Red Oak for Workbench?
Brint in Richmond, VA
>As part of our move-in last year, we took down a couple of trees, including a rather sizable red oak in our backyard. I explained to my wife that having it milled and air-dried on our property was substantially cheaper than buying it from a retailer, so I got the okay, and now I have a 4-foot-thick stickered pile of 5/4 measuring roughly 10x14 under cover out back (on top of cinderblocks and PT 4x4's, set on an old concrete slab set into the trees).
A couple of weeks ago I dropped by the cabinetmaker's shop in Colonial Williamsburg during one of our regular visits (my in-laws live there). I asked one of the craftsmen there and he said that while red oak would be fine for the base, he would not recommend it for the top of a workbench because it easily got "fuzzy" or "stringy." Not that I wouldn't LIKE a maple top -- but part of the rationale for milling the lumber was to avoid having to purchase lumber outside.
Does anyone have advice or experience on this topic? TIA --




