Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

The case against hot hide glue - Part I

Posts

The case against hot hide glue - Part I

#1

The case against hot hide glue - Part I

GolfSteve in Calgary

>The case against hot hide glue - Part I

As much as I would like to like hot hide glue I want to poke at Stephen's obsession with boiled cow hides a bit :-)

1) It's a royal pain to use. No way to skirt around this by saying it just takes a baby bottle warmer sitting on the bench, etc. It is a royal pain compared to liquid hide glue or titebond. Epoxy is the only thing that is more of a pain in the butt than hot hide glue just because epoxy is so hard to clean up.

2) The wife really doesn't like me using the baby bottle warmer to heat boiled cow hides in my dirty shop. Somehow she knows I've used the bottle warmer even when I try to hide it.

3) The glue sets up way too quickly - it requires you to completely change how glue ups are done - eg. when assembling a mitred frame you almost have to assemble and glue one corner at a time. If you try and assembly all four pieces (and the panel) you will have a disaster. Even with a hot shop and pre-warmed pieces, you only have 30 to 60 seconds to get the whole thing assembled, squared up and clamped. That's way tooo short a time.

4) You have to pay a fortune to heat your shop to unbearably warm conditions in order to delay the glue set-up for several seconds.

5) The first batch I got smelled really bad (must have been bad). Newer batches smell like roast beef, making me hungry when I should be concentrating on my glue-up.

Don't get me wrong, I'm really trying to like hot hide glue, but it just ain't working for me. I like how it cleans up nicely and doesn't interfere with finishes. I like how it is repairable and can be temporarily released by heat and hot water. I hate how terribly fast it sets up - which makes it almost impossible to use for anything that needs a bit of adjustment during glue-up (eg. squaring up a frame).

Hot hide glue has almost disasterized more of my glue-ups than any other factor, except for the one that my first year computer science professor used to spout every time someone asked a question�"because you're screwing up!"

On the plus side for hide glue, I do like Patrick Edward's Old Brown Liquid Hide Glue. It is just as easy to use as PVA, although it sets up quite a bit faster than PVA. On the negative side it is a pain having to mail-order your glue across an international border, so next time I'll give Franklin's a try just because I can buy it locally.

See Part II for more about hammer veneering in dry climates. I wanted to keep that as a separate discussion because it is the more serious part of my questions about hot hide glue.

Best wishes,

Steven (who also does not like PVA glue, doesn't like epoxy, and hates cyanoacrylate (which also does not work well in dry climates))

Re: The case against hot hide glue - Part I

#2

JL

Re: The case against hot hide glue - Part I

JL

>I'm not Stephen - and I do use a number of other glues including Titebond, Titebond II, Titebond III, epoxy, CA glue as well as hide glue.

I've used liquid hide glue as well as hot hide glue. I agree with you, hot hide can be a PITA to use. I have a nice glue pot (not a baby bottle warmer).

I'll argue about it setting up that quickly - I usually have about a 15-20 minute working time for hot and about a 30 minute for liquid. I keep my shop at about 62-64 degrees in the winter and it seems to work ok for me (but I usually use rabbit hide glue).

I typically dry fit all of my spindles and then have the ends pre-split. My wedges are ready and pre-sized. I just glue and go. It typically takes about 20 minutes to put a hoop on a loop-back chair and about 30 minutes for a continuous arm.

Why do I use hide glue (either liquid or hot)? I've had several "interesting" failures while putting on a hoop. I'd rather have something I can remove with a heat gun or steam so I can just remove the hoop as opposed to completely reworking the piece.

Re: The case against hot hide glue - Part I

#3

A case for hot hide glue

John K Jordan

>I haven't kept up but I'd be surprised if the recommendations have changed but when I rebuilt a 50-year-old player piano, hot hide glue was the ONLY glue to use on bellows cloth, striker bellows, and any other part that may need to be dismantled again years later for re-rebuilding.

I heated the glue in a small jar in a old pan of water on an ancient hot plate. I disassembled the piano with the help of an old clothes iron and a putty knife. (The project took about a month, working every evening and weekends.)

JKJ

Re: The case against hot hide glue - Part I

#4

Re: The case against hot hide glue - Part I

Wayne Carson "TX"

>if you add a little urea to the glue it will give you more time to work it. There are several receips on the net for using urea.

Re: The case against hot hide glue - Part I

#5

Re: The case against hot hide glue - Part I

GolfSteve in Calgary

>30 minutes working time!!! No way, I've even played with adding urea to the mix, and with my shop at ~70�F and the parts preheated over an electric heater, the hide glue gels up in under two minutes to the point where you can't clamp the parts together to get a nice thin glue line - the glue is so gelled up it holds the parts apart.

The glue is the 220 gram strength stuff from Lee Valley. I also have some stronger stuff from a violin supplier but I don't use it because it sets up so fast.

With liquid hide glue I'd say I've got about five minutes working time.

Re: The case against hot hide glue - Part I

#6

That might be part of the problem

Dan Donaldson

>The higher the gram number, the faster it sets up. The 220 is awful high for woodworking. You should try something in the 150-170 range and see if that helps.

Re: The case against hot hide glue - Part I

#7

Jack Guzman from Maine

The case for hide glue information

Jack Guzman from Maine

>Steve,my experience with hot hide glue has been similar to yours. I build clock cases.The first batch I tried worked great.It was great for getting small trim details to stick without clamping. The second time I tried I experienced the quickly setting glue holding parts apart by their thickness. I'm going to try again and start from scratch with new glue. Try to figure out what was different but I need a reference,more information. So..Stephen Shepherd,when will you finish your book?---Jack

Re: The case against hot hide glue - Part I

#8

Well, Part I

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>Steve,

Those are all of the reasons I like hot hide glue! Yes it can take a bit of fetteling but I think it is worth the effort.

The odor problem probably comes from the glue you are using. If the new glue has an odor it is probably bone glue, I avoid pearl glue and go for ground hide glue. If the glue goes off it can develop and odor.

Also as Dan mentioned the gram strength you are using is too high, you can get by with adding more water to decrease its viscosity and increase open time. But it is better to get a more appropriate gram strength glue.

I have used Lee Valley's Liquid Fish Glue and it is great stuff, long shelf life and great initial tack. It has been deodorized and has the same base of hide glue, hydrolyzed collagen.

Old shops had glue rooms that were heated where the gluing can be done at a leasurely albeit warm pace. I will warm up pieces by the stove prior to gluing if the weather is cold.

Jack, the book is in its final stages, the preface and forward are being written by others as we speak.

Stephen

Re: The case against hot hide glue - Part I

#9

Mixing Hide Glue

Wayne Carson "TX"

>Here is a link for mixing the hide glue

http://www.bearmeadow.com/build/materials/glue/html/glue-measure.html

Re: The case against hot hide glue - Part I

#10

Actually I'm using 260 gram strength glue

GolfSteve in Calgary

>I mis-remembered the gram strength...

From Lee Valley's web-site: "Our granular hide glue is a very strong one (rated 260g� Bloom strength) with a correspondingly short open time; it is good for uncomplicated assemblies where strength is of paramount importance.

Pearl hide glue, which also comes in dry form and is used the same way as granular, is not as strong (rated 150g Bloom strength) but takes longer to gel. With the longer working time, it is better for applications like veneering where you need time to fit, but where high strength is not required."

So you're saying that I should use the 150 gram strength stuff for my structural joints as well as for hammer veneering? Then if I add some urea (say 8 wt%) I can further increase the open time?

Re: The case against hot hide glue - Part I

#11

Re: Well, Part I

GolfSteve in Calgary

>Thanks Stephen...

I'm using Lee Valley's 260 gram strength glue and I find it sets up way too fast. Dan recommended that I switch to the 150 gram strength stuff. What strength would you recommend for general glue-ups of joinery?

How much working time would you expect from Patrick Edwards liquid hide glue? I usually put the liquid hide glue into my glue pot (because the glue is gelled up at room temperature), so the glue would be 65�C/150�F, and my shop is usually around 15-20�C/60-75�F.

Thanks for the advice,

Steven

Re: The case against hot hide glue - Part I

#12

Re: Well, Part I

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>Steve,

Old Brown Glue only needs to be heated to blood heat 37C/98F, those are the only two scales I know. Doesn't need to be as hot as liquid hide glue, which will make it very thin. As long as you can get it out of the bottle and spread on the both sides of the joint so it is 'wet' then it will work.

I use a lower gram strength glue 192 (mid-range) for all gluing including structure. High gram strength is for pianos and harps where you really need the strength.

You can add salt to the high gram strength glue to help with open time, it should be sea salt not iodized salt. There are other chemicals which will also effect open time. You can even add sugar to make the hide glue flexible.

Stephen

Re: The case against hot hide glue - Part I

#13

Re: Actually I'm using 260 gram strength glue

Dan Donaldson

>At 260, I think that it is a wonder that you get anything together at all. ;-) The 150 stuff would be a lot better for what you are doing. Others that know more can chime in, but "strength" is relative, and 150 should be more than strong enough for normal woodworking applications.