>We are thinking of puting in a new deck this spring and have a simple question. thinking about using that new fangeled man made product to keep maintance cost down. I went to the borg and the have TREX and the house brand Veranda. basically the same stuff. but the Veranda is about a 1/8 inch thinner or more didn't measure but by sight I could see it was thinner. I'm a big boy and wonder if there will be a noticable flex to this stuff even if the Joist are on 16" crnters? Don't want to cheap out but don't want to spend money not needed either. So has any one used both? does any one care to comment on either. got a nice 10% off coupon and 1 year free financing I think it is time to stimulate the economy. money I make in intrest instead of spending my cash now might buy a good steak dinner and a six pack or two to christen it with. Thanks Ernie
>Some friends of ours live in an upscale subdivision. They have Trex decks. Their decks are a few years old and still look great. They have a good "foot feel" and I didn't notice any sag (16" on center) - but I'm only ~ 200 lbs.
I'm thinking of replacing my front porch/deck with the Trex when the time comes.
>Ernie, I have a non answer. I don't know the difference between the two products you asked about.
I guess you know that a number of these products have been recalled. I believe Trex was one of the early brands and essentially the entire first generation failed and had to be replaced. I saw a different brand just a month ago that had failed. It looked like wood that had been set on fire, put out, and then painted a lovely shade of tan.
Yesterday I saw some that had splits at the ends of the planks at each screw.
I am turning into an old fuddy duddy and would not buy this stuff at this time. I would suggest you be very careful about buying it and be sure you follow the installation guide very carefully and be sure you get the warranty and get it in writing.
>I put Trex down about 4 years ago and it looks like new. One part is the main entrance to the house so it gets shovelled in the winter (plastic snow shovel) and gets lots of sand tracked on it. One part is in the hot sun and the other portion is mostly in shade.
One problem, primarily with the shady section, is mold will start to show. I have heard they now use a different forumlation to avoid this problem. It actually is trivial to deal with though, I just go out and spray some deck cleaner on it, wait a minute or so and then hose it off. Do it about 2-3X per year. The company says the mold will not harm the material if left untouched and all decks should be cleaned anyway.
The Trex brochure said that 16" OC was OK for my boards but I put them 12" OC. The incremental cost for my deck was very little to do this - I had read various things saying 12" gave a better job. The stuff doesn't have much structural strength and even with 12" OC it is not "concrete floor solid" on a hot day. I had some 20' pieces and picking them up was fun, not only is it very heavy but when you lift in the middle the ends will still touch the ground.
>You may want to check the local lumber yards. There are even more brands (even different levels within Trex brand) and some look nicer than others. Costs at the local lumberyard were very close to the borg, but included delivery (important with 16' and 20' pieces even though I have a full size pickup). I honestly don't remember what brand I used anymore, but it looks nice and has held up well. Be careful driving screws too close to the edge as it will split a chunk off. Otherwise, easy and quick to install. My kids have spilled a bunch of stuff on it that baked on and there are a few stains, but they are not extrememly objectionable. Don't use your good Forrest blade on the CMS as it will wind up dull, especially if you use vinyl railing also.
>LOML liked the color of the Veranada material when we redid our front deck 2 years ago It has come through two winters and summers so far and looks great. We get a bit of green algae because it is on the north side of the house, but that washes right off with a little bleach and water. I used a hidden fastener system, that was bit of a pain to install, but the final effect was nice. A deck with no fasteners on the surface. HD can also order thin boards that match the Veranda for covering the supporting frame. We are looking at remodeling our back deck with the same material. Veranda recommends 12" centers and it seems plenty stury at that spacing, no noticeable springiness under my 220#.
>I have built two decks with Trex. One in Tennessee 11 years ago and one in Indiana 7 years old. Saw the TN deck a couple of months ago and it looks as solid as the day I left. The Indiana deck is great. I used SS screws, predrilled the holes. Used 16" centers for support. Trex has much higher head capacity than wood and is thus HOT on a clear summer day. Too hot for bare feet. It is very flexible when it is hot out so be careful with long lengths. This stuff cleans up easily. I went with the uncolored version in TN and it weathered to a nice grey. Got the brown version for IN and it is now the same color as when I started. If you make sure your deck joists don't gather water you will have a problem free deck for a long while. I used SS Cable Rail for the rail system with cedar 6X6 for posts. Looks very nice.
>If you live in a metro area there may be a plastic recycler making deck boards. As I understand it, it's primarily made of recycled milk containers. As plastic is heavy the recyclers try to make marketable products as close to the source and potential customer as possible. These may not be the same as or as good as but then, there may be no difference. A check of the Yellow Pages and a few phone calls may give you an at source purchase of what the lumber yard is selling. I expect you would have to transport it yourself.
>Twas told by my local lumber store that the biggest problem they've had with plastic decks is that folks butt the planks together during installation. With wet treated lumber, this is ok, as the wood shrinks and now has room to move. With plastic, there is no shrinkage, to speak of, but there is expansion. Butted planks in the bright hot sun will expand and buckle. Follow manufacturers installation instructions.
>I installed one using Trex. No problems with 16" centers, but I predrilled every hole and used whatever spacing was recommended. So far, it looks fine. This is not stuctural lumber though, so be sure to keep to the manufacturer's spacing recommendations. If you use thinner material, I would expect it would require closer spacing. We added a couple of joist supports to try and head off sag. On hot days, pick it up on the edges, not on the flat...
I too have been wanting to replace the decking on my existing deck and researched the heck out of composite decking materials.
Just to name a few brand names that I looked into:
Trex
Eon (Home Depot - special order)
Veranda (Home Depot)
Evergrain
Timber Tech
AZEK
ProCell
GeoDeck
....want some more........ :-)
1) You have to follow the individual companies "specs" on spacing of supports.
2) Some companies will actually calculate the entire project for you and tell you exactly what you need based on the particular product from thier line. (see Eon decking webiste http://www.eonoutdoor.com/)
3) Most companies offer different thicknesses. Exam: 5/4 or 1 1/2.
My deck was built like a Sherman tank. Two by eights complete the sub-structure with 2 x 6's as the decking material. If I were to put down 5/4 material (3/4 true thickness) I'd have a gap where the siding comes down onto the deck. I wouldn't want that. I looked at Evergrain and Eon because they carry the 1 1/2 and 1 1/4 products. One area of my deck is 20 x 20. Decking is single length 20 "footers". There's about 35-40 of these on just this one area. The price of one Evergrain 2 x 6 is $50-$60 FOR ONE 20 FOOT BOARD priced locally. To replace the deck in just this one area (no handrailings, etc.) would cost me over $2,000. The other half of my deck is 35 x 12 and the boards are run diagonally in this section. These means cut-offs. This adds cost to this area.
I think you see where I'm going with this......to just replace the decking would cost me in the neighborhood of over $5,000. And...that's if I do the work. I can't afford that as much as I would like to stimulate the economy. :-) My plan is to flip over the 2 x 6's I have and get a few more years of use out of the other side. This can be hard to do with 5/4 wood.
I've spoke with many a builder, many of my friends and neighbors who have composite decks and they love em'. Yes, mold issues occur, 5/4 decking will give a little under the extreme heat and heavy loads. It's all a matter of what your tastes are and if your wallet can afford the steak dinner. :-)
Good luck with your endeavour. Let us all know how it turns out.