Review of reviews -- Workbenches (Long)
Ken Garlock, Collin County Texas
>To start with, I am beginning the process of building a real, beat it with a mallet, workbench. For the past 5 years I have been using my 'work door', an el-cheapo door supported by two HD saw horses. Two weeks ago I ordered and had delivered a 2 1/4 inch by 30" by 96" maple top through McMaster & Carr, and made by John Boos & Co in Effingham IL.
This whole process got me in researching workbench building.
I bought:
Making Workbenches by Sam Allen
The Workbench Book by Scott Landis
Workbenches,from Design & Theory to Construction and Use, by Christopher Schwarz.
The Workbench, by Lon Schleining.
After reading all four offerings, I am going to rate them as I see them starting with least rewarding to very best.
1. The Workbench Book, by Scott Landis.
This book is more of a survey of workbenches, than a detailed explanation. Yes it has some interesting pictures of bench parts, and drawings, but is short on examples that can be directly used.
2. Making Workbenches by Sam Allen
This book is a reasonable offering. It has many black&white drawings and several examples of workbenches along with parts lists. A person could build a usable bench using the ideas and examples in this book
3. Workbenches,from Design & Theory to Construction and Use, by Christopher Schwarz.
Now we are getting into the real thing. This book has many examples of most all the things you do or might want in a bench, and even more. Example, how often do your use the Crocher on your bench? Oh, you don't know what it is, well buy the book. Chris is also a big advocate of wedge and draw-bore pinning of M&T joints. He also give instruction for building a modern English bench, and a French style bench. Lastly, he includes several tables giving characteristics of those woods that can be used in workbench construction. This is a book worth adding to your library. Note to Ellis, your review of this book reads like a sales pitch at the state fair.
4. The Workbench, by Lon Schleining.
This book wins out of all for multiple reasons. It has many excellent color pictures of the benches used by accomplished wood workers. Lon looks at the individual parts of a bench in detail, and includes a set of exploded drawing for a bench that the 'new guy on the block' can build. He also shows exploded views of benches used by Sam Maloof, Tage Frid, and others. He walks you through the detailed steps in building what he calls "A New Clasic.". Lon stays on topic, and educates the reader in building a bench. Add this book to your shelf.
IF you only want to buy 2 books, get #4 and #3.
That is my story, and sticking to it,
Ken



