Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

OT Question on Synthetic Motor oil

Posts

OT Question on Synthetic Motor oil

#1

OT Question on Synthetic Motor oil

Barry Irby

>I took the advice of one of the TV Mechanics an put Synthetic motor oil in my old Honda CRV, at 140K and drove it another 140K. No engine problems, no excess oil use.

Now, I went to an Auto parts store and the guy tells me I should not put synthetic motor oil in my son's pickup with 106K on it because the engine is already run in and there may be some slop and the slipperier syn oil will leak out. So, what to do? The truck is a 99 Mazda B3000 six cylinder.

Re: OT Question on Synthetic Motor oil

#2

Re: OT Question on Synthetic Motor oil

JohnD

>Slippery and leakage no, viscosity and leakage yes. I would not worry about leakage. Back in my working days we had a lubrication expert and I was always interested in what brand and viscosity to use. He gave me a stack of reports on govt lab testing to read. After all the reading and digesting the data I got back with him. Long story short he only used synthetic and that was 20years ago. I am an advocate of synthetic oil but it really isn't cost effective unless you follow the longer mileage changing schedule and that becomes the argument. Good Luck

Re: OT Question on Synthetic Motor oil

#3

Re: OT Question on Synthetic Motor oil

Mike Parzych

>I put 15,000 mile synthetic in my 99 Taurus at 125,000 last July. Hasn't lost any oil at all, and it still looks real good colorwise.

Re: OT Question on Synthetic Motor oil

#4

Re: OT Question on Synthetic Motor oil

Chuck W

>Barry,

I would try the synthetic oil and check the level frequently. The mileage you state is not that much.

Re: OT Question on Synthetic Motor oil

#5

Re: OT Question on Synthetic Motor oil

Ken Garlock, Collin County Texas

>Hello Barry.

I think your parts store is p'ing on your shoes and telling you it is raining.

A synthetic oil has to meet, and probably exceeds, the same specs as a standard oil. A 10W30 is still a 10W30 regardless of the brand or origin. Yes, you pay more for synthetic, but it lasts 3 to 6 times longer.(based on the old timer 3500 mile oil change cycle.)

I have used Amsoil for years, and had zero problems in 3 cars. My current car came for the dealer with Mobil-1.

Go for it,

Ken

Re: OT Question on Synthetic Motor oil

#6

Jesper, Denmark

You ask yourself: Is the parts store clerk......

Jesper, Denmark

>... an expert on engine technology? And if so, what is he doing there on the counter selling stuff?

Synthetics do a couple of things: 1. last longer without increasing viscosity. 2. Have an OK viscosity over a larger range of temperatures.

If you change oil every 5,000 miles, they do not help you.

They do do a better job of lubricating at cold starts.

if you like 'em, they will not in any way hurt either your 1956 Pick' em up truck or 1930 Packard, unless cleaning out some old tar is bad for the motor?

Re: OT Question on Synthetic Motor oil

#7

Jesper, Denmark

Oh, and I do run a VW.......

Jesper, Denmark

>technology SKODA OCTAVIA (look it up!) 2.0 liter turbocharged and intercooled diesel, which HAS to have synthetic with just the right additives - but then has a factory authorized 20,000 mile oil change interval.

It used 2 quarts of the oil the first 20,000 miles, 1 quart the second 20,000 miles and has not seemingly used any since. I guess it is broken in OK!

The car is about Accord wagon size, does 0-60 in around 9, tops out at 130 mph and does around 40 mpg cruising on the autobahn at a comfortable 100 mgh.

Re: OT Question on Synthetic Motor oil

#8

Re: 1980 F-150 w/ 351 V-8

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

>I bought the truck at 150K, just after oil had been changed. Ran oil for 3K, at 10 mpg w/premiun and Holley 4 barrel. Replaced with full Syntec, next tank I got 12 mpg. Traded truck at 200 K.

TWENTY % increase in gas mileage was well worth the extra $11 for the synthetic oil!

Bill in WNC mountains

Re: OT Question on Synthetic Motor oil

#9

B250 w/360 4bbl

Neal in San Jose

>Dodge van. I bought it new and changed to synthetic (red Line) at 5000 miles. I had to back the idle back a couple of times as it kept creaping up, and the milage went from a consistent 12 to a consistent 13. I finally burned a valve at 170K and had to rebuild. The rebuilder was impressed at how clean it was inside. Very non-scientific and non verifiable, but I've run synthetic in everything I've owned since then. My current Audi came with synthetic 0W-30 from the dealer and has had nothing else.

Re: OT Question on Synthetic Motor oil

#10

Re: OT Question on Synthetic Motor oil

Jay St. Peter - SoMD

>The only thing I've ever heard from a believable source is that once you go synthetic you shouldn't go back. Apparently there is some sort of seal conditioners added to synth and once your seals get used to it regular dino oil will cause them to deteriorate quicker than usual.

Re: OT Question on Synthetic Motor oil

#11

I've heard that, too.

Barry Irby

>That you can't switch back, and I was not planning on it.

Thanks guys.

Re: OT Question on Synthetic Motor oil

#12

Re: OT Question on Synthetic Motor oil

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>I put Mobil 1 in my 1970 Opel and had oil weeping from the valve cover and oil pan seals. The engine ran smoother, but I didn't notice any increase in mileage. I finally quit using it as the oil weeping out of the pan gasket and valve cover gasket was making a mess.

Lee

Re: OT Question on Synthetic Motor oil

#13

Re: OT Question on Synthetic Motor oil

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>I am a retired Manufacturing Engineer. I use the synthetic oil in every internal combustion engine I have and also in the air compressor in my shop. The ONLY downside to the synthetic oil is the cost of the oil -period. It will not leak easier or more. In fact if you replace the oil with the same viscosity as the non-synthetic it will leak less in operation as the viscosity is more stable - IE it will not get quite as thin when the engine is hot. I was told by my son that all military vehicles used in hostile environments (desert and Alaska) now are required to use synthetic lubricants. I have not purchased a new vehicle since 1963 - many have had over 100,000 mi when purchased - I have used synthetic in all - I have not had an engine fail due to lube in over 30 years. (Have blown a couple head gaskets etc.) - no bearing failures or excess oil consumption. I would say the clerk at the part store had more mouth than education.

Re: OT Question on Synthetic Motor oil

#14

Re: OT Question on Synthetic Motor oil

Bilyo

>After reading lots of opinions on this subject, here is what I do based on the understanding that there are only a few oil manufacturers that make all the oil and that the base oil products are basically the same. Only the additive packages are significantly different and, even then, not much. I like the benefits that synthetics provide, but don't like the cost. Also, I have had difficulty convincing myselt to use extended change intervals. So, I compromise. I purchase house brand synthetic oil from a well known department store and change it at slightly greater intervals than I used to, but still within the manufacturers recommendations. The cost is a little more this way, but not much. So far, it is working good.

Re: OT Question on Synthetic Motor oil

#15

Synthetic & oil changes

Curt Harms

>Some go with the extended oil change interval, but change the filter midway between oil changes. I don't know if there's merit in that idea or not.

Re: OT Question on Synthetic Motor oil

#16

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Here's how I figure it.

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

>The car companies want you to buy more cars. With fewer oil changes, the cars, on average, would wear out quicker. Thus, many owner's manuals show 7500- to 15,000-mile intervals. The oil companies want you to buy more oil, so the 3-month/3000-mile change interval has been beat into our heads for decades. I figure the optimum is somewhere in between, say 5000 to 6000 miles, and synthetic should about double that. I switched to synthetic in my truck after I had let it get away from me and ended up at about 12,000 miles. After I drained out 2.5 quarts, I put the full 6 quarts in it's supposed to have... I couldn't believe it was still running as well as it was. Now, with the synthetic, I shoot for once a year or about 10,000 miles, and even then, the used synthetic looks and feels pretty good--better than dino oil at 5000 miles.

Jason