Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

Bookshelves?

Posts

Bookshelves?

#1

JL

Bookshelves?

JL

>I usually make a fixed shelf in the middle of most of the bookcases that I build to impart extra rigidity.

I have been asked to make a 8' x ~4' bookcase (which I personally think is too large). I'll be using 3/4" oak plywood and a face frame construction. I was planning on doing my usual fixed middle shelf. Do ya'll think one would be enough with that span (4')? I'll be edge banding all of the shelves with ~1.5" of oak on both sides and making them out of 3/4" plywood.

TIA

Re: Bookshelves?

#2

Re: sagging and bulging *LINK*

Dave Mount, snow's almost gone

>You seem to be talking about two different issues. The fixed middle shelf helps hold the sides of the bookcase from bulging out. But you're also talking about shelves sagging.

For the sagging question, there's a program on the net called "The Sagulator" which is a calculator that figures sag in shelving based on the materials and construction. I can't vouch for it's accuracy, but I've put a link to it below. 3/4" ply with 1.5" edging does not sound up to a 4' run of books in my mental calculator, but you should run the calcs.

With regard to keeping the shelving sides in, that's primarily a funciton of using hardware for the adjustable shelves that doesn't create a side load. From where I'm sitting, I can see a 4' wide by 7' tall case that we bought before I started woodworking. It has a vertical divider, so the shelves are only 2'. However, there is no central fixed shelf, and all the 3/4" ply shelves are on 1/4" brass paddle pins. There's a 1.5" face frame. We've had it for over 20 years, it's loaded to the gills with books, and the sides have not spread.

Best,

Dave


The Sagulator

Re: Bookshelves?

#3

Re: correction

Dave Mount, snow's almost gone

>I have to correct something I said. I ran the "sagulator" on your specs and whether or not the shelf is fixed does have significant influence on the predicted deflection. The sagulator says your 4' span is OK in a fixed shelf, but not in a floating shelf. I'd be curious to know if this is the joint at the ends that stiffens it or if it's assumed that it's fastened to the back of the carcass. If the latter, I wonder whether putting additional pins in the back would do the same. I do that in kitchen cabs with 1/2" backs.

Dave

Re: Bookshelves?

#4

Re: Bookshelves?

John K Jordan

>JL,

This is a free-standing book case? My gut feeling is a single fixed shelf would add sufficient rigidity to the box.

I would worry more about the shelves sagging as Dave mentioned. This house came with 15 built-in bookcases in the library with shelves from 18" to 43" wide built from what looks like birch plywood faced with a hardwood strip. The previous owner had loaded all the shelves with books. All of the longer shelves had sagged. What I did was turn the sagged shelves over and put my heaviest books and items on the shorter shelves and towards the outer ends of the longest shelves.

If possible, try to talk the client into a design modification of some sort, perhaps two smaller cases or one with a central vertical panel. I think this can look great if the central support is not as deep as the outside case and the utility of the bookcase is not the least bit reduced. (unless they have some 4' long items they want to lay on the shelves!)

JKJ

Re: Bookshelves?

#5

Re: correction

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>Getting an acceptable deflection depends on teh load. The default value of 25 pounds per foot seems bit high unless you are planning on having encyclopedias on the shelf. If you use two edge strips one front and one rear, the shelf is considerably stiffer. Also changing to a 1.75 height of the strip will also help.

Why not use solid oak for the shelves? It will be stronger than the plywood and at least around here cost competitive with the price of hardwood ply. You will have a bit more labor in gluing up the boards for your shelf width.

On a 8' tall bookcase If there is no back then I would think you would need the fixed center shelf to prevent the sides from bowing and the case from racking if you have all the shelves heavily loaded. If there is a fixed plywood back (even 1/4" thick), then the center shelf probably isn't needed.

Lee

Re: Bookshelves?

#6

JL

Re: Bookshelves?

JL

>The client is our church. It is a freestanding unit. The reason why they want a 4' x 8' is - that's what the old shelves are. All of the books are moderately heavy.

My preferences are for ~30" shelves using 5/4 edging. I'm going to try and talk them into narrower bookshelves.

Re: Bookshelves?

#7

JL

Re: I used the Sagulator...

JL

>that's why I'm putting the edge strips. I was more concerned with the bulging possibilities.

Re: Bookshelves?

#8

JL

Re: correction

JL

>I was concerned with bowing and racking. Even though I'm doing a 1/4" plywood back, I'd still prefer a fixed center shelf.

Re: Bookshelves?

#9

Re: Bookshelves?

Curly Smith

>I think Norm had an episode this year where he built bookcases for a law office. I could be wrong, but I think he used a 3/4" back panel and drilled at least two sets of holes for shelf supports in the back. The potential for sagging from the heavy load reduced by the edge banding at the front and the shelf supports at the back.

Re: Bookshelves?

#10

Just FYI

Dan Donaldson

>Blatent commercial ;-) The sagulator and a bunch of other calculators are listed on the links page along with a lot of other useful links. FWIW, a good many of the links given on the boards are there, and others are added as I get time. Take a look ;-)