Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

OT: Dyson . . . too much ? . . .

Posts

OT: Dyson . . . too much ? . . .

#1

OT: Dyson . . . too much ? . . .

steve mackay

>Well it IS a power tool to pick up the saw dust I track into the house so . . . The old Eureka just gasped it's last and her hearts set on a Dyson. Gotta admit they ARE cool. But will the motor last 10 times longer to justify the price tag ? I just KNOW some one here has one and is pasionate about it.

Re: OT: Dyson . . . too much ? . . .

#2

Re: OT: Dyson . . . too much ? . . .

Warren E. White

>We have had one since Nov 2005. I have had to replace the hose and the cannister you empty. They paid for the cannister (the hinge broke) and I paid for the hose. The hose is (in my opinion) a poor design at least on the one I bought. You have to pull down on it to disengage it from the wand. It tore where it connects to the top.

It sucks like crazy. Neat marketing strategy to let you see how much dirt you pick up.

Overall, I like it. I have come to the conclusion that nothing lasts as long as I think it should.

Re: OT: Dyson . . . too much ? . . .

#3

Re: OT: Dyson . . . too much ? . . .

Joseph Mulherin, Sr.

>Steve, we have had one for two years. Buy one and you will not be sorry.

A point for your information....there are TWO filters to clean out periodically. Your rug will love you....

Re: OT: Dyson . . . too much ? . . .

#4

Re: OT: Dyson . . . too little! . . .

Garrett in Victoria

>We bought one and soon returned it. Noisy, and very poor build quality. It looked like a child's transformer toy. Pieces meant to stay on had a tendency to fall off. Wasn't particularly impressed with performance, either. A comment from one of the local dealers was that Dyson spends more money on advertising than anyone else, and obviously successfully so. Instead, we bought a European model that is silent and effective, and we've been happy with it.

Cheers, Garrett

Re: OT: Dyson . . . too much ? . . .

#5

Sebo!

Jim Dillon

>Steve,

I went through this five years ago. When our old Eureka died, I started out looking at the Miele - based on a good friends recommendation. Seemed fine until I started to add all the attachments/beater brushes etc. needed to give a good cleaning to carpets, unlike hardwood floors. Would end up being quite expensive. Stumbled onto the Sebo brand and got one. Unbelievably well built and does it clean. After cleaning our dog/cat infested house with the old Eureka, we filled THREE bags of dirt with the new Sebo. The only downside is that it is heavy, and somewhat expensive. Bags and accessories can be purchased over the internet. And the cord is 40 feet long!! My 2 cents.

Jim

Re: OT: Dyson . . . too much ? . . .

#6

Re: OT: Dyson . . . too much ? . . .

Alan in Little Washington (NC)

>Bite the bullet once and get a whole house vac (like Beam). You will not be sorry. Quieter, more power, no dust returned to the house via pape/cloth bags, etc.

Re: OT: Dyson . . . too much ? . . .

#7

Moses Yoder

Re: OT: Dyson . . . too much ? . . .

Moses Yoder

>We have had a Dyson for several years now without any problems with it and my wife loves it. I think it is as good a vacuum as you can buy for the $400 - $500 range. Sure, you can spend $1200+ and buy better vacuums; the question is do you really need to. We bought the yellow model in the $400 range. We have 7 dogs in the house plus a bird cage and it is intersting to see how much dirt we pick up.

As a side note, I have never understood people's fascination with living in a Martha Stewart house. You spend all that time cleaning dirt out of your house and as soon as you die they bury you under 6 feet of it. Perhaps people associate cleanliness with life. I am not really advocating living in a pig sty, I am just thinking there needs to be a balance in life.

Re: OT: Dyson . . . too much ? . . .

#8

Panasonic. .

jeff

>I've had a Panasonic canister vacuum for 25 years now.

They don't build them like that anymore.

Re: OT: Dyson . . . too much ? . . .

#9

Re: OT: oh do tell...

Henry (Raleigh NC)

>Garrett: What European make/model that is silent (my cats would love that) and effective (I would love that)? Cost?

Henry

Re: OT: Dyson . . . too much ? . . .

#10

Re: OT: Dyson . . . too much ? . . .

Barry Irby

>Went to the local Vac Retailer, can't remember the name of the store, but they had Dyson as well as several other brands. I mentioned I was thinking of buying one and the store owner said, "I wouldn't". Asked which one should I buy and he said, "any of the others". I was so put off, I repaired my old Hoover. (Perhaps he makes more off the others?)

The comments here are the only positive ones I have heard about the Dyson. Have not heard that many comments, but none were anything near Enthusiastic. I see them in peoples houses when I do my Home Inspections and occasionally ask about them. What passes for a ringing endorsement is "It's OK." Maybe they don't live up to the hype. I think even Consumers Report panned them.

I have no idea what you should buy.

Re: OT: Dyson . . . too much ? . . .

#11

FWIW ...

Mike Farinella

>Consumer Reports consistently rates Dyson at the bottom of their lists.

Re: OT: Dyson . . . too much ? . . .

#12

Same as Jim Dillon above - Sebo K3 *LINK*

Garrett in Victoria

>The other option, as Jim also suggested, is the Miele.

Neither is inexpensive, but in this case you do get what you pay for.

Cheers, Garrett


Sebo K3

Re: OT: Dyson . . . too much ? . . .

#13

Don't You Spend One Nickel

Jay in Tx

>...on a Dyson. It was great for a year. Then it would power down automatically after about 15 minutes of vacuuming. I took it apart and cleaned it thoroughly (the funnels were a bit caked, lots of clumpy dust in the innards too). I still couldn't get more than 15 minutes out of it. Called and they said that they would send a tech out or I could take it somewhere, $50 minimum. I took the $50 and put it toward the same department store model that my sister and aunt have been using for a decade. It isn't bagless, but it has been running like a champ for a couple years and pulls out as much dirt as the Dyson ever did. As an added benefit, it picks up the cat hair much better too (in one pass). I even had the purple "pet" model Dyson. Oh, and the current vacuum was cheaper by half. DON'T BELIEVE THE HYPE!

Re: OT: Dyson . . . too much ? . . .

#14

Re: OT: Dyson . . . too much ? . . .

Ralph Turney

>Although I don't put a lot of stock into what Consumer Reports says, one of the Dyson's did place 8th out of 40 vacuums, I wouldn't exactly call that a pass.

R

Re: OT: Dyson . . . too much ? . . .

#15

Many thanks all . . .

steve mackay

>Made her sit here and read your input. I rave 'bout ya'll but shes never partaken. Herself was impressed with the openess ( sp ? ) of the forum. Thanks for makeing me look smarter than I am ! As the Eureka ( $ 40.00 ) lasted seven years I'm think'n theres a shinny new one on the horizon.

Re: OT: Dyson . . . too much ? . . .

#16

Re: Many thanks all . . .

dean campa

>one final thought...i have been away and not able to read the postings lately so this maybe a little to late for your consideration. We have a Dyson DC17animal and we love it. We have had it for about a year and a half and have had no problems at all. We use it on a DAILY basis. Our unit we had before this was a kenmore and at that time that model was rated number 2 by consumer reports. (i do subscribe and put allot of trust into their evaluations) Needless to say that unit lasted 4 years before it died. (it past gone is what the repair service stated) In addition it had 3 filiters that were suppose to be replaced every 3 months at a min. Even buying the filter on line it cost me $50.00 in just filters. So when i looked at the dyson i strongly considered this. $300.00 for the kenmore +$50 every 3 months for 4 years = $1100.00 and it still died at 4 years. So on a positive note we love ours and would not trade it for anything. We even like it better than our oreaka we had before the kenmore. Now i do more cleaning of the container and filters than most. We acutally empty the container every day and wash it with soap and water once a week at least. Then we clean the inner filters every week also. Maybe that is why we have had such good success.

Re: OT: Dyson . . . too much ? . . .

#17

Re: OT: Dyson . . . too much ? . . .

Jerry Samsen

>Go with Oreck -- lightweight, really sucks, great vac....

Re: OT: Dyson . . . too much ? . . .

#18

Re: OT: Dyson . . . too much ? . . .

Kirk (KC) Constable

>My wife decided on the Miele over the Dyson because she WANTED bags. It's quiet, does a good enough job, and will satisfy the 'need to spend a lot to feel like you're getting something good' better than the Dyson. I just about wet myself...

Re: OT: Dyson . . . too much ? . . .

#19

Re: OT: Dyson . . . too much ? . . .

Frank

>I strongly suggest you DO NOT buy a Dyson. We have one and for the first year it seemed to work OK, at least it seemed to do the job. The biggest problem in using it was it didn't fit under cabinet fronts. The brush housing is too high so we had to resort to using the extension hose and cleaning wand just to get under the kitchen cabinets. That was tolerable as long as the vacuum was working.

Then one day the belt drive stopped working. I live in a metropolitan area so I called around to several vacuum repair shops to see if I could get a belt. Only one out of 4 shops carried Dyson parts, the other 3 said they found them a pain to work on and didn't like dealing with the company. The 1 shop that carried parts said they'd sell me the belt but there was no way I could replace it without having special tools from Dyson which they wouldn't sell to consumers anyway. Not only that, but Dyson also controlled the repair price for each job. So, if he charged less than Dyson specified he could lose his access to parts. My simple belt repair cost over $90 to get fixed. The shop owner was apologetic but said that's the way it is with Dyson. He said they were very arrogant in their dealings with customers and repair shops and that the units were all plastic and no better built than any of the other mid-priced units, they were just much better at marketing their products.

When I asked which brands he recommended he basically said any of the other similarly priced or even lower priced units. His opinion was the currently made upright vacuums in general do a pretty good cleaning job due to competition and that the more expensive units don't necessarily clean any better, they may have a few more features (whether useable or not) and tend to last longer due to better construction. He sold several brands priced both above and below Dyson, said they were all much better construction and a lot easier to work on. He felt that Panasonic probably had the best overall line with good models at various price points.

I still have my Dyson but it has gotten very noisy as if there's a bearing going out. I don't know if I'll get it fixed or not but I'll sure look at all the alternatives before making a decision.