Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

Load bearing wall ?

Posts

Load bearing wall ?

#1

Load bearing wall ?

Dustmaker Mike

>Ok now I have helped build a few houses and understand the differances in a load bearing wall and a non load bearing wall on a single story home. Here is the problem I live in a two story house with a full basement so I know I don't know what I am doing. So my question is who do I call to make sure of what I need to do to safely remove it. Who should I look for in the yellow pages or maybe where else should I look? TIA Ya gota love it when the wife ask how hard will it be to remove that wall. I am not sure what is next but I bet I am going to be remodeling a few rooms.

Re: Load bearing wall ?

#2

That's what they invented these things for.....

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>Happy Woodworking!


img

Re: Load bearing wall ?

#3

Re: Load bearing wall ?

Justin Szeliga

>You would need to talk to an experienced carpenter or consult with an architect or engineer. A carpenter with good framing experience can tell you whether a wall is load bearing or not & give some ideas as to what needs to be done to remove a load bearing wall. To determine whether a wall is load bearing you can just check to see if there is a straight pathway from the attic ceiling joists to a foundation in the ground below. In a full basement the presence of lally columns supporting a beam on which the joists of the floor above rest is the easiest way to tell what is a bearing wall & what is not.

Another way is to just do what you want, take out what you want & see if the floor above sags. A foolish, though time honored (dishonored?) approach.

Peace

JJS

Re: Load bearing wall ?

#4

Jesper, Denmark

Easy......

Jesper, Denmark

>Start taking the wall down. If it starts creeking, put a column under a beam.

If you can get into the ceiling above it and there are joists ending on that wall, you'd better leave it alone or plan to replace it with a beam.

Re: Load bearing wall ?

#5

Re: Load bearing wall ?

Keith Newton, LR, Arkansas------WebKitFormBoundary

>A good re-model contractor should know what is involved. Even load bearing wall can be removed, and replaced by headers that transfer the load to the ends and down through the cripples that support both ends. Care should be taken to make sure that the ends are over good support below those points.

Before you get to tearing into the wall though, you should think about what is above, and on both sides of the wall. Wet areas, like kitchen, baths or laundry could mean that there is plumbing coming down through that wall. Those things are not nearly as easy to move around.

There will also likely be some wiring passing through the wall, especially if it is near the service panel.

You can buy a stud-finder which is a little electronic device that you hold against the wall, and slide along. It will light up as it crosses each stud. Those are normally 16" apart. I think they sell for under $20. If it lights up closer than that, then you should expect something else such as plumbing.

You could do as suggested above, and just tear it out, and see what happens, but you may get your name added to the Darwin Awards list. I normally prop the ceiling up on both sides of the wall before taking all of the studs out, and getting the new header in.

Re: Load bearing wall ?

#6

Re: Easy......

Grant Smith

>Mike,

Generally, load bearing walls are perpendicular to the floor joists. Exceptions to this rule are walls surrounding stairways, and walls beneath heavy items above, such as a brick fireplace. Load bearing walls are also usually about centered in a structure.

So, start in the attic. Look to see if you have trusses or site built rafters. If you have trusses then they usually can clear span from end to end, though if they have vertical members in them or reinforced areas, that usually means they are supported by a wall or post beneath.

Look for a beam down the center of the basement, often hidden by a boxed in area in a finished basement. It is often parallel to and very close to the heating ducts if you have forced air heat. This beam is supporting the joists above, CAN'T be removed safely. A wall parallel to and immediately above this joist is usually supporting the joists on the second floor. This beam and wall are generally about centered in an average sized home. Large homes.. say over 24' deep can have more than one beam. Homes with a shape other than rectangular can have several. Once you find this beam and any walls directly on top of that beam, then you usually have located the bearing walls. Walls perpendicular to this beam are not usually load bearing, except sometimes in areas where those walls cross the center beam or in cases where there is an upstairs fireplace or other heavy building feature.

All of this is generalization, and NOT something that you should take action on in terms of removing a wall.

It would also help to know how old the home is and what the basic style of home is.

I suggest you contact an experienced framing carpenter or builder and ask their help.

FWIW,

Grant in Iowa

Re: Load bearing wall ?

#7

Re: Calling a knowledgeable person.....

Ray Carson - Lawrenceville, NJ

>I can't agree more with this post. I work for a structural engineering outfit and have been drafting for 20 years. I'm sure Justin was kidding when he posted, "Another way is to just do what you want, take out what you want & see if the floor above sags. A foolish, though time honored (dishonored?) approach. :-)

You can start by removing sheetrock, plaster, etc. from the walls and ceiling as Jesper stated and find out exactly what is buried in the wall and ceiling.

DO NOT REMOVE ANY STUDS until you know for sure whether or not it's load bearing or not. Usually the ceiling / floor joists will intersect the wall perpendicularly.

If your in doubt call a GOOD carpenter or call a structural Engineer. Get a second opinion if the site visit is of no charge. You can try an Architect but it can be hit or miss.

Grant made some excellent points in his post about houses of irregular shape and houses with trusses, etc. Good advice Grant.

I would come by in a heartbeat Mike if I knew where you live and it was within close proximity to my home. Can you take some pictures of your house and it's interior where you plan to do this demo? Maybe I can help a little by looking at some pictures. We can go off website and handle this with personal email too so we don't clog up WC space.

Good luck Mike and let me know if there is anything more I can help you with. Bearing walls should not be taken lightly.

Siincerely,

Ray

Re: Load bearing wall ?

#8

Re: Load bearing wall ?

Barry Irby

>As a Home Inspector, I could figure out which of your walls is load bearing. However, I have a degree in Building Construction and was a Class A licensed contractor and framed many houses before I started doing inspections. I'm not sure all Home Inspectors are created equal, but you might be able to find one locally with good experience that could help you. You could go to the web site for the American Society of Home Inspectors (ASHI.org) and the first thi9ng that pops up is a locator. Just put your zip code in and it will give you a list.

The other posters have given you good advice. Generally, walls parallel to the joists are not lad bearing and some of the ones perpendicular to them may be. The walls near the center of the house are more likely to be load bearing.

Something no one has mentioned it the location of the plumbing. It is possible to remove the walls, even load bearing ones, and some of them are simple or even easy to remove. The main plumbing stack or even minor stacks can be much more difficult to move. Wiring can be a problem also, but is often easier than plumbing.

Re: Load bearing wall ?

#9

Question

Tony - Memphis

>We live in a typical modern day suburb of Memphis. Down here, the typical construction is 2x4 walls with a roof with a pitch that birds can't even walk up. My house is a single story. When you go into my attic and look, there are no interior supports for the roof. It's a HUGE volume up there. Nice for getting around, but seems like a waste of material. Anyway, I was arguing with a buddy here at work about it. I was thinking since it is a single story and there are no vertical members inside the exterior walls that support the roof, that I have no load bearing walls other than the exterior walls. Is that true? There aren't even any walls that go from outside wall to outside wall. So, my theory was that I could remove every interior wall I wanted and nothing would happen. There aren't even any cross members in the roof. Amazes me that they can/do build them that way, but every house around here is the same. One thing I have noticed is that our roof is very noisy. The daily heat cycles and/or a good wind moves it quite a bit.

Tony

Re: Load bearing wall ?

#10

Re: Question - possibilities

Ray Carson - Lawrenceville, NJ

>"I was thinking since it is a single story and there are no vertical members inside the exterior walls that support the roof, that I have no load bearing walls other than the exterior walls. Is that true?"

I'm not sure I understand this statement. Unless you have 4 posts in the corners with huge headers between them, then you should have some sort of "stud" at a given spacing. I don't know without looking at your house. :-)

"There aren't even any walls that go from outside wall to outside wall."

Are you saying there aren't any interior walls? It's an open floor plan?

"So, my theory was that I could remove every interior wall I wanted and nothing would happen."

This contridicts the above statement. "There aren't even any walls that go from outside wall to outside wall." Again, I'm not sure I understand. Just trying to answer your question Tony that's all.

"There aren't even any cross members in the roof. Amazes me that they can/do build them that way, but every house around here is the same. One thing I have noticed is that our roof is very noisy. The daily heat cycles and/or a good wind moves it quite a bit."

It is possible that the roofs are built without cross-bracing, knee walls, or a "truss-like" roof rafter system. If this is the case then yes, your roof will deflect and move with the wind, snow loads, heat and cold exchange, etc.

You said a bird couldn't even walk up the slope. I'm guessing that your describing a very sharp pitch in your roof. If your house is square with this kind of roof, then it sounds very much like a Cape Cod style or Bungalow house. If this is the case then your bearing walls are the ones where the rafters meet or intersect the walls. You could very well span the entire width of your house with a single piece of lumber or engineered wood product. TJI's for example. Then yes you could possibly have NO interior bearing walls.

I'm hypothesizing a lot here because I don't know your house, it's construction, year it was built, location in Tenn. etc. You could have some new type of construction that I'm not aware of.

I'm curious and would like to see the house your describing. ???

Sincerely,

Ray

Re: Load bearing wall ?

#11

I live in Kent Ohio

Dustmaker Mike

>Looking at it and thinking about it, this is a load bearing wall. It is the middle floor between the basement and the second floor. I looked in the basement and the center support runs under the wall I want to remove. There is not a wall on the second floor that matchs it but I bet the floor joist for the second floor meet on top of it.

Now I have to find someone that can tell me what I can and can not do to support the second floor if I open up this wall. I know there is no plubming or electric in it so that is the easy part. Thanks for the link I will check out the local folks and see if they can at least make sure the house don't fall.

Re: Load bearing wall ?

#12

Re: Question

Barry Irby

>I agree with Ray. I too am a little confused by your description.

Lets say your house is a rectangle. The roof runs from end to end so that from the street you are looking at one side of the roof and from the back yard, the other side. On each end, you have a gable or triangle that sits on top of the end wall and fills in the space up to the roof. A very simple rectangular rancher.

Your attic is tall in the middle and low in the front and back. No interior pieces like the braces in trusses than kill the usefulness of the attic. Locally, we call this a "stick built roof".

If All that is true, and I guessed or reasoned it out correctly, The front and back wall of your house are bearing walls and they carry or bear all the weight of the roof and:

If you have no interior bearing walls they bear the weight of the ceiling as well. Again, locally this would be unusual. Truss roofs could easily span from the front to back wall and you could build houses with no interior bearing partitions or beams, but in stick built roofs it is ordinary for the ceiling joists to reach about half way across the house and rest on a beam or partition that runs parallel to the front and back walls. With stick built roofs, the problem is that the ceiling joists are seldom strong enough to span the 24 or 26 or more feet from front to rear. As Ray mentioned, it would be fairly easy, but somewhat more expensive to do it with the various man-made beams that are available now known as Lvl (Laminated Veneer Lumber) or Truss Joists. So, because LVL have only been available for a few years and because it's cheaper to provide interior walls for the ceiling joists to rest on, builders usually opt for the cheap way out and reserve the LVL's for places where their superior spanning characteristics pay off.

So, go in your attic and look at your Ceiling joists. If they are ordinary 2X6's or 2X8's and not made of OSB looking material of plywood looking material, check near the center of your house and see if they don't over lap each other over the top of a wall. There might be a beam over a space like a family room or master bedroom that allowed the builder to omit the wall in that area. Tech beam might be a "flitch plate" which is a piece of steel about eight inches wide and a half inch thick sandwiched between two piece of wood or it might be an LVL or two.

In any case, if you have lad bearing walls in a rancher, they most probably are parallel to the front and back walls and near the center. Walls that run parallel to the end walls and unlikely to be load bearing.

If your description of the attic is correct, none of the weight of the roof bears on interior walls and only part of the weight of the ceiling could.

While you are in the attic you may find the ceiling joists are not ordinary lumber and that they are the man made stuff and do indeed span all the way across. You may also be able to tell if there is a significant amount of wiring and plumbing in the wall.

Now that you have your homework assignment, go look in the attic and tell us what you see.

Re: Load bearing wall ?

#13

Re: Load bearing wall ?

charlie belden

>Man do I empathize. I WAS married to a woman who, when it came to remodeling, was not constrained in any way by facts and physics. "Because that's a load bearing wall", "Because there's an 1 1/4" galvanized vent pipe in the middle of the wall you want opened up" or "Because that will required running all new copper pipe, drain line - AND - there's no way to vent that sink without some MAJOR plumbing work, which will require restuccoing the entire back of the house" - were not valid reasons for NOT making her wild hare idea a reality.

And how do you deal with a person who says "just slide that hole - through this exterior wall - over a foot and the problem's solved" or "Why don't we (meaning YOU) move the kitchen over there - and then figure out where the stuff that's "over there" can go?"

Sometimes the best answer is "Call a few contractors and lets get some estimates - dollars and time" instead of "Yes dear.". For some reason, wives seem to hear a contractor when HE/SHE says - "well that will add to the cost and add time to the schedule - by about this amount."

Re: Load bearing wall ?

#14

Attics in the south and balloons. *LINK*

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>I too was amazed at the attic space in houses down here. I figured that the larger the attic space the bigger the buffer for heat in the summer. All I know is that attics get to over 150�F ... actually measured it ;).... in the summer here.

Your question reminded me of different framing methods and the on that sticks in my mind, only because of the name, is "balloon framing". How it got it's name is funny.

Anyways, I found this article interesting, that explains a few things about different framing methods.

Happy Woodworking!


http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Balloon_framing#Ballo

Re: Load bearing wall ?

#15

Re: Question - possibilities

Tony - Memphis

>Sorry, I didn't make things more clear. What I meant was that there are no vertical members beyond the exterior walls that support the roof. The rafters run from the exterior wall to the peak with nothing supporting them. The other thing I was trying to describe is that there are no interior walls that run from exterior wall to exterior wall (straigh across that might be tying the exterior walls together). Its more like a maze? I'm sure the joists help keep the exterior walls from bowing out. There are some places where they meet.

Tony

Re: Load bearing wall ?

#16

Re: I live in Kent Ohio

Ken Garlock, Collin County Texas

>Hi Mike. What you want to do affects the structural integrity of the building. In most if not all areas, that will require a building permit from local foobah that worries about those things. Since they would have to pass the work, I would call them in and see what they will pass. With that in hand, you can proceed to find a contractor that would do the work according to the inspectors requirements.

I guess I have been watching too many Holmes on Homes programs, but this seems to be a case where the city/county inspector is your friend.

Best of luck with your project,

Ken (who grew up in Akron)