Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

Biscuits or dowels?

Posts

Biscuits or dowels?

#1

JL

Biscuits or dowels?

JL

>I'll be making a face frame for the bookshelves that I'm building.

The plywood and the frame will be southern red oak. I was planning on using biscuits to attach the frame together and attach the frame to the shelf carcass (though I may consider using feathers or splines for the frame). Should I even consider using dowels? The thickness of the frame boards will be ~3/4" (width will be ~2 1/4").

Re: Biscuits or dowels?

#2

Re: Biscuits or dowels?

Hal Smith

>If you have the equipment, pocket screws are the way to go for assembling the face frame (my opinion). I usually glue the face frame to the carcase without other fasteners. See article in April issue of Pop Wood by Troy Sexton for idea about making stiles 1/16" oversize and then trimming with a flush cutting bit in your router to get a nice joint between the frame and carcase sides. In the cabinet he made, he assembled the frame with mortise and tenon which seems like a lot of work. Good luck. Hal

Re: Biscuits or dowels?

#3

I wouldn't.

John E in SC

>My experience with dowels has always been less than successful. They never seem to line up exactly right, and I think it makes for a much weaker joint than bisquits. Pocket screws are pretty easy also, but I like having the little bit of "wiggle" room you get with bisquits.

My 2 cents.

John

Re: Biscuits or dowels?

#4

Re: Biscuits or dowels?

John McGaw

>I'd definitely use biscuits - they are fast, easy, and strong.. In fact that is what I'm using in the wall of bookshelves in the "library" downstairs. My design really doesn't depend on the face frame as a structural element other than the stiffness the rails give to the shelves but if you were seeking strength then assembling the rails and stiles with pocket screws would give you that. Of course you could use more traditional joinery for the frame's construction but it would never be as easy.