is primarily a tool - mostly a clamping tool - a reference surface - and with enough weight to provide inertia when hand planing and as rigid as reasonably possible. For the latter it's mainly a layout and assembly table with a lot of flat surface area - mass/inertia not all that important - more of a table than a bench.

Books with text and pictures can give you ideas and maybe some How To Make It information - but seldom provide the bench in it's "use context". Watching a video or DVD of Frank Klausz USING his bench - to do dovetails or mortise and tenons fills most of the void found in books. Everything about his bench has a purpose - and how its put together and how it does its job is the result of centuries of refinement - a tool that helps its user work efficiently - time being money for the furniture makers who developed and refined that style of bench.

Another shortcoming of "bench books" is that they try to be all things to all people - a brief survey of several types/styles of benches and a page, maybe two of "plans". You get enough to wet your whistle, but never get enough to actually make the bench. There's just too many details, some subtle and some semi-obvious required. Somethings aren't obvious 'til you get to building the bench. And if you use "traditional joinery" you can dry fit what you have and measure what's next using slip sticks - no reading/misreading a tape measure or transposing a number read off a set of "plans".

Hell - I did 34 web pages on making Das Bench and barely cover what went into making it. All along the way there were refinements made that couldn't have been foreseen earlier -opportunities for modifications as things progressed.

Books are ok for inspirations/ideas and it's nice to go through one before turning out the lights and sleeping - gives the unconscious mind a chance to play with ideas while you sleep and go "Psssst! Look into this idea" as it shuts down and the conscious mind wakes up.

Watch some videos/DVDs that show a bench being used. Then check out a ton of web pages and sites about workbenches. When you've compiled a bunch of info - and notes, THEN decide on your design criteria and start a design. Doesn't need to be perfect - you'll change things as you go.

The last link at the bottom of the attached web page is a great site if you're going to make a bench. Plenty of ideas and lots of details.

Get

- your top's core

- get your vise hardware

- decide on your apron width

- leave room under the apron for clamping

- get leg levelers that can be adjusted

from above for at least one corner, all

four even better (it the top of the Base

ain't level and co-planer it doesn't matter

how thick the apron core is, it won't be

level - after a while

- don't make the bench any longer or wider

than actually necessary - bigger isn't always

better - you will have to move around this

things. Unless you're going to make dining

tables or king sized beds, a 5 or 6 foot long

by 24" wide bench will do the job

- use traditional joinery - dovetails and mortise

and tenon (or loose tenon mortise and tenon)

and splines - and no glue for the top to apron

- allthread the side aprons to the bench core

so you can make changes later if need be

- put a stong bottom shelf in to hold additional

weight if needed later - a bench with a lot of

inertia is a good thing if you're using it with

hand tools.

Ramble mode off.

Books are good. Web info is free - and there's

a lot out there. Seeing a bench in action is really important if you want to understand what a bench does and can do.

I haven't seen the Schwarz book, looked through but did not buy the Lon S book, bought and studied the Landis and Allen books and they both were valuable investments - especially the bench "accourtements" in the Sam Allen book.

charlie belden

ps - eventually I'm going to shorten the screw

on the shoulder vise. That's going to

required cutting another large dovetail

tail - but, because of allthread, is doable.

Had I glued things together I'd be screwed!


Evolution of a Design & the Building of Das Benc

Re: Review of reviews -- Workbenches (Long)

#15

A vote for Jim, with modifications...

Martin from Granbury

>Being a Shaker guy, I've always admired Jim's bench. He did a superb job. However, after reading Chris' book, he makes some valid points about keeping the space directly below the bench top clear, to allow for clamps and holdfasts to be used without obstructions.

In my heart, I've always wanted a Shaker bench with a case of drawers, but I see the validity of Chris' argument.

So here is my proposed solution...

I think I will build a bench similar to Jim's, but with only the lower two banks of drawers. I will still have some storage, have a little more mass, and perhaps I can split the difference on room beneath the top for clamps and holdfasts.

Next time I see Chris (or maybe here), I'll ask him what he thinks.

I have 3 of the 4 books, Landis, Schleining, and Schwarz. I confess I have looked quite a bit at the first two, but never read them from cover to cover. I have read Chris', and I must say I thoroughly enjoy his writing style, dry wit, conversational tone, and his innate ability to explain why and why not certain things are useful in a bench. Regardless of what you think of the first two books, Chris' book is certainly a keeper in my humble opinion.

Thank you Chris, for all you do to teach the world about hand tools.

Jim, I am hoping you might make it down to Berea in November so we can finally meet in person.

Re: Review of reviews -- Workbenches (Long)

#16

Re: Review of reviews -- Workbenches (Long) *LINK*

GolfSteve in Calgary

>Hi Charlie.

Funny thing. When making my bench one of the tenons attacked me also. Luckily no stickes were required.

Cheers,

Steven


Charlie's Attack Results