Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

Question - Need a metal engineer

Posts

Question - Need a metal engineer

#1

Question - Need a metal engineer

jeff

>I've tried to look up this information, but no luck.

About 3 years ago I built a Mobile base for my jointer.

I used 4"x4" pressure treated posts as the supports.

I want to build a new replacement base out of metal.

While the 4x4's supported the jointer with no trouble, they have finally warped from the weight.

I tried to find some metal tubing, U channel, or angle iron.

My supplier says he has no idea of the strength and suggested a 4" U channel should be strong enough.

Does anyone have an idea of the strength of this stuff?

Should I be looking for something else?

What is the strength of a 4x4 PT post in comparison?

My friend can weld this together, but doesn't have the foggiest idea how strong the channel is, he thinks it will work.

The jointer is a 1924 American and weighs close to a ton.

I know my 1000lb planer is easily carried on a 1"x3" tubular steel framework.

Re: Question - Need a metal engineer

#2

Re: Question - Need a metal engineer

Pete in Holland, MI

>Would suggest using some 2x2 square tube with at least a 3/16" wall. Make sure to put some plates on the corners to mount the casters to, else they will fail. 4" channel will hold up a house in the size of base needed for your 1000# machine.

I'm guessing your wood 4x4s were wet treated wood and that they may have done more twisting and warping than sagging under the weight.

I am assuming you are building a base that is about 24-30" square? If so, the 2x2 tube will be more than adequate. I have a 700# surface planer mounted to a base of 1x2(stood vertically) and 2x2 tube and it's fine.

Re: Question - Need a metal engineer

#3

Re: Question - Need a metal engineer

John K Jordan

>I agree about the tubing. I like the 2x2 but a 2x3 or 2x4 will carry more weight. Channel should also work, or I-beam or even heavy angle iron, but the tubing is easier to fit together, can look better, and won't collect sawdust as easily. I don't have numbers on the strength, but my gut feeling is the heavy wall tubing would be plenty. (I like the 1/4 inch which should be more than strong enough for your application if I'm guessing correctly about your design.) A ramp made from such tubing is strong enough to support a car. The last time I needed to know the strength of a piece of steel, I called my local friendly steel supplier and fab shop and he looked it up in a book.

To give you a rough idea of the strength of square tubing, check out this question/answer from a guy who wants to use a 6' piece of wimpy 1"x3" square tubing for a trailer ramp - the calculation indicated that one piece of such tubing supported only at the ends would support over 400 lbs in the center:

http://answers.google.com/answers/threadview?id=726101

In your case, the length will be shorter and the weight should be evenly distributed so it will hold much more weight. Are you going to bolt the jointer to the frame? If so, that will increase the rigidity and minimize bending. I might weld cross members near the ends to better support the steel plates for the casters.

You can often buy steel tubing from fabrication shops as well as steel suppliers. The fab shop I use usually has offcuts if I don't need a full 20' piece.

JKJ

Re: Question - Need a metal engineer

#4

More info to help

jeff

>The Jointer is a 3 legged jointer with a foot-print of 48" x 26".

I planned to have the cross members of angle to put the feet on.

The length total of the U channel would be 6 ft.

This allows a plate to be welded along the top at both ends.

One end of the U channel would be 6" past the jointer foot to have the casters on.

The other end will be 18" extra to have the casters on the plate and the motor above.

I thought that 1/4" plate would work well.

The span is then 6 ft total.

The feet have no holes to bolt to.

Is this overbuilt? Or just right?

Part of the problem (I suspect) is that the metal supplier won't give any enginnering specs either because he doesn't know them or doesn't want to get into engineering and liability.

Jeff

Re: Question - Need a metal engineer

#5

Re: Question - Need a metal engineer

Curly Smith

>A 4" U channel is much bigger and more expensive than you need.

If your jointer weighs 2000# then each rail and caster must support 500# (assuming the weight is evenly distributed). But what is 500# in "force" terms? Well, it's 0.5 kips ( a kip is equal to 1000 pounds-force).

So if you mosey to this website and download the massive 116 page PDF : http://www.steeltubeinstitute.org/pdf/brochures/beam_load_table_bro.pdf

and you scroll down to page 90, you'll find the following for 2x2 square tubing:

_________________wall thickness

___________1/4______3/16_______1/8

span,ft

1__________16________14_________11

2__________8.2_______7.0________5.3

3__________5.5_______4.7________3.6

4__________4.1_______3.5________2.7

So 2x2 square tubing with a wall thickness of 1/4" will support 16 kips over a 1 ft span. You're only trying to support 0.5 kips. For design purposes you can assume that you need to support the entire load of 2 kips (or 2000#). Use the tubing tables and your mobile base dimensions (the span) to find acceptable alternatives.

You can get all the information you want on steel tubing here: http://www.steeltubeinstitute.org/hss_literature1.htm

Re: Question - Need a metal engineer

#6

Re: Question - Need a metal engineer

jeff

>Curly

Great info.

I haven't been able to load the site into my slowwww computer yet.

Do you know how this applies to the U channel and Angle iron?

Can I get away with 3" U channel and 3"x4" Angle iron for the cross supports?

My supplier has the U and Angle in stock and can cut it to size.

Jeff

PS: I like the 3 stooges name.

Re: Question - Need a metal engineer

#7

Re: Question - Need a metal engineer

Curly Smith

>Sorry, I don't have any load tables for angle iron or channel. If you have a good library nearby then you can find the information in one of the many AIME handbooks.

But, and I meant to include this yesterday, are you sure you're not overworking the problem? Your 4x4 frame was more than sufficient for the load. It warped, as mentioned by others, because of differential drying.

If you check the ever popular Sagulator you'll find that a 2x4 is sufficient for the load.

Use (Fir, White) as the shelf material

Shelf load of 500# (total)

36" shelf span

1.5" depth

Vary thickness to get acceptable sag.

For 500# you need 1.75" thickness

For 1000# you need 2.25" thickness

For 1500# you need 2.75" thickness

For 2000# you need 3" thickness

Note: I wouldn't use anything less than a 2x4 unless you're certain that the entire load cannot be placed on one side during installation.

You can obviously laminate 2-2x4's to get back to your 4x4 frame but you don't really need to. Once you get the jointer installed on the frame the calculated deflection (500# on a 3' span) is only 0.002" per foot. I would add some cross-bracing, and probably some corner blocks, to prevent the joints from coming apart when you move the unit.

Re: Question - Need a metal engineer

#8

Thank you

jeff

>Curly

For the net, I kind of shortened up on things.

I debated rebuilding the base from wood again, even flipping the wood and trying to re-warp it to shape.

I'd have alot less problem with mountings of the motor on the metal frame. I'll be able to shorten and narrow it up also.

I was surprised how little the metal cost was when compared to buying some new wood. Welding, casters and any hardware I already have.

I live in the middle of no-where so I don't always have a great choice of material. I usually mail order anything odd or different.

Nearest library where I might find info is an hour or 2 away.

That's why the help on the net has become so valuable.

I know wood is strong, but finding info on how much has always escaped me.

Thank you for the great help.

Jeff

Re: Question - Need a metal engineer

#9

Re: Thank you

Curly Smith

>Had I read the notes in the Sagulator page I could have found all of the info needed...

The deflection we're trying to calculate, Maximum deflection at the Center, is given by the equation 5Wl^3/(384EI) (see this page for the definitions and make note of the units: http://www.engineersedge.com/beam_bending/beam_bending1.htm

The only thing that changes are E, the Modulus of Elasticity, if we're changing materials (ie wood vs steel) and I, the Moment of Inertia, if we're changing shapes. Since you're just interested in steel the only thing that will change is the Moment of Inertia (MOI).

Fortunately, what you need has been tabulated here: http://www.engineersedge.com/structural_shapes_menu.shtml

For the 3"x4" angle that you're interested in select Angle (Steel) #2. Pay attention to how you plan to install it as the MOI changes.

For example, for

4x3x1/2 MOIxx 5.05 MOIyy 2.42

max deflection

0.008" -> 0.02" @ total 2000# load (load on the x-axis -> load on the y-axis)

0.002" -> 0.004" @ 500# installed, evenly distributed load

4x3x3/8 MOIxx 3.96 MOIyy 1.92

max deflection

0.01" -> 0.02" @ total 2000# load

0.002" -> 0.005" @ 500#

You can play with the calculator that they've handily provided here: http://www.engineersedge.com/beam_bending/calculators_protected/beam_deflection_1.htm to determine which solution is best for you. Since you're playing with steel, leave E at the default 30E6, change MOI for the different products, and set the length for your particular design. Or, use the formula and back calculate the MOI to yield your desired max deflection and select the needed product from the charts.

Re: Question - Need a metal engineer

#10

Neat, Thanks Curly.

jeff

>