>Anyone out there put this tool to the test,I mean real production test over a period of months or more?It looks like an intriguing joinery tool,but for the price there seems to be a lot of plastic parts on it.So,if you have one,how has it held up to everyday use?I'm considering the plunge,so please, any help is appreciated.
>Written by Charlie B, this is the most thorough testing, data producing, and investigative web site anyone could imagine for this tool. He loves it, and after reading all the pages, you can see why.
>I have been looking at the http://mortisepal.com/purchase.html. Can the dominoe do that much more (for a hobby woodworker) than the mortise pal. I realize it should be faster but for a hobbiest will it make that much difference?
Earl Who owns niether but is thinking about the mt
Good advice about looking at www.festoolownersgroup.com The target market for Festool seems to be finish carpenters/installers/remodelers where portability and cleanliness is important. There are a number of such folk who post on that forum (for instance Brice Burrel and Per Swenson) who seem happy with the Domino for day to day work.
If you are talking about contractor (as opposed to factory) production, the time saved making mortises would earn back that high purchase price pretty quickly.
I've dug maybe a thousand mortises with mine and no problems so far. There is a lot of plastic, but the hard working parts like gears and adjusters are steel. unlike some of my Delta/DeWalt/PC tools.
>Thanks,Jerry&Robert for the links.Lots to digest there,it looks like Festool has a cult following thing going on or something.Thanks too Jesse for the first hand experience.The more I read,the more I'm leaning toward ordering one, but I'm having a mental wrestling match though,trying to justify all that money for a portable power tool that is about the size of a biscuit joiner.
I have been looking at the http:/mortisepal.com/purchase.html. Can the dominoe do that much more (for a hobby woodworker) than the mortise pal. I realize it should be faster but for a hobbiest will it make that much difference?
Earl Who owns niether but is thinking about the mt
Earl:
If you have more time than money (and you ain't alone) and enjoy woodworking to a large extent because it involves problem solving, adapting to the occasionaly OOPS!, carefully laying out and cutting "traditional joinery", mostly by hand but often with the aid of a power tool for the "grunt work" - the Mortise
Pal would probably do the job for you - assuming you have a router for it - especially if you make your own loose tenons to fit the router bit(s) you may already have.
BUT - if you use the loose tenons they sell then you're looking at another $120+ for the Whiteside bits (which are made to tighter specs than the $10-$15 spiral bits you can buy on line from a host of companies) and you'll need the Template Guide Bushing and the Centering Pin for another $14 so you're looking at about $325 for the jig and stuff to use it, not the $189 cost you initially think of. Not a big deal - but that "under $200" jig will ACTUALLY cost you over 50% more to use their "system" (jig, guide and pin, bits and loose tenons).
But $325 is in the price range of the lower end jigs like the TREND - though it won't do what the TREND can do (see link for the TREND)
My concerns with this jig are
1. when you're cutting a mortise close to the end of a board - you'll have almost half the jig handing out in space - reducing the clamping area actually on the wood. The clamping " jaw" isn't that big and it's got a little knob for tightening it. It's a plunge router that it needs to support - and you will be pushing down on the router when plunging. You DO NOT want a sharp bit, spinning at 20-30K rpms. getting away - for whatever reason. Wood is replaceable - and though wounds heal, bone takes a lot longer - assuming it's just a "fill in the blank" and not a missing chunk. If you're going to cut mortises with a plunge router you want a jig with a nice big stabile table for it to sit on - and this thing doesn't have that.
2. because the distance from reference face to mortise centerline is fixed you won't be able to "cheat" to the inside - or for that matter - to the outside on things like apron parts. There WILL be times when you want to do just that.
3. it's critical that the distance from your reference Edge or End to Mortise Centerline is the same for ALL mortises with that same distance. You don't have to be off by much to cut joints that fit properly. Having the top of a table apron sticking up above the top of a leg will, if you don't plane it flush - cause you some grief. It's worse if it's the leg that's too high. What it takes to set up this jig isn't clear in the pdf manual - but if it involves a lot of eyeballing . . .
If you enjoy jig making, you can make a mortising jig and add on stuff as needed.
The nice thing about woodworking is that there's more than one way to skin a cat. If you want the fur and not all the skinning and taxadermy work you can buy fur skins. But if you like making things in order to make things that's doable too.
For me, I've been there, done that and have the T-shirts. Was fun and I learned stuff. Now I want to make things rather than make things to make what I really want. Having options that make the making easier and quicker helps me overcome my "I'd like to _____ but it'd be such a hassle" barrier.
>Robert (et al - which is latin for "and anybody else who might be interested):
It's really hard to convey adequately the capabilities of, and concepts behind, the DOMINO - mainly because it's not like any other power tool out there - though it looks like a biscuit cutter. It's the Devil In The Details differences between it and the other jigs that will do mortises which is difficult to explain in a page or two. Showing how each cuts ONE mortise can't show what's involved in cutting a mortise on BOTH ends of an apron AND a mortise on a "left" leg and then a "right" leg.
I'm working on more detailed comparison between how a simple table with apron and stretchers is done with the DOMINO, the LEIGH FMT and the MultiRouter (and may throw in the TREND M&T Jig), starting with layout requirements, set ups, getting into parts clamping, jig registering, mortise cutting, parts manipulation, dealing with "offsets" and so forth. Want to summarize with a table of tasks and times for the example, showing some understandable values - after you have an understanding of what's required for each of the jigs. First cut indicates the DOMINO almost 3 times quicker than template guided mortising with either the LEIGH FMT or the MultiRouter, 5 times quicker than than a horizontal mortising unit without templates and almost 7 times faster than a chisel and bit mortiser - which can't do end grain mortising. And this is assuming you do the parts manipulation correctly.
You really have to have done a project like the table/apron/stretchers with the alternatives to really see and understand why the DOMINO is so revolutionary. The fact that a buddy who has done no furniture making at all and had never seen a DOMINO before could cut 4 mortises in each mitered end of four parts to a gate frame - that's 7 feet tall - in less than 15 minutes - AND have everything go together nice and snug hints at how quick and easy this thing is to use. 32 mortises in under 15 minutes -with minimal instructions and no prior experience.
I've demonstrated this project to woodworkers who've used all the other methods - and most of them Get It real quick and either go get one or start saving up to get one. It's the newbie and the occassional woodworker who watch the process and then say something like - "OK, that was interesting - but damn that thing's EXPENSIVE!" often followed by "Why not just pocket hole screw that stuff together?"
>Charlie, I hope you post your research here and at the wreck. I don't know whether I am more impressed by the quality of your analysis or by the fact you take the time to document so thoroughly and share your findings.