Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

Red Oak for Workbench?

Posts

Red Oak for Workbench?

#1

Red Oak for Workbench?

Brint in Richmond, VA

>As part of our move-in last year, we took down a couple of trees, including a rather sizable red oak in our backyard. I explained to my wife that having it milled and air-dried on our property was substantially cheaper than buying it from a retailer, so I got the okay, and now I have a 4-foot-thick stickered pile of 5/4 measuring roughly 10x14 under cover out back (on top of cinderblocks and PT 4x4's, set on an old concrete slab set into the trees).

A couple of weeks ago I dropped by the cabinetmaker's shop in Colonial Williamsburg during one of our regular visits (my in-laws live there). I asked one of the craftsmen there and he said that while red oak would be fine for the base, he would not recommend it for the top of a workbench because it easily got "fuzzy" or "stringy." Not that I wouldn't LIKE a maple top -- but part of the rationale for milling the lumber was to avoid having to purchase lumber outside.

Does anyone have advice or experience on this topic? TIA --

Re: Red Oak for Workbench?

#2

Re: Red Oak for Workbench?

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>I think the Williamsburg guy's cabeza is fuzzy.

Clint

Re: Red Oak for Workbench?

#3

Re: Red Oak for Workbench?

steve mackay

>Oh, if I could only afford it ! Wich YOU can ! It'd be about like having a HUGE granite surface plate for a bench. SWEET ! Would you use oak suports to carry a load like that ? But then you've probably got enough for that also. Double Sweet ! And good look'n to boot.

Re: Red Oak for Workbench?

#4

Re: Red Oak for Workbench?

John McGaw

>My workbench is about ten years old now and is all red oak including the edge-laminated top. Nothing fuzzy or stringy about it that I've noticed. Sure is heavy but I guess that is a good thing 99.99% of the time.

Re: Red Oak for Workbench?

#5

it has worked fine for floors for centuries

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Unless you are a purist you will want to put a sheet of something on the bench to absorb spills and dings anyway. I use Masonit. In my mind anything that results in a heavy bench is acceptable.

Re: Red Oak for Workbench?

#6

Re: it has worked fine for floors for centuries

Jim

>Red Oak scrap finger jointed together in the middle with White Oak on the edges and the vise, 6 years and going strong, not pretty anymore though. Varithane floor finish and a card scraper to clean it up once and a while. I'ld do it again in a blink, a lot cheaper than Maple.


img

Re: Red Oak for Workbench?

#7

JL

Re: Red Oak for Workbench?

JL

>I like red oak - just make sure that it is well sealed - you don't want glue/stain getting into the oak.

Follow Bill's suggestion for a protective masonite top or put down some plastic film when gluing or staining.

If it was cut and stickered last year, it may not be dry enough yet.

Re: Red Oak for Workbench?

#8

Re: Red Oak for Workbench?

Barry Irby

>Brent, If I had the red oak, I would use it for a bench in a heart beat. The top of my lathe cabinet in a red oak "cutting board" I edge laminated out of some stuff I got from a local sawmill. Its getting stained and some slight wear but otherwise is fine. I don't think it was quite as dry as it should have been when I glued it. I have a crack hear and there, but nothing serious enough to consider remaking it. I live in Chester, just south of you in humid southside VA. I would check the MC of the oak before I used it. There are a number of ways you can do this. A moisture meter if you have one. You can cut a piece and weigh the small piece on an accurate set of scales (postal scales), then store it in your house or shop for a few weeks and weigh it again. If it does not lose any more weight, it has reached equilibrium and should be good enough to use. Your scales will tell you how big a piece to cut. For mine, I would cut a piece about 6' by a foot. The bigger the piece, the more change you will get. I would think this would be a good way to do this, as the bench has to live in your shop and you want the wood to be at equilibrium with the shop. Another way is to go over to WoodWeb and read up on how to take a sample, weigh it, bake it in the oven and then weigh it again. That is the more accurate and academic or old school way to do it, but leaves you to decide if the wood will thrive in the shop. Not sure, but I don't think they had kilns back in the day in Colonial Williamsburg, so I think that answers the question about whether Air dried is good enough. you just need to be sure yours is dry.

I would use the red oak in a split second.

Re: Red Oak for Workbench?

#9

Re: Red Oak for Workbench? *LINK*

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>If you want a piece of furniture, red oak works fine. It's moderately hard, it's heavy and it'll last longer than you.

However, I wouldn't worry about whether if fuzzes. Before you do anything else, read Chris Schwarz's book. He used southern yellow pine. That's got to be fuzzier than red oak.

Bruce


The Workbench book