Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

Baseboard Wood Filler?

Posts

Baseboard Wood Filler?

#1

Baseboard Wood Filler?

Bob Slocum

>What do you recommend to fill nail holes in painted baseboard? I've used spackling compound in the past, but had to repaint. Tried some white caulk, but not really satisified because the color/sheen is different than the painted surface. I'm painting first, then installing.

Bob

Re: Baseboard Wood Filler?

#2

Re: Baseboard Wood Filler?

Chuck in ND

>Bob, I think your going to have a hard time finding something that will be a perfect match and stay that way. As you know most caulks will yellow in time, and spackleing needs to be coated. When we do painted woodwork in homes it gets installed first, spackled, sanded, taped off, then sprayed. Thats what gets the best results for us.

Re: Baseboard Wood Filler?

#3

Re: Baseboard Wood Filler?

Barry Irby

>Bob, I think chuck is right. As builder I used to paint the house I built. We always installed the baseboard, filled the nail holes and then primed and painted. I used a glazing compound that was basically putty and it was oil based. Had to cover it with primer to avoid the oil bleeding through the latex paint.

Recently I painted a friend's house and replaced some interior trim. Found a tube of nail hole filler at Lowes. Don't know the name, but it was in the paint dept. and was sold for filling nail holes. A Plastic tube f goop with a sponge or foam application on it that was about an inch in diameter. It worked pretty well once you got the knack of using the applicator. Just press it tot he hole and squeeze a little and wipe with the applicator tip. The stuff in the tube seemed to be Spackle. Water based and latex covered it well.

Re: Baseboard Wood Filler?

#4

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Re: Baseboard Wood Filler?

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

>Bob, the others are on the right track, but they did leave out one minor detail. For the truly professional job, any painted woodwork (using "wood" loosely, of course) needs to have every seam, gap, joint, etc. caulked. Baseboard is caulked to the wall, casing is caulked to the wall and the window or door jamb, the jamb stops on the door jamb are caulked to the jamb, and, you get the picture. The downside is that once you've caulked all trim, both the walls and trim will have to be painted. If the walls are freshly painted, they can just be cut-in again.

For filling nail holes, there are many products out there, and if you start talking to painters, you'll have to talk to about a dozen before you hear something twice. Most of the time, I will use the lightweight spackle. Dries quick, sands easily (unless you leave it for weeks), but it does take two coats to cover if the paint is anything shinier than flat. I also use "Painter's Putty", which is made by several different companies, and is similar to glazing compound, but is harder to get the hole filled and can be painted with one heavy coat. My favorite is probably Crawford's Spackle. It comes in a metal quart can that is bright green. It seems like a cross between joint compound and vinyl spackle. It dries pretty quick, sands like joint compound and doesn't "flash" as bad as lightweight spackle (meaning it can be covered with one coat).

Jason (painter by day, and sometimes night)

Re: Baseboard Wood Filler?

#5

questions

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>On a repaint job using the same colors, which do you prefer to do first, trim or walls? What is used in a carpeted room to keep paint off carpet at baseboard floor junction?

Re: Baseboard Wood Filler?

#6

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Re: questions

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

>Trim first. If there's a significant difference between the wall and trim colors, we'll do the trim one day, then tape the top edge with 1" low-adhesion tape the next day to keep the roller spray off the trim (all paints spray, it's just a question of how much), plus it speeds up the cut-in (still needs to be cut-in somewhat carefully--if you load up the tape, it will wick around the edge of the tape). As for next to the carpet, I rely on a little bit of skill there, particulary if it's the same color. If it's a color change on the trim, then I'll use a wide drywall knife slipped under the base, mashing down the carpet, or I'll use a high-adhesion tape (3M green) and tape the carpet, trying to tuck ~1/8" under the base.

BTW, when it comes to taping (and painting), accuracy first, then speed. I've run so many miles (yes, miles) of tape, I can do a very straight line quickly and practically in my sleep.

Jason

Re: Baseboard Wood Filler?

#7

I agree......

Barry Irby

>I started to mention the thing about caulking everything to every thing, but that was not the question and I decided to keep my answer shorter than my usual babbling. Jason is exactly right. Caulk it all with a tube of caulk with the tip cut off about the least possible amount that will expose the hole in the nozzle and cut it about a forty five or maybe a sixty degree angle. If the caulking tube has the internal seal, use a piece of wire to punch it out. (Thin so as not to enlarge the hole). Once you get into this, it does not take long and will make a huge difference in the appearance of the final product. Make a tiny cove in every inside corner. If they are not smooth, you can use your finger to smooth them, but try to get them smooth right out of the gun, or your finger will get sore. Also does a good job of cutting infiltration (heat loss) around windows and doors. (Really) Be sure to use decent quality caulk and make sure it is "Paintable". (Paint will adhere to it.)

I'm sure Jason, who does this for a living will agree that painting is about 70 percent about the preparation, ten percent about the quality of the paint, and the rest is about applying the paint. They all count, but the quality of the paint and the skill of the applicator will never make up for poor prep work.

Re: Baseboard Wood Filler?

#9

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Re: I agree......

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

>I actually almost always finger-smooth my caulk. There's just no comparison in appearance and longer-term adhesion. The only time I have problems with wearing out my finger is when I'm doing a LOT of it in a short time period--like this past February when I did 4 new-construction student apartments totalling almost 7000 s.f. in 10 days (only the inital coat was on the walls and ceilings, I did the rest). Two of them were 3BR, two 4BR, and each bedroom had its own bathroom. Using the putty for filling took away some of my fingerprints, and after a while, I had to choose which finger I wanted to bleed while smoothing caulk...ugh... But that's just an extreme example. More typical is 2-3 of us caulking a new construction house that might be 2000-3000 s.f., and that won't even make my finger tender. Since the OP indicated that he had pre-painted his trim and only wanted to fill holes, I though I might point out what is expected in a "professional" paint job. It may not be important to him, but it could affect the value for resale.

Jason